3 Best Reel Mowers for Cutting Tall Grass That Old Farmers Trust
Discover the 3 top reel mowers that tackle tall grass effortlessly. Our expert review covers eco-friendly options with advanced blade technology for pristine lawn care results.
Why it matters: Your overgrown lawn doesn’t have to mean firing up a gas-powered beast or dealing with cord tangles from electric mowers.
What’s happening: Reel mowers have evolved beyond basic push-and-hope models to tackle taller grass with surprising efficiency while keeping your yard work eco-friendly and virtually silent.
The bottom line: We’ve researched the top reel mowers that actually cut through thick grass without leaving you exhausted or your lawn looking like a battlefield.
|
|
|
|
$128.84
|
$279.66
|
$89.99
|
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
What Makes a Reel Mower Ideal for Tall Grass
Not all reel mowers can handle overgrown lawns effectively. The right models combine specific mechanical features with proper cutting geometry to slice through taller grass without bogging down or leaving uneven results.
Understanding Reel Mower Mechanics
Reel mowers cut grass using a scissor-like action between rotating blades and a fixed bottom blade. This clean cutting method works best when the reel spins fast enough to maintain momentum through dense grass. Quality models feature precision-ground blades that stay sharp longer and 5-7 blade configurations that provide multiple cutting opportunities per revolution, ensuring tall grass gets caught and cut rather than pushed down.
Key Features for Tackling Tall Grass
Look for reel mowers with 16-inch or wider cutting decks and self-sharpening blade systems. Wider decks reduce the number of passes needed through thick areas, while self-sharpening technology maintains cutting efficiency as you work. Ball bearing wheels and ergonomic handles become essential when pushing through resistant tall grass, reducing fatigue and improving maneuverability around obstacles.
Height Adjustment Capabilities
Effective tall grass cutting requires precise height control ranging from 0.5 to 3 inches. Single-lever height adjustment systems let you quickly adapt to varying grass conditions across your lawn. Start with higher settings for initial cuts, then gradually lower the deck height over multiple mowing sessions to achieve your desired lawn height without shocking the grass or overwhelming the mower’s cutting capacity.
Great States 415-16 16-Inch Reel Mower
The Great States 415-16 stands out as a solid choice for tackling taller grass with its traditional design and reliable cutting mechanism.
Specifications and Build Quality
You’ll find the Great States 415-16 features a sturdy steel construction with a 16-inch cutting width and 5-blade reel system. The mower weighs 29 pounds and offers cutting heights from 1/2 inch to 2-1/4 inches through a single-lever adjustment system. Its powder-coated finish resists rust and wear.
Performance on Tall Grass
This mower handles grass up to 4 inches tall effectively when you maintain proper blade sharpness and cutting technique. You’ll need to make multiple passes for best results on overgrown areas. The 5-blade configuration provides clean cuts without tearing or browning grass tips.
Pros and Cons
Pros: Affordable pricing, easy height adjustment, quiet operation, and no fuel or electricity requirements make it budget-friendly.
Cons: Requires more physical effort than powered alternatives, struggles with thick weeds, and needs regular blade maintenance for optimal performance on challenging terrain.
Fiskars StaySharp Max Reel Mower
This manual reel mower delivers powerful cutting performance without gas, oil, or cords. The InertiaDrive Reel provides twice the cutting power, and the StaySharp system eliminates blade sharpening.
The Fiskars StaySharp Max stands out with its innovative blade technology that maintains cutting performance longer than traditional reel mowers. You’ll find this mower particularly effective for taller grass situations where consistency matters most.
Advanced Cutting Technology
The StaySharp Max features precision-ground, hardened steel blades that resist dulling through extended use on challenging terrain. Its 18-inch cutting width combines with an advanced 5-blade reel system to deliver clean cuts on grass up to 4 inches tall. You’ll appreciate the momentum-driven cutting action that powers through thick growth without the blade binding issues common in lesser models.
Ease of Use and Maneuverability
Ergonomic design makes this mower surprisingly comfortable during extended cutting sessions, with a lightweight frame that won’t exhaust you. The single-lever height adjustment system lets you adapt quickly to varying grass conditions across your lawn. Large 10-inch wheels provide excellent traction and stability, while the reversible grass chute accommodates both side discharge and rear collection preferences.
Pros and Cons
Pros: Self-sharpening blade system reduces maintenance, wide cutting deck covers ground efficiently, superior build quality ensures longevity.
Cons: Higher price point than basic models, heavier weight requires more effort than ultra-light alternatives, blade adjustment requires occasional fine-tuning for optimal performance.
American Lawn Mower Company 1204-14
The American Lawn Mower Company 1204-14 delivers commercial-grade performance for homeowners tackling overgrown lawns. You’ll find this 14-inch reel mower handles thick grass better than most budget models while maintaining the quiet operation you expect from manual mowers.
Heavy-Duty Construction
You’re getting a mower built to last with the 1204-14’s all-steel construction and powder-coated finish. The reinforced steel side plates resist bending under pressure while the 4-blade cutting reel maintains precision alignment through years of use. This commercial-grade build quality means you won’t experience the wobbling or blade misalignment common in lighter models.
Cutting Height Versatility
Your height adjustment options range from 0.5 to 2.75 inches using the easy-adjust lever system. You can tackle grass up to 3.5 inches tall effectively when you start at the highest setting and gradually lower it over multiple passes. The wide height range lets you adapt to different grass types and seasonal growth patterns without switching equipment.
Pros and Cons
Pros: You’ll appreciate the superior build quality, smooth cutting action, and ability to handle thicker grass than comparable models. The steel construction provides stability and longevity that plastic competitors can’t match.
Cons: You’ll need more physical effort due to the heavier frame, and the 14-inch width requires more passes than wider models. Blade sharpening becomes necessary sooner with frequent use on tough grass.
How to Choose the Right Reel Mower for Your Needs
Selecting the perfect reel mower for tall grass requires balancing your specific lawn conditions with your physical capabilities and maintenance preferences.
Grass Type Considerations
Different grass varieties respond uniquely to reel mowing, especially when overgrown. Cool-season grasses like fescue and bluegrass handle reel cutting exceptionally well when they’re 3-4 inches tall, as their softer texture allows clean scissor cuts. Warm-season grasses such as Bermuda and zoysia become tougher and more fibrous when tall, requiring mowers with sharper blades and more cutting power to prevent tearing.
Lawn Size and Terrain Factors
Your lawn’s dimensions and topography directly impact mower selection efficiency. Properties under 5,000 square feet work well with 14-16 inch cutting widths, while larger areas benefit from 18-inch decks to reduce mowing time. Steep slopes and uneven terrain demand lighter models with larger wheels for stability, whereas flat lawns can accommodate heavier, more robust mowers that provide superior cutting consistency.
Budget and Maintenance Requirements
Entry-level reel mowers cost $100-200 but require frequent blade sharpening when cutting thick grass regularly. Premium models ranging $300-500 feature self-sharpening systems and hardened steel blades that maintain performance longer between maintenance sessions. Factor in annual sharpening costs of $30-50 for basic models versus occasional fine-tuning for high-end mowers when calculating your total ownership investment.
Tips for Using Reel Mowers on Tall Grass
Mastering tall grass with a reel mower requires adjusting your approach from standard lawn maintenance. These techniques will help you achieve professional results while protecting your equipment.
Proper Mowing Technique
Start by cutting tall grass in stages rather than attempting to reach your desired height in one pass. Make your first cut at the highest setting, then gradually lower the blade height over multiple sessions. This prevents blade binding and ensures clean cuts through thick stems.
Walk at a steady, moderate pace to maintain consistent cutting action. Rushing creates uneven results and strains the cutting mechanism.
Maintenance and Blade Care
Check blade sharpness before tackling overgrown areas since dull blades tear grass rather than cutting cleanly. Clean grass clippings from the reel after each use to prevent moisture buildup and corrosion. Oil the cutting mechanism monthly during heavy-use periods.
Adjust blade-to-bed knife clearance according to grass thickness. Tighter settings work better for dense growth but require more frequent sharpening.
Seasonal Considerations
Spring growth requires the most aggressive cutting approach since grass shoots up quickly after winter dormancy. Schedule weekly cuts during peak growing season to prevent overwhelming your mower’s capacity.
Fall maintenance becomes crucial for next season’s performance. Clean and oil all moving parts before winter storage to ensure smooth operation when tall grass returns.
Conclusion
You’ve now got the knowledge to tackle your overgrown lawn with confidence using a quality reel mower. Whether you choose the budget-friendly Great States 415-16 the innovative Fiskars StaySharp Max or the heavy-duty American Lawn Mower 1204-14 you’ll be making an eco-friendly choice that delivers superior cutting results.
Remember that success with tall grass depends on proper technique and regular maintenance. Take your time with the first few cuts and don’t forget to keep those blades sharp for optimal performance.
Your lawn will thank you for the clean precise cuts that only a reel mower can provide. Plus you’ll enjoy the quiet operation and the satisfaction of maintaining your yard without relying on gas or electricity.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can reel mowers effectively cut tall grass?
Yes, modern reel mowers can effectively cut tall grass up to 4 inches with proper technique and sharp blades. Advanced models feature precision-ground blades and multiple blade configurations that handle overgrown lawns efficiently. The key is using a scissor-like cutting action and cutting in stages, starting at the highest setting and gradually lowering the blade height.
What makes a reel mower suitable for tall grass?
Reel mowers ideal for tall grass feature wider cutting decks (16-18 inches), self-sharpening blade systems, and ergonomic designs. Look for models with 4-5 blade configurations, single-lever height adjustment systems, and large wheels for better maneuverability. Quality construction with precision-ground, hardened steel blades ensures clean cuts without stressing the grass.
How do I choose the right reel mower for my lawn size?
For lawns under 5,000 square feet, choose 14-16 inch cutting widths. Larger areas benefit from 18-inch decks for fewer passes. Consider your grass type: cool-season grasses like fescue work well with standard models, while warm-season grasses may need sharper blades. Factor in terrain difficulty and your physical capabilities when selecting.
What’s the proper technique for mowing tall grass with a reel mower?
Cut tall grass in stages rather than attempting to reach the desired height in one pass. Start at the highest blade setting and gradually lower it over multiple cuts. Maintain sharp blades, mow weekly during growing seasons, and ensure proper overlap between passes. Clean the mower after each use to prevent grass buildup.
How much should I expect to spend on a quality reel mower?
Entry-level reel mowers cost $100-200 but require frequent blade sharpening. Mid-range models ($200-300) offer better durability and cutting performance. Premium models ($300-500) feature self-sharpening systems and advanced blade technology. Factor in maintenance costs like blade sharpening when calculating total ownership investment.
Do reel mowers require a lot of maintenance?
Reel mowers require regular blade maintenance for optimal performance. Sharp blades are essential for cutting tall grass effectively. Clean the mower after each use, check blade alignment periodically, and sharpen blades as needed. Premium models with self-sharpening systems reduce maintenance frequency but may need occasional fine-tuning.
Are reel mowers suitable for thick weeds and overgrown areas?
While reel mowers excel at cutting grass, they may struggle with thick weeds and extremely overgrown areas. They work best on established lawns with consistent grass growth. For heavily weed-infested areas, consider clearing weeds first or using the reel mower in combination with other lawn care methods.
