6 Best Cucumber Seeds For Pickling Gardens That Old Farmers Swear By

There’s a world of difference between a cucumber you slice for a salad and one you brine for a pickle. Many a first-time gardener has learned this the hard way, ending up with soft, hollow pickles from a watery slicing variety. Choosing the right seed from the start is the most important step toward a pantry full of crisp, delicious pickles.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

What Makes a Great Pickling Cucumber Variety?

A great pickling cucumber is built differently from the ground up. You’re looking for a fruit with thin, tender skin that allows the brine to penetrate easily. The flesh should be dense and firm, not watery, which is the secret to that satisfying crunch.

Look for varieties described as having a small seed cavity. Large seeds and the gel around them create hollow spots in your pickles after brining—a common disappointment. The ideal shape is short and blocky, not long and slender, which helps them fit uniformly into jars.

Boston Pickling: The Time-Tested Heirloom

If you want a cucumber that has proven itself for generations, Boston Pickling is your variety. This heirloom has been a garden staple since the 1870s for a reason. It produces crisp, black-spined cucumbers with a classic, blocky shape.

The plants are vigorous and productive, giving you a steady supply for weeks. Because it’s an open-pollinated heirloom, you can save the seeds from your best fruits for next year’s garden. It’s a reliable, no-fuss choice that works perfectly for both whole pickles and spears.

National Pickling: A Dependable, Heavy Yielder

This variety is the workhorse of the pickling world. Developed with input from the National Pickle Packers Association, it was bred specifically for high yields and uniformity. If your goal is to process a lot of pickles, this is a fantastic choice.

National Pickling cucumbers are known for their classic pickling look: straight, cylindrical, and dark green with black spines. They also carry resistance to cucumber mosaic virus and scab, which can save a hobby farmer a lot of heartache. It’s a dependable performer that consistently delivers jar-filling harvests.

Bush Pickle: Top Choice for Container Gardens

Not everyone has space for sprawling cucumber vines that can quickly take over a garden bed. Bush Pickle solves this problem beautifully. The plant grows in a compact, bushy form, reaching only about two to three feet long, making it perfect for large containers or raised beds.

You do trade some productivity for this compact size; it won’t yield as heavily as a vining type. However, the fruit it produces is crisp, flavorful, and perfectly sized for pickling. For gardeners with limited space, the ability to grow a dedicated pickling cucumber at all is a huge win.

Chicago Pickling: The Perfect Gherkin Producer

This heirloom variety is a star for making small, whole pickles. If you love sweet gherkins or relish, Chicago Pickling is an excellent choice. The plants are incredibly productive, setting a large number of small, firm, and satisfyingly warty cucumbers.

To get the best gherkins, you need to be diligent about harvesting them when they are just two to three inches long. This variety stays crisp and solid even at a small size. It’s a classic for a reason and connects you to a long history of market gardening.

Parisian Pickling: For Classic Cornichons

If your tastes run a bit more gourmet, the Parisian Pickling (also known as ‘Improved Bourbonne’) is the variety for making authentic French cornichons. These are tiny, tart pickles that require a very specific type of cucumber. This variety delivers exactly that.

The fruits are small, slender, and very tender, meant to be picked when they are no bigger than your pinky finger. This requires daily, sometimes twice-daily, harvesting. It’s more work, but the reward is a truly special pickle that you can’t easily find in a store.

Calypso Hybrid: A Modern Disease-Resistant Star

Heirlooms are fantastic, but modern hybrids have their place, especially when it comes to fighting disease. Calypso is a high-yielding, disease-resistant powerhouse. It was developed to resist common cucumber ailments like angular leaf spot, powdery mildew, and cucumber mosaic virus.

This is a practical choice for gardeners who have struggled with disease wiping out their crops in the past. As a hybrid, it offers exceptional vigor and productivity, but you can’t save the seeds and expect them to grow true to type. It’s a tradeoff: seed independence for modern resilience.

Harvesting Cukes at the Perfect Pickling Size

The best seed in the world won’t save you if you harvest at the wrong time. The single most important rule for pickling cucumbers is to harvest early and often. A perfect 4-inch pickler today will be a bloated, seedy yellow giant in two days.

Check your plants every single day once they start producing. Pick them on the small side for the best texture and quality. A good rule of thumb is:

• 1-2 inches: For cornichons
• 3-4 inches: For whole dill or sweet gherkin pickles
• 5-6 inches: For spears and chips. Anything larger is best left for relish.

Consistent harvesting also signals the plant to produce more fruit, so you’ll get a bigger yield over the season. Don’t let them get big on the vine; it’s the fastest way to ruin a good pickling cucumber.

Ultimately, the best pickling cucumber is the one that fits your garden space, your culinary goals, and your local growing challenges. Whether you choose a time-tested heirloom or a modern disease-resistant hybrid, picking the right seed is the first step in planning your pantry right from the garden plot.