7 Best Onion Plants For Long Storage That Old Farmers Swear By

There’s nothing more satisfying than walking out to your shed in the dead of winter and grabbing a firm, perfect onion you grew yourself. The difference between a pantry full of rock-hard onions in March and a pile of soft, sprouted bulbs is decided long before you even plant a seed. It all comes down to choosing the right variety from the start.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why Good Keepers Matter for the Homestead Pantry

Growing onions is one thing; growing onions that last is another game entirely. Sweet onions like Vidalia or Walla Walla are delicious sliced raw on a burger in July, but they have high water and sugar content. That makes them soft and prone to rot within a month or two. They are summer onions, meant to be eaten fresh.

Storage onions are the backbone of a working pantry. They are dense, pungent, and have low water content, with tight, papery skins that act like armor. Properly cured, these are the onions that will see you through soups, stews, and roasts all winter long. Choosing a good keeper means you’re not just growing food for the season, you’re stocking your larder for the year ahead.

Copra: The Gold Standard for Year-Long Storage

If you ask a seasoned gardener to name one onion for storage, chances are they’ll say Copra. This variety has earned its legendary reputation for a reason. It’s not the biggest onion in the patch, but it is one of the hardest and densest you can grow.

Copra bulbs cure down to what feel like wooden balls with multiple layers of coppery, tight skin. This incredible density and low moisture content is the secret to its longevity; it’s not uncommon to have Copra onions remain perfectly solid for 10 to 12 months in proper storage. Its flavor is sharp and pungent when raw but mellows beautifully with cooking, making it a perfect all-purpose kitchen onion.

Patterson: A Modern Favorite for Rock-Hard Bulbs

Patterson is what happens when you take the incredible storage ability of an onion like Copra and improve the field performance. Developed at Cornell University, this variety is a modern workhorse that has quickly become a favorite for its sheer reliability and exceptional keeping quality.

It produces uniform, globe-shaped bulbs that are incredibly hard and store just as long, if not longer, than Copra. Where Patterson really shines is its vigor and disease resistance, particularly against pink root and fusarium. For the hobby farmer, this means a more dependable harvest of flawless, long-lasting onions, even if your soil isn’t perfect.

Stuttgarter: The Reliable German Heirloom Keeper

Often sold as sets in early spring, Stuttgarter is a classic for a reason. This German heirloom has been a staple in gardens for generations because it’s productive, reliable, and stores remarkably well. You’ll recognize it by its slightly flattened, saucer-like shape.

While it might not last a full calendar year like Copra, a properly cured crop of Stuttgarter will easily keep you supplied for a solid 6 to 8 months. It has a fantastic, spicy flavor that holds up to strong cooking. If you prefer growing from sets for an easy, early start, this is one of the best storage varieties you can find.

Redwing: A Flavorful Red Onion That Lasts Months

Let’s be honest: most red onions are terrible keepers. They’re bred for sweetness and color, not for sitting in a cellar. Redwing is the brilliant exception to that rule. It gives you that beautiful deep-red color all the way through the bulb, but with a density and skin quality you’d expect from a yellow storage onion.

You can’t expect Redwing to last a full year, but it will easily store for 5 to 7 months, taking you well into winter. This is a huge win for anyone who loves the sharp-but-sweet flavor of red onions in salads or salsas. Having your own homegrown red onions in January feels like a true luxury.

New York Early: A Dependable, Pungent Keeper

As the name suggests, this variety is a great choice for northern gardeners with slightly shorter seasons. New York Early matures a bit faster than some of the other iron-clad keepers, but it doesn’t sacrifice much in storage potential. It’s a classic yellow globe onion with a strong, pungent flavor.

This is a fantastic, all-around choice that balances speed and longevity. You can count on New York Early to produce a reliable crop of medium-sized bulbs that will store for a solid 6 months or more. It’s a proven, dependable performer that has earned its place in the pantry.

Southport White Globe: A Classic White Storage Onion

Finding a good white onion that stores well can be a challenge, as they tend to have a higher water content than their yellow cousins. The Southport White Globe is an American heirloom that solves this problem. It has been the standard for a dependable white storage onion since the 1800s.

These beautiful, perfectly round onions have a crisp texture and a milder flavor than many yellow keepers, making them excellent for fresh eating as well as cooking. While they won’t last as long as a Patterson, they are the best in their class, easily storing for 5 to 6 months. If you want a dedicated white onion for your winter pantry, this is the one to grow.

Bridger: A Large, Firm Yellow for Winter Months

Sometimes you want an onion with a bit more size without giving up storage life. Bridger strikes that perfect balance. It produces large, blocky, globe-shaped onions that can get quite big but still cure down to a firm, dense bulb ready for the cellar.

Bridger is a consistently heavy yielder with a strong root system, making it a vigorous plant in the garden. Its thick, dark-yellow skins protect it well, allowing it to store for an impressive 7 to 9 months. It’s the ideal choice if you want a hefty onion for slicing that you can still count on come February.

The secret to a year-round onion supply isn’t complicated; it’s about making a smart choice in the seed catalog. By planting varieties bred for low moisture and dense flesh, you set yourself up for success before the first sprout ever breaks the soil. Choose your keeper, cure it well, and enjoy the taste of your own garden all winter long.