6 Best Retaining Walls For Preventing Slope Failure That Old-Timers Swear By
Discover 6 time-tested retaining walls old-timers swear by. From gabion to dry-stack stone, learn which classic designs best prevent slope failure.
There’s nothing more humbling than watching a hillside you thought was stable slowly slump its way into your pasture after a week of heavy rain. A slope isn’t just a feature of your land; it’s a force of nature you have to manage. Getting it wrong means losing valuable ground, fighting endless erosion, and maybe even undermining a barn foundation.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Reading Your Land: Assessing Slope Failure Risk
Before you move a single stone, you need to learn to read the story your land is telling you. A failing slope rarely gives way all at once. It whispers before it shouts. Look for the subtle signs: small, crescent-shaped cracks in the soil (we call them "slump scarps"), trees that lean downhill at an odd angle, or patches of ground that stay wet and spongy long after a rain.
The type of soil you have is half the battle. Heavy clay soil holds a lot of water, becoming incredibly heavy and slick, making it prone to sliding. Sandy or loamy soil drains better but can wash out from underneath if water flow isn’t controlled. The real trick is to walk your property during a downpour. See where the water goes, where it pools, and where it runs fastest. That water is what will destroy your wall if you don’t account for it.
The Dry-Stack Fieldstone Wall: A Timeless Classic
There’s a reason you see these beautiful, mortar-free walls all over old farms. They were built with what was available: the endless supply of rocks pulled from the fields. A dry-stack wall is more than just a pile of stones; it’s a carefully fitted puzzle that relies on gravity and friction to hold itself together. Its greatest strength is its permeability. Water can weep right through the gaps, relieving the immense pressure that would buckle a solid wall.
This is the perfect solution for slopes under four feet high, especially if you’re rich in rock but poor in cash. The work is slow and demands a good eye for finding the right stone for the right spot. You learn to "batter" the wall back, leaning it into the hillside so gravity works for you, not against you. It’s not the fastest method, but a well-built dry-stack wall can outlive you, settling and shifting with the ground instead of fighting it.
Gabion Baskets: Industrial Strength for Steep Grades
Sometimes you have a problem that artistry can’t solve. For a seriously steep grade or a large-scale washout, gabion baskets are a brutally effective tool. Think of them as giant, rectangular cages made of heavy-gauge wire mesh. You place the empty baskets, wire them together, and fill them with rough, fist-sized rock. The weight and mass create an incredibly stable structure.
The beauty of gabions is their simplicity and strength. They are essentially pre-made, stable building blocks that provide their own excellent drainage through the rock fill. You can stack them high and create very strong, near-vertical walls. The tradeoff is the look—it’s more industrial than rustic. But you can soften the appearance by filling the top layer with soil and planting it, eventually turning your steel-and-rock wall into a living green one.
The Classic Railroad Tie Wall: A Proven Method
For decades, railroad ties were the go-to material for a tough, affordable retaining wall. They’re dense, heavy, and treated to resist rot for a very long time. The key to making them last isn’t just stacking them; it’s anchoring them back into the hill. Every few layers, you must install a "deadman"—a tie laid perpendicular to the wall, extending back into the slope, with another tie spiked to its end to form a ‘T’. This mechanical anchor is what gives the wall its real strength against the pressure of the earth.
But we have to talk about the creosote. Those old ties are soaked in it, and it’s not something you want leaching into your soil, especially anywhere near a vegetable garden or a water source. Newer landscape timbers are pressure-treated with less toxic chemicals and are a better choice for most farm applications. If you do use old ties, reserve them for non-food areas like holding back a driveway bank.
Secure landscaping fabric, irrigation tubing, and more with these durable, galvanized steel garden stakes. Their U-shaped design and sharp, beveled ends ensure easy ground penetration and reliable holding power.
Timber Crib Walls: Interlocking Log-Style Support
A crib wall is like a heavy-duty version of Lincoln Logs built into a hillside. You build a box-like structure with interlocking timbers (or even whole logs) and fill the resulting "cribs" with free-draining stone and soil. This creates an immensely heavy, stable structure that works as a single, massive unit to hold back the earth.
This method shines when you have a lot of timber on your property and need to retain a significant amount of soil. The interlocking design distributes the load across the entire structure, making it incredibly resistant to pressure. The main drawback is that it’s still wood. It will eventually rot, especially where it meets the soil. Using rot-resistant wood like black locust or cedar can extend its life significantly, but it’s not a "forever" solution like stone or concrete.
Poured Concrete Walls: Unmatched Modern Durability
When a slope is threatening a critical structure like a barn or house, you bring in the heavy artillery: poured concrete. A properly engineered concrete wall, built on a solid footing with steel rebar for reinforcement, is the strongest and most permanent solution you can build. It’s a no-nonsense approach for when failure is simply not an option.
This is not a casual weekend project. A concrete wall requires careful excavation, building forms, and understanding how to place rebar to handle the tensile forces. Most importantly, you must include drainage. Weep holes through the face of the wall and a deep gravel backfill are non-negotiable. Without them, you’re just building a concrete dam that will eventually fail under hydrostatic pressure. It’s expensive and often requires a professional, but for high-stakes situations, it provides unmatched peace of mind.
Terraced Earth Berms: Working With Your Contours
Sometimes the best wall isn’t a wall at all. Terracing is an ancient technique of reshaping the slope itself into a series of smaller, level steps. You cut into the hillside and use the excavated soil to build up a compacted berm on the downhill side of the cut. This turns one large, unusable slope into several smaller, manageable flat areas perfect for planting beds or creating pathways.
This approach is often the most sustainable and visually appealing. You’re working with the land, not fighting it. The key is to immediately plant your new berms with deep-rooted grasses, shrubs, or cover crops. The roots are what will knit the soil together and prevent your newly moved earth from simply washing away in the first big storm. It’s a great option for gentler slopes where you want to increase your usable acreage.
Why Good Drainage is Key to Any Long-Lasting Wall
Here’s the most important lesson you’ll ever learn about retaining walls: Dirt doesn’t break walls. Water does. Soil by itself is manageable, but soil saturated with water becomes an incredibly heavy, fluid mass that exerts immense hydrostatic pressure. No matter which type of wall you build, your number one priority must be giving that water an escape route.
Every successful wall needs a drainage system behind it. This usually consists of a layer of clean gravel directly against the back of the wall, which allows water to percolate down freely. At the base of the wall, you should lay a perforated drain pipe (a French drain) bedded in more gravel, which collects the water and carries it safely away to daylight. A wall without drainage is just a temporary dam, and nature always wins against a dam.
Solve your landscaping drainage challenges with this flexible, perforated pipe. It expands from 6 to 25 feet and easily connects to 3" and 4" corrugated pipes, as well as 4" PVC.
Choosing the right retaining wall is a balance of your land’s needs, your available materials, and your budget. The old-timers knew that the best solutions were often the ones that worked with nature’s forces instead of trying to defy them. So read your land, plan for the water, and build something that will stand long after you’re gone.
