6 Best Cabbage Seeds For Sauerkraut That Old Farmers Swear By

There’s nothing more disappointing than opening a crock of sauerkraut you’ve tended for weeks, only to find a mushy, bland, or watery mess. You did everything right—the salt ratio, the temperature, the airlock—so what went wrong? The problem often starts months earlier, right when you’re choosing your seeds, because not all cabbages are created equal when it comes to fermentation.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

What Makes a Cabbage Perfect for Sauerkraut?

The secret to crunchy, tangy sauerkraut isn’t in the crock, it’s in the cabbage head itself. You’re looking for a head with low water content. A watery cabbage will release too much brine, diluting the salt concentration and leading to soft, unappealing kraut.

Next is sugar content. Fermentation is driven by beneficial bacteria (Lactobacillus) that consume sugars and produce lactic acid, which is the preservative that gives sauerkraut its signature tang. A cabbage with higher natural sugar content provides more food for these bacteria, resulting in a more robust and reliable ferment.

Finally, consider the leaf structure and density. The ideal kraut cabbage has a tightly packed, dense head with thin, crisp leaves. This combination shreds into fine, uniform ribbons that hold their texture through the fermentation process. A loose-headed cabbage with thick-veined leaves often results in a coarse, chewy product.

Brunswick: The Classic German Heirloom Choice

When old-timers talk about making sauerkraut, Brunswick is often the cabbage they’re picturing. This German heirloom has been the standard for generations for a good reason. It’s a late-season variety, perfectly timed for a big fall harvest and kraut-making weekend.

The heads are massive, drum-shaped, and slightly flattened on top, often weighing in at 6 to 9 pounds. They are incredibly dense and packed with the sweet, crisp leaves that are perfect for shredding. The flavor is exactly what you want for a traditional, sharp, and complex sauerkraut.

Being an heirloom, Brunswick can sometimes be more vulnerable to pests and diseases than modern hybrids. But if you have healthy soil and a bit of luck, the resulting kraut is worth the risk. It’s the benchmark against which all other sauerkraut cabbages are measured.

Late Flat Dutch: For Massive Sauerkraut Batches

If your goal is to fill several large crocks to last the entire winter, Late Flat Dutch is your workhorse. This variety is all about scale. It’s one of the largest open-pollinated cabbages you can grow, with heads that can easily top 15 pounds under the right conditions.

Like its name suggests, it produces enormous, flattened heads that are rock-solid and dense. This high density means you get a tremendous amount of shredded cabbage from a single head, significantly cutting down on your harvesting and processing time. One head can often fill a medium-sized crock all by itself.

Late Flat Dutch requires a long growing season, so it’s not for gardeners in far northern climates. But if you have the time, its excellent storage quality—both as a fresh head and as finished sauerkraut—makes it an incredibly practical choice for serious homesteaders.

Golden Acre: An Early Season Kraut Favorite

You don’t always have to wait until the fall chill to make sauerkraut. For those who want a batch ready for summer cookouts, Golden Acre is the perfect fit. It’s a compact and early-maturing variety, often ready to harvest in just over 60 days from transplanting.

The heads are smaller, typically around 3 to 4 pounds, and perfectly round. They are surprisingly dense for their size and have a wonderfully sweet, mild flavor. This makes for a kraut that’s less intensely sharp than those made from late-season varieties, which many people prefer.

Because of its smaller size and quick turnaround, Golden Acre is an excellent choice for gardens with limited space or for succession planting. You can get a crop in and harvested long before your main-season cabbages are even starting to head up. Just be prepared to plant more of them if you’re planning a large batch.

Copenhagen Market: The All-Around Performer

If you’re looking for a single cabbage variety that does it all, Copenhagen Market is a fantastic choice. It’s a reliable, no-fuss heirloom that performs well in a wide range of climates and soil types. It’s the dependable friend in the garden.

This variety produces uniform, tightly wrapped, round heads weighing about 4 to 5 pounds. It strikes a great balance—it’s ready earlier than the big winter keepers but later and larger than super-early types like Golden Acre. The flavor is sweet yet classic, and its dense texture holds up beautifully to shredding and fermentation.

What makes Copenhagen Market so valuable on a small farm is its versatility. It makes a wonderfully crisp and flavorful kraut, but it’s also a top-notch cabbage for fresh eating in slaws or for cooking. Any heads you don’t use for fermenting will never go to waste.

Glory of Enkhuizen: For a Sweet, Crisp Kraut

For those who find traditional sauerkraut a bit too sharp, Glory of Enkhuizen offers a delightful alternative. This Dutch heirloom is prized for its exceptionally high sugar content, which profoundly influences the final product. A sweeter start leads to a sweeter finish.

The heads are large, round, and firm, making them easy to shred. That extra sugar doesn’t just add sweetness; it provides a feast for the fermenting bacteria, often leading to a more vigorous and active fermentation process. The result is a kraut that is crisp, mild, and complex, with a rich flavor that isn’t overwhelmingly acidic.

This is a great mid-to-late season variety that also stores well. It’s an excellent choice for anyone who wants to experiment with kraut flavors or for those who use sauerkraut as a major ingredient in cooked dishes like casseroles and stews, where its milder profile truly shines.

Kaitlin Hybrid: Disease-Resistant & Reliable

Let’s be practical: sometimes, growing heirloom cabbage is a battle. If you’ve struggled with soil-borne diseases like fusarium wilt or black rot, a modern hybrid like Kaitlin can be a garden-saver. A reliable harvest of a good hybrid is always better than a failed crop of a prized heirloom.

Kaitlin was bred specifically for performance and disease resistance, and it delivers. It produces large, dense, uniform heads with a classic blue-green color. It holds well in the field without splitting, giving you a wider window for harvesting, which is a huge benefit on a busy homestead.

Don’t let the word "hybrid" fool you into thinking you’re sacrificing quality. Kaitlin has a fantastic crisp texture and a sweet flavor that ferments into a top-tier sauerkraut. It offers peace of mind and a dependable yield, ensuring your pantry will be full, even in a challenging growing season.

Growing Cabbage for the Best Fermentation

Choosing the right seed is just the first step. The way you grow your cabbage has a massive impact on its suitability for sauerkraut. A stressed plant will produce a subpar head, regardless of the variety.

Cabbage is a heavy feeder that demands rich soil and consistent moisture. A plant that struggles for water or nutrients will produce a smaller, less dense, and often bitter-tasting head. Amending your soil with plenty of well-rotted compost and ensuring even watering throughout the growing season is non-negotiable for growing great kraut cabbage.

For the late-season storage varieties, timing your harvest is the final secret. Try to wait until after your first light frost. The shock of the cold signals the plant to convert its starches into sugars as a form of antifreeze. This process, known as "sweetening up," gives you a head that is not only tastier but also primed with the sugars needed for a spectacular fermentation.

Ultimately, the perfect sauerkraut starts with intention—in the seed you choose and the soil you build. Don’t be afraid to plant a couple of different varieties to see which performs best in your garden and, more importantly, which one makes the kraut that you and your family love the most.