6 Best Calcium Supplements For Laying Hens That Prevent Weak Eggshells
Ensure strong eggshells for your laying hens. This guide reviews the top 6 calcium supplements, from classic oyster shell to liquid options, for a healthy flock.
You reach into the nesting box and feel it—that dreaded, rubbery eggshell that squishes under the slightest pressure. It’s a clear signal your flock is sending for help. Providing the right calcium supplement isn’t just about getting strong eggs; it’s fundamental to the long-term health and productivity of your laying hens.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Why Laying Hens Need a Dedicated Calcium Source
A hen’s body performs a minor miracle every 24 to 26 hours. Forming a single eggshell requires a massive amount of calcium, pulling it directly from her bloodstream. To meet this demand, she must draw from either her diet or, if her diet is lacking, her own bones.
Think of her skeleton as a calcium bank account. If dietary deposits are low, she’ll make withdrawals to form that shell. Consistent withdrawals lead to brittle bones, a condition similar to osteoporosis, which can result in fractures and a shortened, painful life. This is why simply providing a good layer feed is often not enough.
Layer feeds are formulated with a baseline level of calcium, but individual needs vary dramatically. A high-production hen, a bird in her laying prime, or the entire flock during a summer heatwave (when feed consumption drops) will require more calcium than the feed provides. A dedicated, free-choice calcium source allows each hen to regulate her own intake, taking exactly what she needs, when she needs it.
Ignoring this leads to more than just weak shells. Chronic calcium deficiency can cause egg binding, where an egg gets stuck in the oviduct, and vent prolapse—both serious, often fatal, conditions. Providing a separate calcium source is one of the easiest and most important things you can do for your flock’s well-being.
Manna Pro Crushed Oyster Shell: The Classic Choice
When you think of chicken calcium, you’re probably picturing crushed oyster shell. Manna Pro is the brand you’ll find in nearly every feed store, and for good reason. It’s the reliable, no-frills standard that has supported healthy flocks for decades.
The key to its effectiveness is its form. The coarse, flaky texture of oyster shell ensures a slow and steady release of calcium carbonate into the hen’s system. Hens typically consume it in the afternoon, and the large particles sit in the gizzard, dissolving gradually overnight. This timing is perfect, as most of the shell formation happens while the hen sleeps. This slow-release mechanism is crucial for building strong shells consistently.
Grubblies Calcium+ Supplement: A Fine Limestone
Grubblies offers a high-quality ground limestone supplement, which provides a different approach to calcium delivery. Unlike the large flakes of oyster shell, this supplement has a finer, more granular consistency. This makes it a great option for mixing directly with fermented feed or for flocks that seem hesitant to peck at larger shell fragments.
The main tradeoff here is absorption speed. The smaller particle size means the calcium is absorbed more quickly by the hen’s body. This can be beneficial for a quick boost, but it doesn’t provide the same slow, overnight release that larger oyster shell pieces do. For this reason, some flock keepers use both—limestone for a quick-access source and oyster shell for that long-duration supply.
Purina Oyster Shell: A Trusted Flock Favorite
Ensure strong eggshells and healthy hens with Pecking Order Oyster Shell. This natural calcium supplement supports consistent egg production and promotes overall bone health in your flock.
Purina is one of the most recognized names in animal nutrition, and their oyster shell product lives up to that reputation. Much like Manna Pro, it provides the essential coarse-particle calcium that laying hens need for strong eggshells. Its primary advantage is brand trust and widespread availability.
If you’re already feeding Purina products, adding their oyster shell is a seamless choice. The product is known for its consistent sizing and cleanliness, ensuring you’re not getting a bag of dust with a few shell fragments. It functions identically to other high-quality oyster shells, providing that critical slow-release calcium source for overnight shell development. It’s a dependable workhorse for any backyard flock.
Durvet Liquid Calcium for Water-Based Dosing
Liquid calcium is not a replacement for a free-choice supplement, but rather a specialized tool for specific situations. This water-soluble supplement is designed for rapid intervention. You add it to the flock’s waterer to deliver a fast-acting dose of calcium to every bird that drinks.
This is your go-to solution in a few key scenarios:
- An acute deficiency: If you find a hen that is egg-bound or clearly struggling, liquid calcium can provide an immediate boost.
- Extreme heat: When chickens reduce their feed intake to stay cool, they also reduce their calcium intake. Adding liquid calcium to their water ensures they stay supplemented.
- Integrating new pullets: It can help young layers get a head start as they begin their laying careers.
Use it as a temporary support, not a long-term strategy. Hens still need the mechanical benefits and slow-release properties of a grit-based source like oyster shell for sustained health. Over-reliance on liquid calcium can lead to excess calcium intake, which can cause kidney damage.
Small Pet Select Oyster Shell for Peak Hardness
For the flock owner who prioritizes sourcing and premium quality, Small Pet Select offers a meticulously prepared oyster shell. This product is often marketed for its exceptional cleanliness and consistent particle size. While functionally similar to other oyster shells, the attention to detail can be a deciding factor for some.
A consistent grind means birds are less likely to pick through the supplement, ensuring more uniform consumption. If you’ve found other brands to be too dusty or inconsistent, this can be an excellent alternative. It’s about providing the best possible version of a classic, essential supplement for optimal shell hardness and hen health.
DIY Crushed Eggshells: The Sustainable Option
Using your own flock’s eggshells is the ultimate sustainable practice. It’s free, reduces waste, and returns valuable calcium right back to your hens. However, you must prepare them correctly to avoid serious problems.
Never feed raw, fresh eggshells to your flock. Doing so can encourage egg-eating, a habit that is incredibly difficult to break. It also poses a risk of transferring bacteria. The proper method is crucial:
- Rinse the shells to remove any remaining egg white.
- Dry them completely. You can let them air dry for a day or two.
- Bake the dry shells at a low temperature (around 200°F or 95°C) for 10-15 minutes. This sterilizes them and makes them brittle.
- Crush them into small, unrecognizable pieces, no larger than a pinky fingernail.
While an excellent supplement, relying solely on your own shells may not be enough, especially if you have a large flock or eat a lot of eggs yourself. It’s best used as a complimentary source alongside a commercial oyster shell to ensure your hens never run short.
How to Properly Offer Calcium to Your Flock
How you offer calcium is just as important as which type you choose. The single most important rule is to always provide calcium in a separate container, free-choice. Never mix it directly into your flock’s main feed ration.
Hens have a remarkable ability to self-regulate their calcium intake. A laying hen will seek it out when she needs it, while a rooster, a molting hen, or a young pullet that isn’t laying yet will largely ignore it. Forcing them to consume it by mixing it into their feed can be harmful. Excess calcium can lead to kidney damage and interfere with the absorption of other vital nutrients.
The best method is to use a dedicated dispenser or a heavy dish that can’t be easily tipped over or filled with bedding. Place it near their feeder but keep it separate. Keep the container filled, and trust your hens to take what they need.
This simple practice of free-choice supplementation empowers each bird to manage her own health. It accounts for individual differences in production, age, and metabolism far better than any one-size-fits-all feed formulation ever could. It is the cornerstone of responsible and effective flock management.
Ultimately, preventing weak eggshells is a straightforward task. By providing a constant, separate source of calcium, you empower your hens to build strong shells and maintain their own skeletal health. Whether you choose a classic oyster shell, a convenient liquid, or a sustainable DIY option, consistency is the key to a healthy, productive flock.
