5 Best Small Bale Hay For Easy Handling On Small Farms To Save Your Back
Small farm operators can avoid back strain with the right hay. This guide details the 5 best small bale options for easy, manual handling and storage.
There’s a moment every small farmer knows well: staring at a freshly delivered stack of hay and calculating the number of times you’ll have to lift each bale before winter is over. That single motion, repeated dozens or hundreds of time, can make or break your back. Choosing the right hay isn’t just about animal nutrition; it’s a strategic decision for your own physical sustainability on the farm.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Why Small Bales & Hay Type Matter for Your Back
The most obvious reason to stick with small square bales is weight. A typical small bale weighs between 40 and 60 pounds, a manageable lift for most people. Compare that to a round bale, which can easily top 1,000 pounds and requires a tractor for every single move. For a small operation without heavy equipment, small bales are the only practical choice.
But not all small bales are created equal. The type of hay inside dramatically affects the bale’s density, shape, and even how it feels in your hands. A fluffy, soft orchardgrass bale of 50 pounds feels very different to lift and carry than a dense, coarse, 50-pound bale of first-cut timothy.
Understanding this difference is key. Some bales are tightly packed and stack like perfect bricks, which is great for the hay mow but can be tough to pull flakes from. Others are looser and easier to handle for daily feeding but might create a less stable stack. Your choice impacts everything from how you store it to how you feed it, and most importantly, the strain it puts on your body day after day.
Timothy Hay: The Classic Choice for Most Livestock
Timothy is the gold standard for grass hay, especially for horses. It offers a great balance of fiber, protein, and energy for most adult animals at maintenance. The bales themselves are typically uniform, dense, and hold their shape well, making them fantastic for stacking securely in a loft or shed.
When you pick up a timothy bale, you know what you’re getting. They are consistently packed, which means their weight is predictable. This predictability is a huge asset for planning and for your body. You won’t be surprised by a bale that’s 15 pounds heavier than the last one.
The main tradeoff with timothy is that its coarse, stemmy texture can make the bales feel rigid and a bit prickly to handle. The flakes often break off in solid, heavy chunks. While great for reducing waste, it requires a bit of muscle to peel a few flakes off for feeding time.
Orchardgrass: A Softer Bale for Picky Eaters
Orchardgrass is noticeably softer and leafier than timothy. Animals often prefer its texture and taste, making it a great option for picky eaters or livestock that need to be encouraged to eat more forage, like lactating goats or older horses.
This softness translates directly to handling. Orchardgrass bales tend to be fluffier and less dense than timothy. A 50-pound orchardgrass bale might be physically larger than a 50-pound timothy bale, feeling less like a brick and more like a firm pillow. They are easier on the hands and the flakes pull apart with minimal effort.
The downside is that this soft structure can make them less ideal for stacking. They can be a bit "squishier" and may not lock together as tightly as timothy bales, potentially leading to a less stable stack. You have to be more deliberate when building your hay mow to ensure it remains solid.
Alfalfa Bales: Nutrient-Dense for Growing Animals
Alfalfa is a legume, not a grass, and it’s a nutritional powerhouse. It’s high in protein, calcium, and overall energy, making it essential for animals with high metabolic needs—think growing youngsters, pregnant or lactating mothers, or animals needing to gain weight.
This nutritional density comes at a cost: weight. Alfalfa bales are consistently the heaviest small bales you will handle. Because they are so leafy and fine-stemmed, they can be compressed into incredibly dense packages. A small bale of pure alfalfa can easily push 70 pounds or more, a significant jump from a typical grass hay bale.
If you need alfalfa’s nutrition, you have to plan for the physical toll. Use a hay cart or wheelbarrow whenever possible, and always lift with your legs. Never underestimate an alfalfa bale; what looks like a standard small bale can be a real back-breaker if you’re not prepared for its density.
Brome Grass Hay: A Palatable, Lower-Sugar Option
Brome is another excellent grass hay that offers a great middle ground. It’s highly palatable—most livestock find it very tasty—and it often has a good balance of nutrients without being overly rich. For animals with metabolic concerns, like easy-keeper horses or certain breeds of goats, brome can be a fantastic lower-sugar alternative to other grasses.
In terms of handling, brome grass bales are typically moderately dense. They aren’t as soft and fluffy as orchardgrass, but they lack the coarse rigidity of some timothy cuttings. This makes them relatively pleasant to handle and stack.
The key is to find a good source. Quality can vary, so always check a bale for good color, a fresh smell, and freedom from dust or mold. A well-made brome bale is a versatile and back-friendly option for a wide range of animals.
Timothy-Alfalfa Mix: A Balanced, All-Purpose Bale
For many small farms, a mixed bale is the perfect solution. A timothy-alfalfa mix combines the high fiber of a grass hay with the protein and mineral punch of a legume. This creates a balanced feed that supports a wide range of needs without being as intensely rich as pure alfalfa.
These mixed bales are often the sweet spot for handling, too. The timothy provides structure, so the bales stack better than pure orchardgrass. The alfalfa adds some weight, but they are rarely as dense and heavy as a pure alfalfa bale. You get a firm, manageable bale that’s packed with enhanced nutrition.
This is an incredibly efficient choice for a farm with diverse livestock. You can feed the same hay to your horse, your milk goats, and your sheep, simplifying your feeding routine and your hay purchasing. It’s a smart choice that saves time, money, and strain.
Storing Small Bales to Prevent Mold and Spoilage
Your effort in choosing and moving hay is wasted if it spoils in storage. The number one rule of hay storage is to keep it off the ground and under a roof. Never stack bales directly on a concrete or dirt floor, as moisture will wick up and ruin the bottom layer.
- Use pallets: Wooden pallets are the best way to create an air gap underneath your stack.
- Allow for airflow: Don’t pack bales so tightly against walls or each other that air can’t circulate. A little space can prevent condensation and mold.
- Stack intelligently: Alternate the direction of each layer (a "criss-cross" pattern) to build a stable, interlocking stack that won’t topple over.
A wet bale is more than just a loss; it’s a hazard. Moldy hay can cause serious respiratory and digestive issues in livestock. Furthermore, a water-logged bale can easily double in weight, making it a dangerous and miserable task to remove from the barn. Protecting your hay is protecting both your animals and your back.
Matching Hay Type to Your Specific Animal’s Needs
While handling ease is important, the nutritional needs of your animals must come first. The "best" hay is always the one that is most appropriate for the specific species, age, and life stage of your livestock. There is no one-size-fits-all answer.
A good framework is to start with the animal’s requirements and then find the most manageable option within that category.
- Maintenance Adult Horse: Timothy, Orchardgrass, or Brome are excellent choices. Focus on clean, low-dust bales.
- Lactating Dairy Goat: She needs the high protein and calcium from Alfalfa. A Timothy-Alfalfa mix can be a great compromise for balancing nutrition and bale weight.
- Fattening Lambs or Beef Calves: The extra protein from an Alfalfa mix will support healthy growth far better than a simple grass hay.
- Rabbits or Guinea Pigs: They need high-fiber, soft-stemmed grass hay. Second-cut Orchardgrass or Timothy is often ideal and comes in light, easy-to-handle bales.
Ultimately, the goal is to find the intersection of good nutrition for them and sustainable effort for you. Don’t sacrifice animal health for an easier-to-lift bale, but don’t assume you have to lift the heaviest option, either. Make an informed choice that serves both your farm and your body.
Choosing the right small bale is a proactive step in managing your farm workload. By understanding how hay type affects bale density and weight, you can make a strategic choice that nourishes your animals without punishing your body. It’s one of the simplest ways to work smarter, ensuring you have the strength and health to keep farming for years to come.
