6 Best Tomato Seeds For Canning Whole Tomatoes Old Farmers Swear By

There’s a deep satisfaction that comes from looking at a pantry shelf lined with jars of whole tomatoes, each one a testament to a summer’s hard work. That feeling starts long before you fire up the canner; it begins with a simple choice in the dead of winter: the right seed. Choosing the best tomato for canning whole is the single most important step in ensuring your jars are filled with firm, flavorful fruit, not a watery, mushy mess.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

What Makes a Good Whole Canning Tomato Variety?

Not every tomato is destined for the canning jar. Slicer tomatoes, with their high water content and sprawling seed cavities, break down into a pulpy soup under the heat of processing. What you’re looking for is a "paste" or "sauce" tomato.

These varieties are bred specifically for preservation. They have thick, meaty walls, very little gel or juice, and a low seed count. This dense flesh is crucial for a whole tomato that holds its shape and texture after being peeled, packed, and processed.

The ideal shape is also a practical consideration. Elongated, plum, or pear-shaped tomatoes pack more efficiently into a quart jar than a round one, leaving less empty space. Finally, the skin matters. A good canning tomato has skin that slips off easily after a quick blanch in boiling water, saving you time and frustration during a long day of processing.

San Marzano: The Gold Standard for Canning

When you think of canning tomatoes, the San Marzano is often the first name that comes to mind. This Italian heirloom is legendary for a reason. Its long, blocky shape is practically designed to fit snugly in a jar, and its flesh is exceptionally dry and dense.

The flavor is low in acid, rich, and complex, a taste that only deepens with processing. With very few seeds and minimal juice, it creates a beautiful, firm final product that stands up on its own. It’s the variety by which all other paste tomatoes are judged.

However, the San Marzano demands a bit of attention in the garden. It can be prone to blossom-end rot if calcium levels are low or watering is inconsistent. As an indeterminate variety, it will produce steadily over a long season, which is great for small batches but requires ongoing harvesting.

Amish Paste: Rich Flavor in a Canning Jar

If flavor is your absolute top priority, the Amish Paste is a serious contender. This heirloom variety produces large, acorn-shaped fruits that are much juicier than a typical Roma but pack an intensely rich, sweet tomato taste. It bridges the gap between a paste tomato and a fresh-eating slicer.

Because of its slightly higher water content, it’s not as dense as a San Marzano, but what you trade in firmness you gain in incredible flavor. The fruits are meaty with few seeds, and they hold up well enough for whole canning, though they are also legendary for making sauce.

Be prepared for some irregularity. Unlike the uniform Romas, Amish Paste tomatoes can vary in size and shape on the same vine. This is part of the charm of an old-world heirloom, offering character both in the garden and in the jar.

Roma VF: The Reliable, Disease-Resistant Choice

Sometimes, the best ability is availability. The Roma VF is the workhorse of the canning garden, prized not for its gourmet flavor but for its sheer dependability. It’s a classic plum tomato that produces uniform, medium-sized fruits perfect for packing.

The "VF" in its name is its superpower: it indicates resistance to Verticillium and Fusarium wilts, two common soil-borne fungal diseases that can wipe out a tomato crop. For gardeners who have struggled with these issues, planting a resistant variety like the Roma VF is a game-changer.

This is a determinate variety, meaning it sets the bulk of its fruit in a concentrated window. This is a massive advantage for canners who prefer to dedicate a weekend to processing a large harvest all at once. The flavor is good and classic, but it’s the reliability and convenient harvest schedule that earns it a permanent spot in many gardens.

Opalka: A Polish Heirloom with Few Seeds

The Opalka is a standout for anyone who dreads the task of seeding tomatoes. This Polish heirloom produces uniquely long, slender fruits that look more like a red banana pepper than a tomato. They can grow up to six inches long, with a distinctive nipple on the blossom end.

Inside, the Opalka is almost all solid, dense meat. The seed cavities are tiny and contain very few seeds, making prep work incredibly fast. The flavor is excellent—sweet, rich, and well-balanced.

As an indeterminate plant, Opalka vines will climb and produce heavily, often later in the season. They need tall, sturdy staking to support the weight of the fruit-laden trusses. For those with the space and support, it’s a fantastic choice for a low-seed, high-flavor canned product.

Martino’s Roma: Heavy Yields for Big Batches

When the goal is to fill the pantry shelves, yield is king. Martino’s Roma is an heirloom determinate variety that is legendary for its incredible productivity. The compact plants set an enormous amount of fruit that all ripens in a short period, making it another perfect choice for large-batch canning.

The fruits are smaller than a standard Roma, more of a pear shape, but they are packed with classic, robust tomato flavor. They are meaty and dry, holding their shape exceptionally well when peeled and processed. Their smaller size can also make them easier to pack tightly into jars.

Because of its heavy fruit set, it’s wise to provide Martino’s Roma with sturdy caging or staking, even though it’s a determinate bush plant. The weight of the fruit can easily overwhelm the branches, and keeping them off the ground is key to a clean, healthy harvest.

Principe Borghese: Small Size, Perfect for Jars

Don’t let the small size fool you; the Principe Borghese is a preservation powerhouse. This Italian heirloom is traditionally used for sun-drying because of its extremely low moisture content and rich flavor. Those same characteristics make it a unique and excellent choice for whole canning.

The grape-sized fruits are so small and firm that you can pack them into jars without any cutting at all. They hold their shape perfectly, creating a visually stunning product that’s wonderful in pasta dishes or stews where you want a burst of whole tomato.

The determinate plants are famously productive, yielding hundreds of little fruits per plant. While peeling each one would be a monumental task, many canners simply blanch them and pack them with skins on, as the skins are quite thin. They offer a different approach to whole-tomato canning that is both beautiful and delicious.

Determinate vs. Indeterminate for Canners

Choosing between determinate and indeterminate varieties is less about the tomato and more about your schedule. This single decision will define your entire preservation workflow for the season. There is no right or wrong answer, only what works for you.

• Determinate plants grow to a fixed, bushy size and produce their entire crop over a short, two-to-three-week period. This is the ideal choice if you prefer the "canning weekend" model—harvesting dozens of pounds of tomatoes at once and processing them in one or two massive sessions. Roma VF and Martino’s Roma are classic examples.

• Indeterminate plants grow as long vines that continue to produce fruit all season long until killed by frost. This is better suited for someone who wants a steady supply of tomatoes for fresh eating and prefers to can in smaller, more manageable batches every week or two throughout the late summer. San Marzano and Opalka fit this model.

Many experienced canners plant both types. They’ll use a block of determinate plants for the bulk of their whole tomatoes and sauce, then rely on a few indeterminate vines for a steady supply of fresh tomatoes and smaller batches of specialty products later in the season. This hybrid approach offers the best of both worlds: a full pantry and a long, delicious harvest.

Ultimately, the best canning tomato is the one that thrives in your soil and fits your schedule. By starting with a variety bred for the job, you set yourself up for success. The reward is a pantry full of beautiful jars, each one a delicious reminder of the summer garden, ready to be opened on a cold winter day.