6 Best Heavy Duty Hay Racks For Aggressive Goats That Actually Last
Goats are tough on equipment. We review 6 heavy-duty hay racks built to withstand aggressive herds, reduce costly waste, and provide long-lasting value.
You walk out to the barn and see it again: the brand new hay feeder, now bent at a 45-degree angle, is being used as a jungle gym by your most mischievous doeling. The ground below is littered with expensive alfalfa that’s been pulled out, trampled, and soiled. If you’re tired of wasting feed and replacing flimsy equipment, you’ve realized that a standard feeder just won’t cut it for goats.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Why Goats Destroy Feeders & What to Look For
Goats aren’t malicious; they’re just incredibly hard on equipment. Their natural behavior involves pushing, rubbing, climbing, and head-butting everything in their environment to test it. A feeder isn’t just a place to eat—it’s a scratching post, a sparring partner, and a mountain to be conquered.
This means a "goat-proof" feeder isn’t just about holding hay. It’s about withstanding constant, dynamic pressure from multiple angles. Flimsy wire cages get bent, thin metal troughs get dented, and poorly welded joints snap under the force of a dominant buck showing off. Any gap large enough for a head can become a trap, and any flat surface is an invitation to climb.
When shopping, look past the marketing and focus on the build. The key is heavy-gauge steel and quality welds. Look for rounded edges to prevent injury and vertical bars spaced closely enough to prevent heads from getting stuck (about 3 inches is a good target). A design that angles inward at the top or has a slanted top bar can also be a powerful deterrent against climbing, which is a primary cause of both feeder destruction and hay waste.
Finally, consider the finish. A galvanized or powder-coated finish will resist rust and corrosion from urine and moisture far longer than simple paint. This isn’t just about looks; it’s about the long-term structural integrity of your investment. A rusty feeder will eventually fail, no matter how thick the steel was to begin with.
Tarter Goat Hay Feeder: The All-Around Workhorse
If you’re looking for a versatile, freestanding feeder that can handle a decent-sized herd, the Tarter bunk-style feeder is a common sight on hobby farms for a reason. It’s built from heavy-duty steel and often features a V-shaped hay rack over a grain trough. This design keeps hay contained and forces goats to pull it through the slats, reducing the amount they can drop on the ground.
The real strength of this design is its stability. Its wide footprint and sheer weight make it difficult for even the most determined goats to push around or tip over. This is a set-it-and-forget-it piece of equipment that can serve as a central feeding station in a paddock or a large stall. It’s built to take a beating from horns and hooves year after year.
The main tradeoff is its size and cost. This is not a small feeder, and it represents a significant upfront investment. Moving it for cleaning requires some muscle, and it takes up a considerable amount of floor space, making it less ideal for very small, tight pens.
Little Giant Wall Feeder: A Space-Saving Option
For those with limited space in stalls or small pens, a wall-mounted feeder is often the most practical solution. The Little Giant Wall Feeder is a popular choice because it gets the entire unit off the floor, freeing up valuable real estate and making stall cleaning much easier. It’s typically made of heavy-duty wire or steel rods welded to a solid backplate.
The design keeps hay contained and off the ground, which is crucial for preventing parasite transmission and waste. By mounting it at the proper height, you can make it comfortable for adults to eat from while discouraging kids from trying to climb in. It’s a simple, effective tool for a few goats in a confined area.
However, its strength is also its weakness. A wall feeder is only as strong as its mounting. If you just use a few screws into a plywood wall, an aggressive goat will rip it down in a week. It must be secured with heavy-duty lag bolts directly into solid wall studs or posts to have any chance of survival. It also holds less hay than a large bunk feeder, requiring more frequent refills.
Behlen Country 3-in-1: For Hay, Grain, and Mineral
Efficiency is the name of the game on a hobby farm, and consolidating tasks saves precious time. The Behlen Country 3-in-1 feeder does exactly that by combining a hay rack, a grain trough, and a mineral pan into a single, freestanding unit. This creates a one-stop-shop for nutrition, simplifying your daily chores.
This feeder is typically built tough, with a sturdy frame designed to be placed in the middle of a pen. The all-in-one design can also help prevent waste, as any hay that drops from the rack often falls directly into the grain trough below, where it’s likely to be eaten instead of trampled.
The primary consideration here is herd dynamics. A single, combined feeder can be easily monopolized by a dominant herd queen, who may prevent more timid goats from getting their share of grain or minerals. You have to be sure your management style allows for this, or be prepared to supervise feedings to ensure everyone gets access.
Sioux Steel Goat Feeder: Maximum Durability Pick
When all else has failed and you’re on your third feeder in two years, it might be time to bring in the heavy artillery. Sioux Steel is known for producing equipment that borders on indestructible, and their goat feeders are no exception. These are often made from the thickest gauge steel you can find, with robust welds and designs that anticipate the worst a goat can do.
These feeders are characterized by their sheer weight and overbuilt nature. They often feature extra reinforcements, rounded top bars to prevent perching, and smart designs that minimize waste while maximizing strength. This is the kind of feeder you buy once and expect it to last for decades, not just seasons.
Of course, this level of durability comes at a premium. Sioux Steel feeders are a serious investment. They are among the most expensive options on the market, and their weight makes them difficult to move. This is the right choice for someone who values long-term reliability above all else and is willing to pay for a permanent solution to a recurring problem.
Rugged Ranch Wall Hay Feeder for Reducing Waste
Waste is one of the biggest hidden costs of raising livestock. The Rugged Ranch Wall Hay Feeder directly targets this problem with a design focused on making it difficult for goats to pull out more than a mouthful at a time. The tight grid pattern forces them to work for their food, drastically cutting down on dropped and soiled hay.
This feeder is a wall-mounted unit, so it saves floor space while keeping hay clean. Its solid metal back and bottom catch loose leaves and stems, ensuring even the most valuable bits of alfalfa aren’t lost. For anyone feeding expensive, high-quality hay, the feed savings can help the feeder pay for itself over time.
The tradeoff is eating speed and potential frustration. Some goats, particularly those used to free-choice hay from a loose pile, may find the tight grid annoying. It can slow down their consumption, which may be a pro or a con depending on your management goals. It’s also less suitable for very coarse or stemmy hay, which can be difficult to pull through the small openings.
Premier 1 Supplies Feeder: Ideal for Small Herds
Not everyone needs a feeder built to withstand a herd of 200-pound Boer bucks. For smaller breeds like Nigerian Dwarfs or Pygmies, or for those with just a few goats, the thoughtfully designed equipment from Premier 1 Supplies is often a perfect fit. Their feeders are typically lighter and more manageable but still built with goat behavior in mind.
Premier 1 often focuses on smart, practical features. You might find feeders with adjustable bar spacing, keyhole mounting slots for easy removal and cleaning, or designs specifically scaled for miniature breeds. They understand the small-farm context, where ease of use and portability can be just as important as raw strength.
The clear limitation is scale and brute force. While well-made, these feeders are generally not intended for large, aggressive animals. A determined Alpine or Boer could likely damage a feeder designed for a Mini LaMancha. It’s about choosing the right tool for the job—and for a small herd, these are often the smartest, most user-friendly tools available.
Mounting Your Feeder for Maximum Goat-Proofing
The best feeder in the world is useless if it’s installed improperly. Goats will exploit any weakness, and the connection point to a wall or post is the most common point of failure for wall-mounted units. Simply put, do not use screws; use lag bolts.
Find the solid wood studs or posts in your barn wall. Drill pilot holes and secure the feeder with heavy-duty lag bolts and washers. This distributes the force across a wider area and anchors the feeder to the barn’s actual structure, not just the flimsy siding. A goat can easily rip a screw out of a single plank, but they can’t pull a lag bolt out of a 4×4 post.
Height is the other critical factor. Mount the feeder so the bottom is roughly at shoulder height for your average adult goat. This position is comfortable for them to eat from but high enough to discourage young kids from climbing in and getting stuck or soiling the feed. For freestanding bunk feeders, consider placing them on a patch of gravel or a concrete pad to prevent the area from turning into a muddy mess.
Choosing the right hay feeder is less about finding a perfect product and more about understanding the destructive genius of a goat. By matching the feeder’s design—be it a heavy-duty bunk or a space-saving wall unit—to your herd’s size, temperament, and your available space, you make an investment. It’s an investment in saved feed, saved time, and the simple peace of mind that comes from knowing your equipment will still be in one piece tomorrow morning.
