6 Best Canning Spices For Pickled Beets Your Grandmother Knew
Unlock your grandmother’s secret to perfect pickled beets. Discover the 6 classic canning spices that create that timeless, tangy-sweet flavor profile.
You’ve pulled the last of the beets from the garden, their deep red globes piled high on the kitchen counter. The satisfaction of the harvest is real, but so is the task ahead: turning this earthy bounty into something that will taste like summer in the dead of winter. The secret to truly memorable pickled beets isn’t just the vinegar and sugar; it’s the careful selection of spices your grandmother probably knew by heart.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
The Foundation of Flavor in Pickled Beets
The goal of pickling isn’t to mask the flavor of the beet, but to enhance it. Beets are naturally sweet and profoundly earthy, a combination that provides a perfect canvas for a range of spices. Your brine—the mixture of vinegar, water, sugar, and salt—is the medium, but the spices are the art.
Think of it like building a house. The beet is the land, and the brine is the foundation. The spices are the framework, the walls, and the roof that give the final product its character. Without them, you just have sweet and sour beets. With them, you have a complex, aromatic preserve that tells a story.
The key is balance. You need spices that provide warmth, some that offer a tangy bite, and others that contribute a subtle savory background. Getting this balance right is what separates a good jar of pickled beets from a great one that people ask you for year after year.
McCormick Whole Cloves: The Classic Warming Spice
There’s a reason whole cloves are in nearly every traditional pickled beet recipe. Their intense, pungent, and sweet-spicy flavor is the perfect counterpoint to the beet’s deep earthiness. They cut through the richness and add a warmth that feels essential, especially for a pantry item you’ll be opening on a cold day.
However, cloves demand respect. They are potent, and a heavy hand can quickly turn your batch from "pleasantly spiced" to "overpowering." A common mistake is adding too many, resulting in a medicinal flavor that bullies every other ingredient. As a rule of thumb, start with just 2-3 whole cloves per pint jar and adjust in future batches if you want a stronger presence.
The integrity of the spice matters, too. Using old, dusty cloves from the back of the cabinet will impart a dull, bitter flavor. Fresh, high-quality whole cloves ensure a clean, vibrant warmth that infuses the brine slowly and evenly over time. This is one area where spending a little more on a reliable brand pays dividends in the final product.
Frontier Co-op Mustard Seed for a Tangy Bite
Mustard seed is the workhorse of the pickling world. It doesn’t just add its own flavor; it brings a sharp, tangy heat that brightens the entire jar. This "bite" is crucial for cutting through the sweetness of the sugar and the beets themselves, creating a more balanced and interesting pickle.
You’ll typically find two main varieties: yellow and brown. Yellow mustard seeds are the most common, offering a classic, mild tang. Brown mustard seeds are smaller, more pungent, and deliver a spicier kick. For most pickled beet recipes, yellow is the standard, but using a mix or switching to brown can be a great way to customize your batch to your own preference.
Unlike ground mustard, which would cloud your brine, whole seeds release their flavor gradually. As the jars sit on the shelf, the seeds soften slightly and continue to infuse the vinegar. This slow release is exactly what you want for a shelf-stable preserve, ensuring the flavor is just as good in six months as it is in six weeks.
Simply Organic Allspice for Aromatic Depth
Allspice is the ultimate supporting actor in a pickling blend. Its name says it all—it tastes like a combination of cloves, cinnamon, and nutmeg. This complexity allows it to bridge the gap between the sweet, warm spices like cloves and the sharper, zesty ones like mustard seed and peppercorns.
Using whole allspice berries is non-negotiable for pickling. The ground version is far too potent and will turn your beautiful ruby brine into a muddy mess. The whole berries, much like cloves and peppercorns, release their complex oils slowly, creating layers of flavor that you can’t achieve with a single spice.
While you could try to replicate its flavor by adding a pinch of cinnamon and nutmeg, it’s never quite the same. Allspice provides a unique aromatic quality that adds a subtle, almost mysterious depth. Just a couple of whole berries per pint jar is enough to round out the flavor profile without taking center stage.
The Spice Way Star Anise for a Sweet Twist
Add a unique licorice flavor to your cooking and baking with The Spice Way Star Anise. Packed fresh in small batches, our premium star anise is pure, with no additives or preservatives.
If you want to move beyond the traditional and create a pickled beet with a truly memorable flavor, consider star anise. This isn’t a spice found in most old-school American recipes, but its sweet, licorice-like notes are a stunning match for the natural sugariness of beets. It introduces an unexpected layer of warmth and sweetness that is both familiar and exotic.
The key with star anise is extreme moderation. Its flavor is powerful and can easily dominate everything else in the jar. For most batches, one single pod per quart jar (or half a pod per pint) is more than enough to impart its unique character without tasting like licorice candy.
Think of star anise as a specialty ingredient. It’s perfect for a smaller, experimental batch or for creating a "signature" pickled beet to give as gifts. It pairs exceptionally well with other warming spices like clove and allspice, creating a rich, dessert-like aroma that makes your pickled beets stand out.
Morton & Bassett Bay Leaves for Earthy Notes
Bay leaf is the quiet, foundational element in your pickling spice blend. Its contribution is savory and herbal, an earthy note that grounds the sweeter spices and complements the beets themselves. You might not be able to pick out its specific flavor in the finished product, but you would certainly notice its absence.
A single dried bay leaf in a quart jar adds a subtle complexity, preventing the brine from becoming too one-dimensionally sweet or spicy. It works in the background, weaving the other flavors together. It’s the ingredient that makes people pause and wonder, "What is that delicious, savory note in there?"
Be sure to use whole, uncracked leaves. Broken pieces will be difficult to fish out later and can release a slightly more bitter flavor. Quality matters here; a brittle, pale leaf has lost most of its essential oils and won’t contribute much. A pliable, olive-green leaf will provide the best, most balanced flavor.
Spicewalla Peppercorns for a Zesty Finish
No pickling recipe is complete without the clean, sharp heat of peppercorns. They provide the final zesty kick that lifts the entire flavor profile. For canning, always use whole peppercorns, as ground pepper will create a cloudy, unappealing brine and can impart a bitter taste over time.
While standard black peppercorns are excellent, this is an easy place to introduce more complexity.
- Tellicherry peppercorns are left on the vine longer, developing a deeper, more complex, and almost fruity flavor.
- A mix of black, white, green, and pink peppercorns can add visual appeal and a more nuanced spectrum of heat and flavor.
The heat from peppercorns is different from that of mustard seed. It’s a sharper, more direct spice that hits the back of the palate. Including both in your blend creates a more dynamic and satisfying experience, ensuring your pickled beets are anything but bland.
Creating Your Own Ball Pickling Spice Blend
Buying a pre-made pickling spice is convenient, but making your own gives you complete control. It allows you to adjust the ratios to your exact liking and ensures every single ingredient is fresh and potent. You can make a large batch at the beginning of the season and have it ready for whatever you decide to pickle.
A great starting point for a classic blend is a ratio built around the most dominant flavors. Think in "parts" which could be anything from a teaspoon to a cup, depending on how much you’re making.
- 2 parts Mustard Seed
- 2 parts Whole Black Peppercorns
- 1 part Whole Allspice Berries
- 1 part Whole Cloves
- Crumbled Bay Leaves and other additions to taste
This is just a template. If you love a spicy kick, increase the peppercorns or add a few dried chili flakes. If you prefer a warmer, sweeter profile, slightly increase the allspice. Keep notes on your blends from year to year. This is how family recipes are born—not by following a book, but by tasting, tweaking, and making it your own.
In the end, the best spices are the ones that make a jar of pickled beets taste exactly how you want them to. By understanding what each spice brings to the brine, you can move beyond simply following a recipe to creating a preserve that truly reflects your garden and your palate. That jar, opened on a dark February evening, is more than just food; it’s a direct link back to the hard work and satisfaction of a summer harvest.
