6 Best Smoker Comparisons For Choosing The Right One Old-Timers Swear By
We compare 6 classic smokers seasoned pitmasters swear by. This guide breaks down fuel type, build, and flavor to help you choose the right one.
You’ve just finished processing a hog or a few dozen chickens, and the freezer is full. Now you’re looking at the bellies, the hams, and the extra birds, thinking about turning that harvest into something truly special. Choosing the right smoker isn’t just about buying another piece of equipment; it’s about honoring the work you put into raising that animal. It’s the final step in the farm-to-table journey, and the tool you choose will define the flavor and your experience.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Why Classic Smoker Designs Endure on the Farm
Out on the farm, you learn to value things that are simple, repairable, and built to last. That’s why old-timer smoker designs stick around. They don’t have digital control boards that can fry in a thunderstorm or proprietary parts you can’t find five years from now.
These classic smokers are built from steel, ceramic, or other durable materials. They operate on the simple principles of fire, airflow, and time. If something goes wrong, you can usually figure it out with a little common sense, not a customer service hotline.
This focus on fundamentals means you learn the craft of smoking, not just how to push a button. You learn to manage a fire, read the smoke, and understand how weather affects your cook. That’s a skill, and like most things on a farm, a valuable skill is worth more than a fancy gadget.
Oklahoma Joe’s Highland for Offset Stick Burning
The offset smoker is what most people picture when they think of traditional barbecue. You build a small, clean-burning fire with wood splits in the firebox, and the heat and smoke draft across the main chamber to cook the meat. The Oklahoma Joe’s Highland is a widely available and affordable entry into this world.
Using an offset is a hands-on process. You aren’t setting a dial and walking away; you’re managing a live fire for hours, adding a log every 45-60 minutes. It demands your attention. The reward for this effort is an unmatched, deep smoke flavor that you can only get from burning pure hardwood.
This smoker is for the person who has a ready supply of seasoned hardwood like oak or hickory and enjoys the process as much as the result. It has a large capacity, perfect for smoking a whole hog shoulder or multiple briskets after a harvest. It’s a commitment, but the flavor is legendary.
Weber Smokey Mountain: The Reliable Water Smoker
The Weber Smokey Mountain, or WSM, is the definition of a reliable workhorse. This bullet-shaped charcoal smoker is famous for its ability to hold a steady low-and-slow temperature for 8-12 hours on a single load of fuel. It’s incredibly efficient and forgiving.
Its secret is the large water pan that sits between the charcoal and the meat. The water absorbs and radiates heat, creating a stable, humid cooking environment that prevents meat from drying out. This makes it almost foolproof for long cooks like pork butt or brisket.
The WSM is for the farmer who wants consistently great barbecue without having to babysit a fire all day. You can load it up, get the temperature dialed in, and go about your chores, checking on it only occasionally. It’s less about the romance of fire-tending and more about dependable, delicious results with minimal fuss.
Pit Barrel Cooker: Simple, Effective Drum Smoking
Drum smokers operate on a beautifully simple principle: hang the meat vertically over a charcoal basket and let convection do the work. The Pit Barrel Cooker (PBC) perfected this concept, creating a smoker that’s incredibly easy to use and produces fantastic results.
Because the meat hangs, juices drip down, hit the hot coals, and create a flavorful steam that rises back up to baste the meat. This process cooks food surprisingly fast and keeps it exceptionally moist. There are no vents to fiddle with; it’s designed to run at a consistent temperature right out of the box.
The PBC is ideal for anyone short on space or time. It’s perfect for smoking chickens, racks of ribs, or pork shoulders. If you value efficiency and don’t want to overcomplicate things, this is your smoker. It proves that you don’t need a complex setup to make world-class barbecue.
The Big Green Egg: A Versatile Kamado Classic
The Big Green Egg is the most well-known of the kamado-style cookers, which are based on ancient clay oven designs. Made from thick, heavy-duty ceramic, these cookers are unmatched in their insulation and heat retention. They are incredibly fuel-efficient, able to hold a low temperature for over 18 hours on one load of lump charcoal.
This isn’t just a smoker; it’s a complete outdoor cooking system. It can hold 225°F for a pork butt or reach over 700°F for searing a steak. You can bake bread in it, cook a pizza, or grill vegetables. The thick ceramic walls create a radiant heat that cooks food evenly and keeps it incredibly juicy.
The downside is the high price and the weight—you won’t be moving it around easily. A kamado is a long-term investment for the person who wants one versatile tool for all their outdoor cooking needs. It’s the "buy once, cry once" option that will likely outlast you.
Masterbuilt Electric for Curing Meats and Fish
Sometimes, barbecue isn’t the goal. When you’re curing your own bacon, making smoked sausage, or preserving a catch of fish, you need precise, low-temperature control that traditional smokers can’t easily provide. This is where a simple electric smoker, like those from Masterbuilt, shines.
These are essentially insulated boxes with an electric heating element and a small tray for wood chips. You can set the temperature to 150°F and hold it there for hours, generating a consistent, gentle smoke. This is critical for safely curing and drying meats without cooking them through.
An electric smoker is a specialized tool, not an all-purpose barbecue pit. It won’t give you a beautiful smoke ring on a brisket. But for the homesteader focused on preservation, it is an indispensable piece of equipment for turning pork belly into bacon or salmon into lox.
Traeger Pro Series: Consistent Pellet-Fired BBQ
Achieve wood-fired flavor effortlessly with the Traeger Pro 22 pellet grill. This 6-in-1 BBQ offers precise temperature control and a large 572 sq. in. cooking area for versatile grilling, smoking, and more.
Pellet smokers have become the modern standard for convenience. A unit like the Traeger Pro Series uses a digital controller to automatically feed hardwood pellets into a fire pot, maintaining a precise temperature you set on a dial. It’s as easy to use as a kitchen oven.
The main advantage is consistency. A pellet smoker removes the variables of fire management, allowing you to produce great results every single time, regardless of your skill level. It’s perfect for the busy farmer who wants to put a brisket on in the morning and know it will be perfectly cooked by dinner without any intervention.
The tradeoffs are a reliance on electricity and a milder smoke flavor compared to a stick burner. You also have to buy the pellets, unlike an offset where you might use wood from your own property. This is the choice for someone who prioritizes convenience and repeatability above all else.
Choosing Your Smoker: Fuel, Time, and Purpose
There is no single "best" smoker; there’s only the best smoker for you. The right choice comes down to balancing three factors: your fuel, your time, and your primary goal.
First, consider your fuel. Do you have acres of free hardwood? An offset stick burner turns that resource into amazing flavor. If you prefer the convenience of buying a bag of fuel, charcoal or pellets are your answer. If you’re focused on curing, electricity is the most practical.
Next, be honest about your time. If you enjoy the craft of tending a fire all day, the offset is for you. If you need to set it and get back to your chores, a pellet grill, electric smoker, or a water smoker like the Weber Smokey Mountain is a much better fit.
Finally, what will you be smoking most often?
- Large cuts & big crowds: An offset or a large kamado offers the most space.
- All-around versatility: A kamado like the Big Green Egg can grill, smoke, and bake.
- Cured meats & fish: An electric smoker provides essential low-temperature control.
- Maximum convenience: A pellet grill delivers consistent results with push-button ease.
Think through these questions, and the right choice for your farm will become clear. It’s not about finding a perfect smoker, but the perfect partner for your lifestyle and goals.
In the end, the smoker you choose is a tool for transforming your hard work into something memorable. Whether it’s the deep, smoky bark from an offset or the perfectly cured bacon from an electric, the right smoker helps you close the loop on your food production. It’s one of the most rewarding ways to enjoy the harvest and share it with family and friends.
