6 Best Oil Based Fly Sprays For Goats That Old-Timers Swear By
Oil-based fly sprays offer superior, lasting protection for goats. We explore 6 traditional formulas that seasoned keepers rely on for effective pest control.
Nothing ruins a peaceful morning on the farm faster than the sight of your goats stomping, twitching, and shaking their heads relentlessly. The constant buzz and bite of flies isn’t just an annoyance; it’s a direct threat to their health, comfort, and productivity. For generations, old-timers have known that the secret to a lasting fly spray isn’t just what’s in it, but what makes it stick.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Why Oil-Based Sprays Stick and Protect Goats
The simple genius of an oil-based fly spray is its staying power. Unlike water-based formulas that evaporate within an hour or wash off in the morning dew, oil-based sprays adhere directly to the hair shaft. This creates a lasting barrier that keeps the active ingredients right where they need to be.
This oily film does more than just hold the repellents. It also provides a physical barrier that can suffocate smaller pests like gnats and no-see-ums on contact. Plus, it gives your goats’ coats a healthy sheen, which is a nice bonus. When a summer thunderstorm rolls through, you can bet the oil-based spray will still be offering some protection long after a water-based one has washed away.
The key is understanding that this persistence is both a pro and a con. The oil can attract dust and dirt, and you need to be careful applying it in the hot sun to avoid sunburn. But for sheer, long-lasting effectiveness against biting flies, nothing beats a good oil base.
Pyranha Wipe N’ Spray: A Classic Farm Favorite
Walk into almost any seasoned farmer’s barn, and you’re likely to find a distinctive yellow and red can of Pyranha. This stuff is a legend for a reason. It’s a potent, pyrethrin-based formula with a heavy oil base and a strong citronella scent that flies seem to hate.
Its versatility is a major selling point. You can mist it on from a distance for general coverage or spray it onto a cloth and wipe it carefully around the face and ears. This wipe-on method is perfect for goats, as they often dislike being sprayed directly in the face, and it ensures you get coverage right where those pesky face flies congregate.
Be warned: Pyranha is strong. It’s designed for quick knockdown and lasting repellency, which means it’s not something you should use on very young kids or goats with sensitive skin without doing a patch test first. For healthy, mature goats under heavy fly attack, however, it’s one of the most reliable tools in the arsenal.
Farnam Bronco Gold Equine Fly Spray for Goats
Don’t let the horse on the label fool you. Many of the most effective and trusted products in a goat owner’s cabinet are technically "equine" sprays. Old-timers learned long ago that what works to keep a horse from stomping flies works just as well to give a goat some peace.
Bronco Gold is a step up from the classic white-bottle Bronco, offering a more robust oil base that improves its longevity. It provides a quick knockdown of flies on contact and leaves behind a repellent shield that holds up well to sun and moisture. It’s a solid, middle-of-the-road option that balances potency with a more pleasant scent than some of the harsher products.
As with any off-label use, common sense is your best guide. Always perform a small spot test on one goat before spraying your whole herd to check for any skin reaction. For most herds, Bronco Gold is a dependable workhorse spray that gets the job done without breaking the bank.
Absorbine UltraShield EX for Intense Fly Seasons
When the fly season hits its peak and you’re dealing with relentless swarms of horse flies, deer flies, and horn flies, you need to bring out the heavy artillery. Absorbine UltraShield EX is that heavy artillery. It’s known for its powerful, multi-ingredient formula and its claim of long-lasting, weatherproof protection.
While the label might promise over two weeks of protection, real-world farm use puts it closer to three to five days, especially in hot, humid weather. Still, that’s a huge improvement over sprays that barely last a day. The formula is designed to bind to the hair shaft and resist sweat and rain, making it ideal for goats out on pasture.
This is not your everyday, gentle fly spray. UltraShield EX is a solution for intense problems. Use it when the fly load is causing visible distress, weight loss, or preventing your goats from grazing peacefully. Because of its strength, it’s crucial to apply it sparingly and avoid sensitive areas, especially on your dairy does near the udder.
The Old-Timer’s Skin So Soft & Vinegar Mix
Long before specialized fly sprays filled the shelves at the feed store, farmers made do with what they had. One of the most enduring DIY recipes is a simple mix of Avon’s Skin So Soft bath oil, apple cider vinegar (ACV), and water, sometimes with a dash of citronella oil.
The theory is simple: the Skin So Soft provides the oily base to make the mixture stick, while its scent and the scent of the ACV act as repellents. This isn’t a chemical insecticide that kills flies on contact. It’s a repellent that makes your goats a less appealing target.
This mixture is best suited for situations with low to moderate fly pressure. Its biggest advantage is that you know exactly what’s in it, and it’s very gentle on the skin. The tradeoff is that it requires frequent reapplication, often daily, to remain effective. It’s a great choice for those who prefer a non-pesticide approach and don’t mind the extra labor.
A Homesteader’s DIY Neem & Cedarwood Spray
For the modern homesteader who likes to blend traditional wisdom with natural ingredients, a neem and cedarwood oil spray is a powerful alternative. This DIY mix leverages the well-known insecticidal properties of neem oil with the repellent qualities of essential oils.
A common recipe involves mixing a carrier oil (like fractionated coconut oil) with water, a small amount of pure, cold-pressed neem oil, and a few drops of cedarwood and lemongrass essential oils. A squirt of a mild, natural soap helps emulsify the oil and water. Neem oil disrupts the life cycle of many insects, while cedarwood is particularly effective against ticks and gnats.
Like any DIY solution, results can vary based on the quality of your ingredients and your specific fly situation. Proper dilution is critical, as concentrated essential oils can irritate a goat’s skin. This is the perfect option for the farmer who wants total control over their inputs and is committed to an all-natural approach to herd health.
Espree Aloe Herbal: A Gentle, Natural Option
If you like the idea of a natural spray but don’t want the hassle of mixing your own, Espree’s Aloe Herbal Horse Spray is an excellent choice. It’s another "equine" product that has found a happy home in the goat barn. Its formula is built around gentle, natural oils like citronella, cedarwood, and eucalyptus.
The inclusion of aloe vera makes this spray particularly soothing to the skin, which is a huge benefit for goats who may already have irritation from fly bites. It’s not an oily, greasy spray, but it uses the natural oils as its active ingredients, providing a pleasant-smelling repellent barrier.
Think of this as your maintenance spray. It’s perfect for daily use, for sensitive-skinned animals, and for dairy goats where you want to avoid harsh chemicals around milking time. It won’t hold up to a swarm of horse flies like UltraShield, but for keeping common stable flies at bay, it’s a fantastic, gentle option.
Safe Application Tips for Your Goat Herd Health
No matter which spray you choose, applying it correctly is just as important as the product itself. The goal is to protect your goats, not cause them more stress or harm. A little bit of care during application goes a long way toward ensuring your herd’s health and well-being.
Follow these simple rules for safe and effective application:
- Always patch test. Before dousing a new goat, apply a small amount to one spot and wait 24 hours to check for any irritation or allergic reaction.
- Protect the face. Never spray directly at a goat’s head. Instead, spray the product onto a soft cloth or a gloved hand and gently wipe it around their eyes, ears, and muzzle, avoiding direct contact with the membranes.
- Avoid application in direct sun. The combination of hot sun and oil-based sprays can, in some cases, cause sunburn on light-skinned goats. Apply in the cooler morning or evening hours.
- Check your dairy does. If you’re milking, be extra careful. Avoid spraying the udder and teats, and always check the product label for any milk withdrawal times.
- Fly spray is one tool, not the whole solution. The best defense is an integrated one. Combine your spray routine with good manure management, fly traps, and clean bedding to reduce the overall fly population on your farm.
Ultimately, the "best" fly spray is the one that works for your specific herd, your environment, and your management style. Whether you reach for a heavy-duty commercial product or mix up a batch of your own, the goal is the same: to give your goats relief. A comfortable goat is a healthy and productive goat, and keeping the flies off is one of the most important jobs we have during the long summer months.
