6 Best Electric Fence Collars For Goats Escaping Fences For Stubborn Goats
For stubborn goats that challenge fences, an electric collar is key. We analyze the 6 best options, focusing on durability, range, and effectiveness.
There’s a special kind of frustration that comes from seeing your prize doe standing on the wrong side of a fence she shouldn’t have been able to cross. You’ve checked the physical fence, patched the holes, and even added another hot wire, but she still finds a way out. For these master escape artists, a standard electric fence just isn’t enough of a deterrent. This is where an electric fence collar, also known as an e-collar or containment system, becomes a necessary tool for keeping your most stubborn goats safe and secure.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
When to Consider an Electric Collar for Goats
An electric collar is a tool of last resort, not a replacement for a good physical fence. Before you even consider one, your primary barrier needs to be sound. Walk your fence line, check for gaps, and ensure your charger is putting out a proper shock. A containment collar is meant to reinforce a boundary, not create one from scratch.
Think of it as adding a psychological barrier where a physical one is failing. This is for the goat that leans through woven wire until it pops, the one that patiently tests every inch of electric netting, or the crafty buck that has figured out how to shimmy under a gate. It’s a solution for a specific behavioral problem, not a general fencing shortcut.
It’s also crucial to understand that these systems are designed for dogs. This means you must pay close attention to fit and contact. A goat’s thick hair, especially a winter coat, can prevent the collar’s contact points from touching the skin, rendering it useless. You’ll need to trim a small patch of hair on the neck and ensure the collar is snug—but not too tight—to get reliable performance.
PetSafe Stubborn Dog: A Top All-Around Pick
If you’re looking for a reliable, widely available system that gets the job done, the PetSafe Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence is a solid choice. It’s designed specifically for hard-to-train animals, offering four higher-intensity static correction levels plus a tone and vibration-only mode for training. This flexibility is key for goats, as you can start low and only increase the level if absolutely necessary.
The collar itself is waterproof and durable, which is essential for an animal that lives outdoors 24/7. The system typically comes with enough wire to cover about a third of an acre, but it’s expandable up to 25 acres with the purchase of more wire. This makes it scalable for most hobby farm layouts, from a small buck pen to a larger pasture perimeter.
The main tradeoff is the proprietary battery. While they last for a few months, you can’t just run to the store for a standard AA. However, for its balance of features, effectiveness on stubborn animals, and widespread availability, it’s an excellent starting point for solving a persistent escape problem.
SportDOG In-Ground Fence for Rugged Use
For those with rougher terrain or who are just plain hard on equipment, the SportDOG In-Ground Fence system is built to take a beating. SportDOG’s reputation is built on gear for hunting dogs, so everything from the wire to the collar is designed for durability. The collar is not just waterproof but fully submersible, a feature you’ll appreciate after a week of heavy rain.
This system’s real advantage lies in its robust components. The included boundary wire is often a heavier gauge than what comes with standard kits, meaning it’s less likely to break during installation or from future frost heave. The transmitter is also powerful, capable of covering up to 100 acres with additional wire, and includes built-in lightning protection—a non-trivial feature for farm equipment.
The higher-end build quality comes with a slightly higher price tag. But if you’ve had issues with wire breaks in the past or your property includes wooded areas, creeks, or rocky soil, the investment in a tougher system like this one pays for itself. This is the choice for a "buy it once, cry once" approach to containment.
Extreme Dog Fence: For Large Acreage Needs
When your pasture is measured in multiple acres, not just square feet, you need a system designed for distance. The Extreme Dog Fence kits are specifically packaged for this purpose, with some bundles covering up to 25 acres right out of the box. Their transmitters are powerful enough to maintain a consistent signal over very long wire runs.
The standout feature is the quality of the wire included in their kits. They often provide heavy-duty 14-gauge wire, which is significantly more durable than the standard 20-gauge wire found in most basic systems. This thicker wire is more resistant to damage from weather, burrowing animals, or accidental scrapes from equipment, which is a major consideration on a large, working property.
This system is overkill for a small paddock. But if you’re trying to contain a herd within a large, multi-acre pasture and want to reinforce the entire perimeter, this is the most practical and reliable way to do it. The initial cost is higher, but it’s far more effective than trying to stretch a smaller, less powerful system beyond its intended limits.
Educator ET-300: For Targeted Fence Training
Train your dog effectively with the Mini Educator ET-300 e-collar. This waterproof system features a half-mile range, 100 training levels, plus vibration and tone modes, and includes a training clicker for positive reinforcement.
Sometimes the problem isn’t the entire fence line, but one specific corner or gate your goat loves to test. In this case, a full in-ground containment system might be more than you need. The Educator ET-300 is a remote training collar, not a containment fence, and it gives you direct control for targeted training sessions.
Instead of an automatic correction at a boundary, you manually trigger a stimulation when you see the goat approaching the problem area. The Educator is known for its "blunt" stimulation, which is less sharp than a typical shock, and a unique "tapping" vibration that’s often enough to get an animal’s attention without any static at all. This allows for more nuanced communication with your animal.
This is a hands-on approach. It requires you to be present and observant, ready to provide a correction at the right moment. It’s not a set-it-and-forget-it solution. But for teaching a goat that a specific gate is off-limits or for reinforcing a weak spot in a cross-fence, a remote trainer offers a level of precision that an automated system can’t match.
PetSafe Wireless Fence: Easiest Installation
If the thought of trenching or burying hundreds of feet of wire is a non-starter, the PetSafe Wireless Fence offers a compelling alternative. There is no wire to bury. You simply plug in the base station transmitter inside your barn or house, and it projects a circular radio boundary. Installation takes minutes, not hours.
This system is ideal for temporary setups, renters, or creating a safe zone within a larger pasture. You can easily adjust the radius of the circle, making it flexible for different needs. Because it’s portable, you can take it with you if you move or use it to create a temporary pen while visiting another farm.
However, the convenience comes with major limitations. The boundary is a circle, which rarely matches property lines, and it’s not suitable for properties with significant slopes, metal buildings, or dense trees, as these can interfere with the radio signal and create inconsistent boundaries. Use this for simple, open, and relatively flat areas only.
Garmin Delta XC: A Versatile Training Tool
Like the Educator, the Garmin Delta XC is a remote training collar, not a containment system. It’s a high-quality, versatile tool for the farmer who wants more than just boundary enforcement. Garmin is a leader in GPS and outdoor tech, and that quality is evident in the build and functionality of their training collars.
The Delta XC offers multiple correction types—tone, vibration, and 18 levels of momentary or continuous static stimulation. This range allows you to find the absolute lowest level of correction that works for your specific goat. The compact, intuitive remote is easy to use with one hand, which is a big deal when you’re also holding a lead rope or a feed bucket.
This is an investment in a multi-purpose tool. You can use it to reinforce fence boundaries, but also to correct other behaviors like jumping on people or aggressive head-butting. If you see value in having a reliable training aid for various aspects of herd management, the Garmin is an excellent, durable, and feature-rich option.
Safely Training Your Goat to the New Boundary
Putting a collar on a goat and hoping for the best is a recipe for failure. Proper training is what makes these systems work humanely and effectively. The goal is for the goat to learn and respect the boundary, not to live in fear of a random shock.
First, let the goat wear the collar (turned off) for a few days to get used to it. While it’s wearing the collar, use training flags to create a clear visual line a few feet inside the actual wire boundary. This gives the goat a visual cue to associate with the correction.
Next, walk the goat on a lead rope up to the flagged boundary. When you reach the flags, the collar’s warning tone will sound. As soon as it does, say "No!" and gently pull the goat back away from the flags. Praise it for moving back. Repeat this process multiple times in different areas over several days. The vast majority of animals learn from the tone and pressure alone and will rarely, if ever, receive a static correction. Patience during this phase is the single most important factor for success.
Ultimately, an electric fence collar is just one tool in your larger farm management toolkit. Whether you need the rugged durability of a SportDOG, the large-acreage capacity of an Extreme Dog Fence, or the targeted training of an Educator, the right choice depends entirely on your property and your specific problem animal. By pairing the right technology with patient, consistent training, you can finally keep that stubborn escape artist safely where they belong.
