6 Best Sweet Cicely Plants for Desserts
Explore 6 thriving Sweet Cicely varieties. These easy-to-grow herbs offer a unique anise flavor, perfect for enhancing your favorite dessert recipes.
You’ve just pulled a perfect rhubarb crumble from the oven, but something is missing. You’re craving that subtle, sweet anise note that cuts through the tartness, a flavor you can’t quite find in a spice jar. The real magic comes from the garden, but finding the right plant—one that actually thrives in your specific conditions—is the real challenge. This isn’t just about finding one plant; it’s about building a small arsenal of anise-flavored herbs to suit every dessert and every corner of your property.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Understanding True Sweet Cicely (Myrrhis odorata)
True Sweet Cicely is the benchmark for a reason. Its flavor is a delicate, sugary anise with a fresh, green background, almost like a blend of fennel and celery with a spoonful of sugar. The entire plant is edible, from the fern-like leaves to the hollow stems, which can be used as a natural, flavorful straw.
This plant is a true perennial, a "plant it once and enjoy it for years" addition to the garden. But it has non-negotiable demands. Sweet Cicely requires cool, moist, and partially shaded conditions to thrive. It will languish and burn in a hot, sun-baked spot, making it a poor choice for many open-field gardens.
Think of it as a woodland edge plant. It’s perfect for that damp corner near a downspout or under the dappled light of a fruit tree. Getting it started can be a test of patience, as seeds require a period of cold stratification, but once established from a division or a nursery plant, it’s a low-maintenance source of sophisticated flavor.
‘Blue Fortune’ Anise Hyssop: A Hardy Cicely Ally
If your garden is the polar opposite of a cool, shady woodland, Anise Hyssop (Agastache foeniculum) is your answer. This plant is a workhorse. It loves full sun, tolerates lean soil, and stands up to drought once it’s established.
The flavor is a more direct, potent licorice-anise, less subtle than Sweet Cicely but incredibly useful. The leaves are fantastic for infusing simple syrups or teas, and the beautiful purple flower spikes are also edible, making a stunning garnish for cakes and fruit salads. Unlike the delicate nature of Sweet Cicely, Anise Hyssop is robust and forgiving.
Beyond the kitchen, this plant is a pollinator powerhouse. A stand of Anise Hyssop will be buzzing with bees from mid-summer until frost, making it a valuable addition to any hobby farm ecosystem. It’s a plant that works for you on multiple levels—flavor for the house and food for the beneficial insects.
‘Smokey’ Bronze Fennel: A Bold Anise Alternative
Bronze Fennel (Foeniculum vulgare ‘Purpureum’) brings both drama and intense flavor. Its feathery, smoke-colored foliage is a showstopper in the garden, and the flavor of its fronds is a pure, powerful anise. This is not a subtle herb; a little goes a very long way when minced into shortcakes or whipped into cream.
Be aware of its growth habit. Fennel is often grown as an annual, but it’s technically a short-lived perennial that will readily self-seed if you let the flowers mature. This can be a blessing, giving you a steady supply of new plants, or a curse, as it can start to pop up where you don’t want it. Decide early if you will deadhead it for control or let it naturalize.
One critical piece of farm wisdom: do not plant fennel near your dill. They are close relatives and will cross-pollinate, resulting in seeds and foliage with a muddled, unpleasant flavor. Give them plenty of space to keep both herbs true to type.
‘Vertissimo’ Chervil for Delicate, Cicely-like Notes
For those who find fennel too bold, Chervil (Anthriscus cerefolium) offers a whisper of anise. Its flavor is remarkably similar to Sweet Cicely—sweet, delicate, with hints of parsley and licorice. It’s the perfect finishing herb, meant to be sprinkled on fresh fruit or folded into a gentle custard at the last minute.
Chervil is a cool-season annual. This is its defining characteristic and its primary challenge. It bolts and turns bitter the moment the weather gets hot. You can’t plant it once in May and expect it to last all summer.
The key to a steady supply is succession planting. Sow a short row of seeds every two to three weeks, starting in early spring. Find a spot with afternoon shade to prolong its season. It’s more work, but the reward is a uniquely refined flavor that heat-loving herbs simply can’t replicate.
OCALA Star Anise Shrub for Southern Gardens
For gardeners in warmer climates (zones 7-10), where cool-weather herbs like Sweet Cicely are a fantasy, the Ocala Star Anise Shrub (Illicium parviflorum ‘OCALA’) is a game-changer. This is a tough, evergreen native shrub whose leaves carry a wonderful, authentic root beer and anise scent. It provides a year-round source of flavor in climates that are hostile to more traditional herbs.
This plant solves a major problem: it provides anise flavor from a low-maintenance, woody perennial that thrives in the heat and humidity of the South. The leaves can be used to infuse milk for ice cream or to make a fragrant simple syrup.
A crucial safety note is in order: this is NOT the same plant as the culinary spice Star Anise (Illicium verum). Furthermore, other related Illicium species, like the Japanese Star Anise, are highly toxic. Be absolutely certain you are growing Illicium parviflorum from a reputable nursery source.
French Tarragon: A Sophisticated Anise Flavor
French Tarragon (Artemisia dracunculus ‘Sativa’) is the gourmet choice. Its flavor is complex and layered—a warm, smooth anise note with a peppery finish that is completely unique. It’s less sweet than its counterparts, making it brilliant for balancing rich, creamy desserts like crème brûlée or panna cotta.
This herb has two quirks you must respect. First, it demands sharp, well-drained soil and will quickly rot in heavy, wet clay. Raised beds or sandy loam are its best friends.
Second, true French Tarragon cannot be grown from seed. Any seeds sold as "Tarragon" will produce the nearly flavorless Russian variety. You must buy a plant or get a division from a fellow gardener. It’s a bit of extra effort, but the sophisticated flavor is absolutely worth it.
Growing Anise-Flavored Herbs in Part-Shade
The standard advice to plant herbs in "full sun" is an oversimplification that ignores the reality of most gardens. Many of the best anise-flavored plants actually prefer or tolerate some shade, which is great news for utilizing less-than-perfect spots on your property.
For those shady, damp areas, your choices are clear:
- True Sweet Cicely is the star performer here.
- Chervil also thrives in cooler, shaded spots, which helps delay bolting.
For areas with morning sun and afternoon shade, you have more flexibility. Anise Hyssop and Bronze Fennel will still grow well, though they may be slightly less vigorous than in full sun. French Tarragon also appreciates some relief from scorching afternoon heat, especially in warmer zones. Matching the plant to the available light is more efficient than trying to change the site to fit the plant.
Harvesting and Using Your Anise Herb Garden
Harvesting these herbs correctly is key to capturing their peak flavor. The best time is in the morning, after the dew has dried but before the sun gets hot and begins to volatilize the essential oils. Use sharp scissors or snips to make clean cuts.
For the leafy herbs—Sweet Cicely, Fennel fronds, Chervil, and Tarragon—fresh is always best. Their delicate flavors diminish significantly when dried. Chop them just before using to release their aromatic oils. Anise Hyssop is more versatile; its leaves and flowers are both potent and can be used fresh or dried for tea. With the Ocala Star Anise shrub, you can pluck a few leaves anytime to infuse into liquids.
Think beyond simple chopping. Muddle the leaves of Anise Hyssop or Sweet Cicely with sugar to top a bowl of berries. Infuse whole sprigs of Tarragon or Fennel into a simple syrup for cocktails or for poaching fruit. The goal is to transfer that beautiful, garden-grown anise flavor into your dessert in the most direct and delicious way possible.
The best anise-flavored plant isn’t a single species; it’s the one that fits the climate, soil, and light you already have. By choosing the right herb for the right spot, you move from fighting your garden to working with it. The result is a richer, more diverse palette of flavors ready to elevate your kitchen creations with minimal effort.
