6 Best Shallot Sets For Gourmet Cooking Old-World Chefs Recommend

You can follow a recipe to the letter, but if your ingredients lack character, the dish will always fall flat. This is especially true for alliums, the flavor base of so many great meals. Growing your own shallots isn’t just about saving a few dollars; it’s about accessing a world of flavor that grocery stores simply don’t offer.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why True Shallots Are a Chef’s Secret Weapon

Let’s clear something up right away: the best shallots are grown from bulbs, or "sets," not from seed. These are "true" shallots, vegetatively propagated for generations to preserve their unique qualities. A shallot grown from seed is essentially a specific type of onion, lacking the complex, delicate flavor that makes a true shallot so special.

A true shallot has a flavor profile that sits perfectly between garlic and onion, but it’s more refined than both. It’s less pungent and aggressive than an onion, with a subtle sweetness that deepens beautifully when cooked. When a recipe calls for a shallot, this is the flavor it’s aiming for—a sophisticated foundation that elevates other ingredients without overpowering them.

This nuance is why chefs prize them. A raw shallot, thinly sliced, adds a delicate bite to a vinaigrette without the harshness of raw onion. Sautéed, it melts into a sweet, aromatic base for sauces and sautés. For the home cook, growing your own means this secret weapon is always just a few steps from your kitchen door.

French Gray Shallot: The Ultimate Gourmet Flavor

If you ask a classically trained chef to name the one true shallot, they will almost certainly say the French Gray, or griselle. This is the pinnacle of shallot flavor. It possesses an intensely rich, complex taste with hints of hazelnut and a creamy texture that is simply unmatched. It’s assertive yet refined, and it’s the standard by which all other shallots are judged.

But perfection comes with a price. The French Gray is a notoriously poor keeper. You’ll be lucky to get it to last until Christmas, even with perfect curing and storage. Its skin is delicate, and it’s more susceptible to rot than other varieties. Growing it is a commitment to using it relatively quickly.

So, is it worth it? Absolutely, if your goal is pure culinary excellence. Plant a small patch of French Grays for your fall and early winter feasts, sauces, and special occasion meals. Just don’t plan on them being your year-round staple. Think of it as a seasonal delicacy, like a perfect summer tomato.

Frog’s Leg Shallot: Classic French Heirloom

The Frog’s Leg shallot gets its name from its elongated, slightly curved shape, resembling its namesake. This French heirloom is a fantastic choice for the hobby farmer who wants authentic flavor without the fuss of the French Gray. It offers a wonderfully robust and well-balanced taste that is a significant step up from any store-bought variety.

This variety strikes an excellent balance between gourmet quality and practicality. It’s easier to grow and more vigorous than the French Gray, and its keeping qualities are far superior. Properly cured, Frog’s Leg shallots will easily last six months or more, taking you well through the winter.

Use Frog’s Leg where you want a classic, assertive shallot flavor to shine. It’s brilliant in pan sauces for steak, roasted with root vegetables, or caramelized for savory tarts. It’s the kind of reliable, high-quality producer that makes you feel like a seasoned pro.

Dutch Red Sun: Mild Flavor, Beautiful Color

Sometimes you need a shallot that plays a supporting role rather than taking center stage. That’s where Dutch Red Sun comes in. This variety is known for its beautiful reddish-purple skin and blush-colored interior rings, adding a welcome splash of color to your dishes.

Its flavor is milder and sweeter than its French cousins, making it an excellent choice for raw applications. Thinly sliced in salads, salsas, or sandwiches, it provides a gentle allium kick without any harshness. It also cooks down beautifully, lending a subtle sweetness to lighter sauces and dishes.

Dutch Red Sun is also a reliable and easy grower, producing good-sized bulbs that store reasonably well, typically for about five to six months. If you find traditional shallots a bit too strong, or if you simply want a versatile and visually appealing option, this is an outstanding choice.

Ambition F1: The High-Yielding French Hybrid

Heirlooms are fantastic for their unique flavors, but sometimes you just need a big, reliable harvest. Ambition F1 is a modern French hybrid that delivers on that front. As an F1 hybrid, it’s bred for vigor, uniformity, and disease resistance, which translates to a much easier growing experience and, most importantly, significantly higher yields.

While some purists might dismiss hybrids, the flavor of Ambition is genuinely excellent. It boasts a classic, refined French shallot taste that is perfect for everyday gourmet cooking. You get that sought-after flavor profile combined with bulbs that are larger and more consistent than many heirlooms.

Think of Ambition as your workhorse gourmet shallot. It’s perfect for the gardener who wants to produce a large, dependable crop to use generously throughout the year. The storage is also very good, easily lasting into the spring.

Conservor F1: The Best Choice for Long Storage

The biggest challenge for any hobby farmer is making the harvest last. The Conservor F1 shallot was bred specifically to solve this problem. As its name implies, its standout trait is its exceptional storage capability. When properly cured and stored, these shallots can last for up to a year.

This longevity makes Conservor an incredibly practical choice. It means you can plant one main crop of shallots in the spring and still be dicing your own homegrown bulbs the following winter. The bulbs are round, firm, and have tight, durable skins that protect them in storage.

The flavor is very good—a solid, all-purpose shallot taste that works in any dish. It may not have the sublime complexity of a French Gray, but its reliability is unbeatable. For self-sufficiency and a year-round supply, Conservor is the top contender. Many savvy gardeners plant a patch of these alongside a more flavorful heirloom to get the best of both worlds.

Dutch Yellow: A Reliable All-Purpose Staple

If you’re just starting with shallots or want a no-fuss, can’t-miss option, look no further than Dutch Yellow. This variety is the most common type of shallot set you’ll find, and for good reason. It’s incredibly reliable, productive, and easy to grow in a wide range of conditions.

Dutch Yellow provides that classic, mild shallot flavor that’s more subtle than an onion but still present. It’s a true all-purpose variety, equally at home minced in a vinaigrette as it is forming the base of a winter stew. While it may not win awards for complexity, it will never let you down.

Storage is also quite good, typically lasting around six months. For a hobby farmer with limited time, its dependability is a huge asset. You plant it, give it basic care, and you will be rewarded with a solid harvest of versatile, tasty shallots.

Planting and Curing Your Gourmet Shallot Haul

Growing shallots from sets is one of the easiest things you can do in the garden. The key is timing. Plant them in the fall in milder climates or in early spring as soon as the ground can be worked in colder zones. They need well-drained soil and a sunny spot.

To plant, simply separate the cluster of bulbs into individual cloves. Push each clove into the soil, pointed-end up, so that the tip is just barely visible at the surface. Space them about 6-8 inches apart to give them room to multiply. Each single clove you plant will grow into a new cluster of 5-10 shallots.

Harvesting and curing are the most critical steps for long storage. When the green tops begin to yellow and fall over in mid-summer, it’s time to harvest. Gently lift the entire cluster from the soil and move them to a warm, dry, well-ventilated area out of direct sun. Let them cure for two to four weeks, until the necks are completely dry and the outer skins are papery. Once cured, you can trim the tops and roots and store them in a cool, dark, dry place. Do not skip this curing step—it’s the secret to making your harvest last.

Choosing the right shallot isn’t about finding a single "best" variety. It’s about matching the plant’s characteristics to your kitchen’s needs. By planting a mix—perhaps a French Gray for immediate gourmet use, and a Conservor for the long winter—you can equip your pantry with a full spectrum of flavor for the entire year.