6 Best Tomato Presses For Making Tomato Sauce Old Farmers Swear By
Get smooth, seedless sauce the old-fashioned way. We review 6 durable tomato presses, from manual to electric, that seasoned farmers swear by.
There’s a moment every summer when you look at the kitchen counter and realize you’re facing a mountain of ripe tomatoes. You can either let them go to waste or turn them into something that will feed your family all winter long. For turning that mountain into sauce, a good tomato press is the most important tool you’ll own.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Choosing the Right Press for Your Tomato Harvest
The first decision you’ll face is manual versus electric. It isn’t just about saving your arm from cranking for hours. It’s about scale, time, and your entire approach to food preservation.
An electric press is a game-changer if you’re processing bushels at a time. It turns a full-day, all-hands-on-deck event into a manageable afternoon task. But they’re an investment and take up significant storage space. A manual press, on the other hand, is simple, reliable, and connects you to the process. It’s perfect for the gardener with 15 to 30 plants.
Don’t get too caught up in brand names until you’ve answered these questions:
- How many pounds of tomatoes will you process at once? Under 50 pounds is manual territory. Over 100 pounds, and you should seriously consider an electric model.
- How often will you use it? If it’s a once-a-year marathon, an electric model’s speed is invaluable. If you do small batches every weekend, a manual crank is less of a chore.
- What’s your budget? A quality manual press is a modest investment. A durable electric one is a significant purchase that should be weighed against the value of your time.
The material matters, too. Stainless steel and cast iron parts will outlive you, while plastic components can become brittle over time. Think about whether you’re buying a tool for this season or for the next generation.
Victorio VKP250: The Classic Hand-Crank Mill
When people picture a traditional tomato press, they’re usually thinking of something like the Victorio. It’s a classic for a reason: it’s simple, effective, and built to last for decades. This is the workhorse you see clamped to countless farmhouse kitchen tables every August.
The design is straightforward. You load quartered tomatoes into the hopper, turn the crank, and the auger pushes them against a screen. The sauce comes out one chute, and the dry-ish skins and seeds come out the other. It does an excellent job of separating, leaving you with a smooth, seedless puree ready for the pot.
The Victorio is ideal for someone processing a moderate harvest from a large garden. It’s a satisfying, rhythmic process, but make no mistake, it is a workout. The key is to have a very sturdy table or counter to clamp it to. A wobbly setup will make the job ten times harder. For the price and reliability, it’s hard to beat for small to medium-scale preserving.
O.M.R.A. Spremy Electric: The Italian Workhorse
If you’re serious about sauce and processing hundreds of pounds of tomatoes, you need a serious machine. The Italian-made O.M.R.A. Spremy is exactly that. These machines are built with one purpose in mind: to process tomatoes quickly and efficiently, year after year.
The Spremy’s power comes from a commercial-grade, continuous-duty motor. This means it won’t overheat or bog down, even when you’re feeding it bucket after bucket of tomatoes for hours. It’s constructed with heavy-duty components, from the stainless steel hopper to the cast iron body. This isn’t a kitchen gadget; it’s a piece of farm equipment.
The main tradeoff is cost and specialization. This is a significant investment for a tool that primarily does one thing. But if your goal is to turn a massive harvest into a year’s worth of sauce with minimal time and fuss, the O.M.R.A. pays for itself in saved labor. It’s the closest you can get to a professional setup in a home kitchen.
Weston Deluxe Electric: For Large Harvests
The Weston electric press offers a different value proposition for the serious homesteader. While it has the power to tackle huge harvests like the Italian models, its strength lies in its versatility. It’s often sold as a "grinder and strainer," and it lives up to that name.
This machine is a beast, capable of processing a bushel of tomatoes in minutes. The motor is powerful, and the auger design pulls fruit through with impressive speed. Where it really shines, though, is with its optional attachments. The same motor base can be used for grinding meat, making sausage, or even stuffing jerky.
For a hobby farmer looking to maximize the utility of their equipment, this is a huge advantage. Instead of buying three separate machines, you have one powerful motor that can handle it all. The downside is its size and complexity; cleanup is more involved than with a simple manual crank. But if you’re processing deer in the fall and tomatoes in the summer, the Weston’s multi-functionality makes it a very smart investment.
Fabio Leonardi SP5: Heirloom Quality Performance
Stepping up to a Fabio Leonardi is like moving from a good farm truck to a commercial tractor. These are lifetime, and likely multi-generational, machines. Built in Italy with an uncompromising focus on quality, they are designed for semi-commercial use and will handle anything a hobby farmer can throw at them.
The build quality is immediately apparent. We’re talking about massive, powerful motors, niploy-coated cast iron bodies, and stainless steel components where it counts. They are incredibly heavy and stable, designed to run all day without a hint of strain. The performance is flawless, producing a beautiful, consistent puree from even the toughest tomatoes.
This level of quality comes at a steep price. A Fabio Leonardi is the most expensive option on this list and represents a serious commitment to food preservation. It is absolute overkill for a small garden. But for the farmer who is processing for market, for a multi-family co-op, or who simply believes in buying the best tool once and having it forever, there is no substitute.
Norpro 1951 Sauce Master: A Reliable Manual Pick
The Norpro Sauce Master operates on the same principle as the Victorio and is another excellent choice for a manual press. It has a loyal following among old-timers who appreciate its sturdy build and reliable performance. It’s a testament to a simple design done well.
One of its standout features is a large hopper, which means less time spent refilling and more time cranking. The suction cup base, combined with a C-clamp, provides a very stable platform, which is critical when you’re applying force to the crank. Like other manual mills, it does a fantastic job of separating seeds and skins, giving you a clean puree.
Choosing between the Norpro and the Victorio often comes down to small preferences or which one you can find a better deal on. Both are dependable, long-lasting tools that will serve a medium-sized garden well. The Norpro is a solid, no-frills option that delivers consistent results year after year.
OXO Good Grips Food Mill: A Versatile Choice
Sometimes the best tool isn’t the most specialized one. The OXO Good Grips Food Mill isn’t a tomato "press" in the same way as the others, but for small-batch sauce makers, it’s an indispensable kitchen tool that many seasoned gardeners swear by.
Unlike a press that separates skins and seeds from raw tomatoes, a food mill is typically used after the tomatoes have been cooked down. You run the cooked pulp through the mill, and it works by pressing the soft flesh through a perforated plate, leaving the skins and seeds behind. It comes with different discs for a fine or coarse texture, giving you more control over the final product.
The major advantage here is versatility. You’ll use the same tool for making applesauce, mashed potatoes, and fruit purees. If you have fewer than a dozen tomato plants, the speed of a dedicated press is unnecessary. A food mill requires more upfront cooking, but for small quantities, it produces a beautiful, rustic sauce and earns its keep in your kitchen the other 11 months of the year.
Prepping Tomatoes for the Best Pressing Results
You can have the best press in the world, but your results will be disappointing if you don’t prep your tomatoes properly. A few simple steps beforehand make the entire process smoother and more efficient. Don’t just dump them from the basket into the hopper.
For most manual and electric presses, a quick wash and removing any bad spots is all you need. If you’re dealing with large beefsteak tomatoes, cutting them into quarters will help them feed into the auger more easily. For paste tomatoes like Romas or San Marzanos, you can often just toss them in whole. Some people find that a quick 5-10 minute simmer in a stockpot softens the tomatoes, allowing them to break down and release their juice more readily, which can reduce strain on your machine (and your arm).
The most important trick that old-timers know is the "second pass." Once you’ve run all your tomatoes through the press, take the pile of discarded skins and seeds and run it all through the machine again. You will be shocked at how much thick, valuable pulp is extracted on this second run. It’s the key to minimizing waste and getting the absolute most out of your harvest.
Ultimately, the right tomato press is the one that fits the scale of your garden and the rhythm of your life. Whether it’s a simple hand-crank model for a few dozen plants or an electric beast to tackle a half-acre plot, the right tool transforms a chore into a deeply satisfying act of provision. There’s nothing better than looking at a pantry full of beautiful red jars in the dead of winter, knowing you captured the taste of summer yourself.
