6 Best Low Waste Hay Feeders For Small Horse Farms That Slash Your Hay Bill
Slash your hay bill with the right feeder. We review the 6 best low-waste options for small horse farms, helping you reduce waste and save money.
You toss a few flakes of hay on the ground, and ten minutes later, half of it is trampled into the mud. It’s a frustratingly common scene on small horse farms, where every dollar and every minute counts. Watching expensive hay get used as bedding is more than just annoying; it’s a direct hit to your bottom line. The right hay feeder isn’t a luxury—it’s a critical tool for slashing your feed bill and making your farm more efficient.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Why Hay Waste Hits Small Farms the Hardest
When you’re only feeding a handful of horses, every wasted flake feels personal. Unlike large operations that buy hay by the ton, we often buy it by the bale, paying a premium for convenience and smaller quantities. That means the financial impact of a 20-30% waste rate, which is common for ground feeding, is magnified.
But the cost isn’t just in dollars. Wasted hay means more mucking, more mud, and more time spent on chores that don’t move your farm forward. That trampled hay mixes with manure and moisture, creating a perfect breeding ground for bacteria and parasites. It can contribute to issues like thrush, scratches, and even respiratory problems from dust and mold.
Ultimately, a good feeder system isn’t just about saving money on hay. It’s about saving your time, protecting your horse’s health, and managing your pasture more effectively. It’s a foundational investment in a more sustainable and less stressful farming life.
Hay Chix Nets: Best for Slow, Paced Grazing
Reduce hay waste and promote healthy digestion with the Hay Chix slow feed hay net. Made from durable, UV-treated marine-grade nylon, this half bale net features a patented closure for easy filling and secure feeding.
Slow-feed hay nets are one of the most popular solutions for a reason: they work. By forcing horses to pull small bites through a grid of openings, these nets mimic the slow, continuous grazing their digestive systems were designed for. This keeps gut-acid levels stable, reduces the risk of colic and ulcers, and helps prevent boredom-related behaviors like cribbing or wood chewing.
The Hay Chix brand is known for its durability and variety. You can get nets that fit a single flake for a stall or massive ones to cover an entire round bale. The key is choosing the right hole size.
- 1.75" or 2" holes are great for most horses and harder keepers, slowing them down without causing frustration.
- 1" or 1.25" holes are ideal for "easy keepers" or ponies who need their intake seriously restricted.
The tradeoff is the daily chore of filling them. Wrestling a tight flake of hay into a net on a cold, windy day is nobody’s favorite task. Some horses also become destructive chewers, though a well-made net can withstand a lot of abuse. Despite the hassle, their impact on hay savings and horse health is undeniable.
Tarter Equine Hay Basket: Simple and Durable
Sometimes, the simplest solution is the best one. The Tarter Equine Hay Basket is essentially a heavy-duty metal basket on legs. There are no moving parts, no grates to replace, and nothing for a clever horse to break. Its primary job is to get the hay off the ground, and it does that job exceptionally well.
By elevating the hay, you immediately eliminate waste from trampling, mud, and manure. Horses can eat comfortably around it without fighting, and the open design allows for good airflow, keeping the hay fresh. It’s built from heavy-gauge steel, so it won’t get knocked over or pushed around the pasture by an itchy herd.
This feeder’s main limitation is that it doesn’t significantly slow down consumption. A horse can still pull out big mouthfuls and drop some on the ground nearby. It’s a fantastic choice for reducing major waste in a group setting, especially if your horses self-regulate well, but it isn’t a true "slow feeder." Think of it as a massive improvement over ground feeding, not a precision grazing tool.
High Country Plastics Feeder: All-Weather Pick
If you’re tired of dealing with rust or splintering wood, a heavy-duty plastic feeder is the answer. High Country Plastics makes several models that are tough, safe, and incredibly easy to maintain. They won’t rust in the rain or crack in the cold, making them a reliable choice for any climate.
Many of their feeders, like the "Slow Feeder Saver," come with a removable grate that turns them into an effective slow-feeding system. The grate floats on top of the hay, dropping as the level goes down, which ensures horses are always eating in a comfortable, head-down position. Because they’re made from a single piece of molded plastic, they are easy to spray out and keep clean.
The main consideration is the durability of the grate itself. While the feeder body is nearly indestructible, an aggressive horse might manage to damage the grate over time. However, for most small herds, these feeders offer a fantastic balance of waste reduction, slow-feeding benefits, and all-weather durability.
The Hayhut: Protects Round Bales from Weather
For small farms that use round bales, the Hayhut is a game-changer. This feeder is essentially a large plastic hut that completely covers the bale, protecting it from rain, snow, and sun. This single feature can save an entire bale from turning into a moldy, inedible mess, paying for the feeder in just a few saved bales.
The Hayhut allows multiple horses to eat at once through large windows, minimizing competition. It keeps the bulk of the hay contained and clean, drastically reducing the "all-you-can-stomp" buffet that an unprotected round bale becomes. It’s a set-it-and-forget-it solution for providing free-choice hay, especially during winter.
The investment is significant, and its large footprint makes it a semi-permanent fixture in your pasture. While it protects the bale from the elements, it doesn’t stop horses from pulling hay out and dropping it around the feeder’s base, so some minor ground waste will still occur. It’s the ultimate solution for weather protection, less so for slowing down aggressive eaters.
Porta-Grazer: The Top Choice for Natural Grazing
The Porta-Grazer is engineered around a simple but powerful concept: let horses eat the way nature intended. This barrel-shaped feeder requires the horse to eat with its head down, pulling small bites through a grate. This posture is better for their respiratory health, encourages proper dental wear, and helps develop a strong topline.
Because the horse has to work for every bite, it slows consumption way down and nearly eliminates waste. The hay is packed tightly in the barrel, so it can’t be flung around or soiled. This makes it an outstanding choice for horses in stalls, on a dry lot, or for those with metabolic issues who need their intake carefully managed.
The primary drawbacks are cost and capacity. A single Porta-Grazer is a significant investment, and it only holds about half a small square bale, requiring frequent refills for a horse on full-time hay. It’s the perfect tool for targeted, individual feeding but isn’t practical as the sole feeder for a larger group.
Hay Optimizer: A Tough Feeder for Group Use
The Hay Optimizer is designed to solve the problem of feeding a small group in a confined space. Made from thick, durable polyethylene, this tombstone-style feeder allows several horses to eat peacefully at the same time from their own station. The design minimizes bickering and ensures that more timid horses get their share.
This feeder excels at containing hay. The deep tub and high sides make it very difficult for horses to pull hay out and drop it on the ground. It can hold several small square bales, reducing the frequency of refills. Its rounded edges and robust construction make it one of the safest and toughest options for a dynamic herd.
Like the Tarter basket, the Hay Optimizer is more of a waste reducer than a true slow feeder. It doesn’t have a grate to restrict intake, so horses can eat at their normal pace. It’s an excellent, long-lasting investment for keeping a dry lot tidy and ensuring your hay bill reflects what your horses are eating, not what they’re sleeping on.
Feeder Management Tips to Maximize Savings
Buying a great feeder is only half the battle. How you use it can make a huge difference in how much hay and money you actually save. Smart placement is crucial. Never put a feeder in a low-lying, muddy area. Place it on high, dry ground, preferably on a gravel or sand pad, to prevent it from becoming a mucky mess.
Don’t overfill the feeder. Giving horses a mountain of hay encourages them to become picky, sorting through to find the tastiest bits and leaving the rest. It’s better to feed smaller amounts more frequently, ensuring they clean up what you give them before getting more.
Regularly clean out the "fines"—the dusty, leafy particles that accumulate at the bottom. This buildup can become unpalatable and may even mold. A quick scoop-out once a week keeps the feeder fresh and encourages horses to eat every last bit. Finally, watch your herd dynamics. If one horse is guarding the feeder, you may need a second one to ensure everyone gets to eat without stress.
Choosing the right hay feeder is an investment that pays for itself faster than almost any other purchase on a small farm. It directly translates into lower feed bills, healthier horses, and less time spent on back-breaking chores. By matching the feeder to your specific herd and management style, you can stop feeding the mud and start feeding your animals more efficiently.
