6 Best Online Hatcheries For Chicken Eggs That Preserve Heritage Breeds

So you’ve decided to move beyond the standard hybrid layers and build a flock with a bit more history and self-sufficiency. You want birds that can forage, raise their own young, and provide both eggs and meat. The first step is often the hardest: finding a reliable source for quality, fertile hatching eggs from true heritage breeds.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why Choose Heritage Breeds for Your Flock?

Heritage breeds are more than just old-fashioned chickens. They are standard-bred poultry defined by The Livestock Conservancy, meaning they can reproduce naturally and have a long, productive outdoor lifespan. Unlike modern industrial hybrids bred for a single purpose, these birds are the original all-rounders of the farm.

For the hobby farmer, this translates to resilience. Heritage chickens are generally better foragers, more adept at evading predators, and more resistant to common diseases and parasites. They thrive in free-range environments where they can supplement their own diet, reducing your feed bill. Many breeds, like the Sussex or Plymouth Rock, are also excellent mothers, meaning you can grow your flock naturally without relying solely on an incubator.

Choosing heritage breeds is also an act of conservation. The rise of industrial agriculture pushed many of these incredible birds to the brink of extinction. By raising a flock of Dorkings, Buckeyes, or Dominiques, you are directly participating in the preservation of genetic diversity. You’re not just raising chickens; you’re safeguarding a living piece of agricultural history for future generations.

Cackle Hatchery: Huge Selection of Heritage Eggs

When you want options, Cackle Hatchery is often the first place people look. They are one of the largest hatcheries in the country, and their catalog reflects that scale. You can find dozens of heritage breeds here, from the ever-popular Buff Orpington and Australorp to less common varieties like the New Hampshire Red and Black Jersey Giant.

The major advantage of their size is availability. If you decide you want to hatch a specific, relatively common heritage breed, there’s a good chance Cackle has the eggs in stock and ready to ship. Their website is easy to navigate, and the ordering process is straightforward, making it a great entry point for those new to buying hatching eggs online.

The tradeoff for this massive selection is that the breeding stock may not be as meticulously selected for exhibition-level perfection as what you’d find at a small, specialized breeder. However, for a functional and productive homestead flock, their birds are more than suitable. They are a reliable workhorse hatchery for getting started with established heritage breeds.

Meyer Hatchery: Top-Notch Customer Service

Meyer Hatchery has built a stellar reputation based on one thing: excellent customer service. When you’re dealing with the delicate and time-sensitive process of shipping fertile eggs, knowing there’s a helpful person on the other end of the phone is invaluable. This is especially true if you’re a first-time hatcher with lots of questions.

Their selection of heritage breed eggs is well-curated, focusing on breeds that are particularly well-suited for backyard and homestead life. You’ll find hardy and productive options like Wyandottes, Buckeyes, and Delawares. Meyer is also great at providing educational content, helping you understand the unique traits of each breed so you can make an informed choice for your specific needs.

What sets them apart is the confidence they inspire. They are transparent about their NPIP (National Poultry Improvement Plan) certification and their flock health practices. When a box of their eggs arrives, you feel assured that they’ve done everything on their end to set you up for a successful hatch. For peace of mind, Meyer is consistently a top choice.

Greenfire Farms: Sourcing Rare, Exotic Breeds

If your goal is to raise chickens that none of your neighbors have ever seen, Greenfire Farms is your destination. They specialize in importing and breeding some of the rarest and most exotic chickens in the world. This isn’t where you go for a standard Barred Rock; this is where you find breeds like the otherworldly Cemani, the hardy Swedish Flower Hen, or the robust Liege Fighter.

These birds aren’t just for show. Many of the breeds Greenfire works with possess unique traits valuable to a hobby farmer, such as exceptional foraging skills, unique egg colors, or extreme climate hardiness. They have painstakingly built their breeding programs from imported stock, offering genetic lines that are simply unavailable anywhere else in the United States.

Be prepared for the two major tradeoffs: price and patience. These eggs are an investment, often costing several times what you’d pay at a larger hatchery. Because they are a specialized breeder, not a massive hatchery, availability is limited and you often have to order well in advance. This is the place for the dedicated enthusiast committed to raising and preserving truly unique poultry.

McMurray Hatchery: A Century of Poultry Expertise

McMurray Hatchery is an institution in the poultry world. With over a century in business, they have a deep-rooted understanding of poultry genetics, health, and logistics. This experience translates into a reliable product and a smooth ordering process, which is why they’ve remained a go-to source for generations of farmers.

They were one of the pioneers in offering a wide variety of breeds to the public, and they have a solid catalog of heritage chickens. McMurray was instrumental in keeping many of these breeds in the public eye when hybrids began to dominate the industry. You can count on them for popular dual-purpose breeds like the Rhode Island Red, Buff Orpington, and a variety of Cochins and Brahmas.

Think of McMurray as the steady, dependable choice. Their quality is consistent, their shipping is reliable, and their reputation is rock-solid. While they may not have the exotic rarities of a specialty breeder, they provide healthy, productive stock from the most well-known heritage lines. They are a safe bet for anyone looking for classic, proven breeds.

Ideal Poultry: Great for Broiler Heritage Breeds

While most heritage breeds are considered dual-purpose, some lines have been selected to be particularly good for meat production. If your primary goal is to raise your own meat birds without resorting to the fast-growing but fragile Cornish Cross, Ideal Poultry is an excellent resource. They cater to folks raising birds in larger numbers, and their selection reflects that focus.

Ideal offers robust heritage and "heritage-cross" breeds that are excellent for pasturing. Look for their specific lines of White Plymouth Rocks or New Hampshire Reds, which have a faster growth rate than many exhibition lines while retaining the hardiness and foraging ability of a true heritage bird. This gives you the best of both worlds: a flavorful, healthy bird that can thrive in a natural environment.

Because they are a large-scale hatchery, their minimum orders might be higher, making them a great fit if you’re planning to fill your freezer for the year. They understand the logistics of shipping large orders and have a streamlined process for it. For the homesteader focused on meat production, Ideal offers practical and productive options.

Sand Hill Preservation: A True Conservationist

Ordering from Sand Hill Preservation is less of a commercial transaction and more like joining a conservation movement. This is a family-run operation dedicated to preserving critically endangered and rare varieties of poultry, often the ones that larger hatcheries have dropped. Their catalog is a treasure trove of genetic history.

This is not Amazon Prime. You’ll likely be mailing in an order form and a check, and you’ll need to do it months in advance. The focus here is entirely on the preservation of the breeds, not on high-volume sales or fancy web design. You order from Sand Hill because you believe in the mission and want to be a steward of a rare genetic line.

The reward for your patience is access to incredibly rare breeds and the knowledge that you are supporting a vital genetic bank. The quality of the stock is often exceptional because it’s managed by people who are deeply passionate about maintaining breed standards and genetic integrity. If your primary motivation is conservation, Sand Hill is unmatched.

Preparing Your Incubator for Arrival of Eggs

The hatchery’s responsibility ends once the eggs are safely delivered to your door. From that point on, a successful hatch is entirely up to you and your equipment. The most critical step happens before your eggs even arrive.

You must have your incubator running and stable for at least 24 to 48 hours prior to setting the eggs. This gives you time to make sure it holds a consistent temperature and humidity. Don’t trust the built-in thermometer; always double-check it with a calibrated, independent thermometer and hygrometer.

• Temperature: Aim for 99.5°F (37.5°C) for most forced-air incubators.
• Humidity: Maintain 45-55% for the first 18 days, then increase to 65-75% for the final 3 days of lockdown.
• Location: Keep the incubator in a room with a stable temperature, away from direct sunlight, drafts, and vibrations.

When the box arrives, resist the urge to immediately put the eggs in the incubator. Shipped eggs need to rest. Let them sit, pointy-end down in an egg carton, at room temperature (around 60-70°F) for 12 to 24 hours. This allows the air cell, which can get scrambled during shipping, to settle back into its proper position at the wide end of the egg. Skipping this resting period is one of the most common reasons for a poor hatch rate with shipped eggs.

Choosing the right hatchery is about aligning their strengths with your personal goals for your flock. Whether you prioritize a huge selection, rare genetics, customer support, or a conservation mission, there’s a hatchery that fits your needs. By starting with quality fertile eggs and a well-prepared incubator, you’re taking the most important step toward building a vibrant, resilient, and productive heritage flock.