6 Best Hay Feeders To Deter Birds From Stealing Hay That Stop Waste
Protect your hay from birds and reduce costly waste. Our guide reviews 6 top feeders designed to keep hay clean, dry, and secure from pests.
You toss a fresh flake of hay into the feeder, and within minutes, a flock of starlings descends like a noisy, feathered cloud. They don’t just eat; they pull strands out, trample them into the mud, and foul what’s left behind. This isn’t just annoying—it’s expensive, turning your carefully purchased hay into bird bedding and wasted money.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Why Bird-Proof Hay Feeders Save You Money
The most obvious cost of bird interference is the hay they steal or ruin. A single bird doesn’t eat much, but a flock can carry off or spoil a significant portion of a bale over time. Hay that’s pulled onto the ground is immediately contaminated with dirt, manure, and parasites, making it unsafe for your livestock to eat. You end up paying for hay that never nourishes your animals.
The hidden costs are even more significant. Soiled hay can grow mold and harbor bacteria, which can lead to respiratory issues or digestive upset in your animals. A single vet bill for colic or an infection will dwarf the cost of a good feeder. Preventing waste isn’t just about saving feed; it’s a critical part of proactive herd health management.
Finally, think about your time. Constantly cleaning up scattered, ruined hay and refilling feeders more often than necessary is a drain on your most limited resource. A well-designed feeder contains the hay, minimizes cleanup, and lets you focus on other essential farm tasks. It’s an investment in efficiency.
High Country Plastics Feeder: Top Waste Saver
When your primary goal is eliminating waste from every possible angle, a ground-level, covered feeder like those from High Country Plastics is hard to beat. These are typically roto-molded, heavy-duty plastic tubs with a solid lid and openings on the sides for animals to eat through. Many models also include a slow-feed grate inside.
The design is brilliant in its simplicity for deterring birds. The solid cover gives them nowhere to perch and access the hay from above. Because the hay is fully contained, there’s very little spillage for ground-feeding birds to pick through. The slow-feed grate, if included, makes it even harder for birds to pull out strands.
The main tradeoff is price and portability. These feeders are a significant investment and can be heavy and awkward to move, especially when full. They are best suited for a permanent or semi-permanent feeding station in a paddock or dry lot, serving a few animals at a time. For a set-and-forget solution in a high-traffic area, they are a fantastic choice.
Tarter Covered Bunk Feeder for Small Herds
For small herds of goats, sheep, or miniature horses, a covered bunk feeder is a classic for a reason. Tarter makes a popular model, but the design principle is what matters: a V-shaped trough on legs with a simple roof over the top. This setup addresses bird problems from two directions.
The roof is the obvious bird deterrent. It physically blocks starlings, pigeons, and other birds from landing in the hay. This single feature prevents the contamination and waste that comes from birds nesting and defecating in their food source. The sloped V-shape of the bunk also helps keep hay centered and reduces the amount that gets pushed out onto the ground.
These feeders are ideal for animals that can eat side-by-side. The elevated design keeps the hay off the wet ground, improving drainage and further reducing spoilage. While not a "slow feeder," it’s a massive improvement over open troughs or feeding on the ground, providing a great balance of accessibility, protection, and cost for the small hobby farm.
Porta-Grazer: A Unique Barrel-Style Feeder
The Porta-Grazer takes a completely different approach. Instead of an open trough, it’s an upright barrel system where the animal eats through a grate that sits on top of the hay and drops as the hay is consumed. This design mimics a natural grazing posture, which is excellent for digestion and dental health.
From a bird-proofing perspective, it’s nearly perfect. The hay is entirely enclosed. Birds cannot land on it, pull strands out, or contaminate it in any way. The openings in the feed grate are just large enough for your animal’s muzzle, offering no purchase for a bird’s beak. It is, by its very nature, a fortress for your hay.
The primary consideration here is that it’s a single-animal feeder. If you have a herd of five goats, you’ll need five Porta-Grazers to prevent competition and ensure everyone gets to eat peacefully. This can make it a costly option for larger groups, but for one or two horses or for separating animals with specific dietary needs, it’s an incredibly effective tool for both health and waste reduction.
HayChix Hay Nets: A Versatile Slow-Feed Option
Reduce hay waste and promote healthy digestion with the Hay Chix slow feed hay net. Made from durable, UV-treated marine-grade nylon, this half bale net features a patented closure for easy filling and secure feeding.
Sometimes the simplest solution is the most effective. A high-quality, small-hole hay net, like those from HayChix, is one of the most versatile and affordable ways to stop birds from stealing hay. The concept is straightforward: the small openings (typically 1-2 inches) allow livestock to pull out small bites of hay but make it nearly impossible for birds to extract long, wasteful strands.
Birds are opportunistic. If they can’t easily grab a beakful and fly off, they’ll move on to an easier target. A tightly packed hay net offers very little reward for their effort. This drastically cuts down on the hay being pulled onto the ground, which is the primary source of waste.
The beauty of a net is its flexibility. You can hang it in a stall, along a fence line, or even place it inside a larger trough or bunk feeder to add a slow-feed, bird-proof element to your existing setup. The crucial factor is safety. Always hang nets high enough so an animal cannot get a hoof caught, or use a solid-walled feeder to contain them.
Agratronix Hay-Hutch for Outdoor Group Feeding
Quickly and accurately measure hay bale moisture with the AgraTronix HT-Pro. This tester features a 20" probe and an illuminated LCD display for easy readings between 8% and 44%.
If you feed round bales, you know they can become a bird metropolis overnight. The Agratronix Hay-Hutch (and similar "hay bell" designs) solves this problem by completely covering the bale. It’s a large, durable polyethylene dome with feeding windows cut out around the bottom.
This design eliminates the number one problem with round bales: waste from the top. Birds love to perch on, nest in, and pull apart the top of an unprotected bale, ruining the best hay first. The Hay-Hutch makes the top of the bale completely inaccessible to both birds and weather, preserving the quality of the entire bale until it’s consumed.
This is a specialized piece of equipment and a real investment. It’s not for someone feeding a few square bales. But if you’re managing a small herd of cattle, a larger group of horses, or a flock of sheep through the winter on round bales, the savings are dramatic. It can easily pay for itself in a single season by preventing hundreds of pounds of hay from becoming compost.
Behrens Galvanized Trough with a DIY Cover
Never underestimate a clever DIY solution. For many hobby farmers, the best feeder is one adapted to their specific needs. A sturdy, basic Behrens galvanized stock trough provides the perfect foundation for a custom, bird-proof feeder that won’t break the bank.
The modification is simple in concept. You can build a wooden A-frame roof to cover the trough, or for an easier solution, create a lid from a sheet of welded wire fencing. Use a grid with openings large enough for your animals to eat through (e.g., 4×4 inches for goats) but too small and awkward for birds to get through. Securing the wire grid with hinges on one side makes refilling easy.
This approach requires some basic tools and a bit of time, but the payoff is huge. You get a feeder that is the exact size and configuration for your space and your animals. It’s often the most cost-effective way to achieve a truly bird-proof setup, giving you complete control over the design and materials.
Key Features to Look for in a Hay Feeder
When you’re comparing options, the single most important feature for deterring birds is a physical barrier. This can be a solid roof, a full enclosure, or small openings like those in a hay net or grate. If a bird can’t easily land on or pull from the hay, you’ve solved 90% of the problem.
Beyond bird-proofing, consider these practical features:
- Durability: Livestock are not gentle. Look for heavy-gauge steel or thick, roto-molded plastic that can withstand pushing, rubbing, and kicking. Flimsy materials will not last.
- Drainage: Any feeder used outdoors must have drainage holes. Rain-soaked hay quickly turns to moldy sludge, and a feeder without drainage becomes a compost bin.
- Safety: Check for sharp edges, points, or gaps where a leg or head could become trapped. The feeder should contain hay, not your animals.
- Ease of Cleaning: A feeder that is difficult to clean will not get cleaned often. Look for smooth surfaces and designs that don’t have tight corners where old feed can accumulate.
Ultimately, the "best" feeder is a balance of these features tailored to your situation. A feeder that’s perfect for two horses in a stall is useless for a flock of 20 sheep in a pasture. Define your specific needs first—number of animals, location, and budget—and then find the feeder that best meets them.
Choosing the right hay feeder isn’t just about convenience; it’s an essential part of managing your resources wisely. By investing in a design that protects your hay from birds and the elements, you’re not just buying equipment. You’re cutting feed costs, protecting your animals’ health, and saving yourself valuable time.
