6 Best Alfalfa Seeds For Livestock Forage That Old Farmers Swear By

Staring at a wall of seed bags can feel overwhelming, each promising the greenest fields and the heaviest bales. But choosing the right alfalfa seed isn’t about finding a magic bullet; it’s about matching the plant to your land, your animals, and your time. Get it right, and you’ll have rich forage for years; get it wrong, and you’re looking at a costly reseeding project next season.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

What to Look For in Quality Alfalfa Forage Seed

Before you even look at a brand name, you need to know your numbers. The most important one is the Fall Dormancy (FD) rating, a scale from 1 (very dormant) to 11 (non-dormant). For most of the country where you get a real winter, you’ll be looking for something in the 2 to 5 range. A lower number means the plant hunkers down early for winter, giving it excellent cold hardiness but slightly slower spring green-up.

Next, look at the disease resistance package. Every seed tag has a chart listing resistance to major alfalfa diseases like Phytophthora Root Rot, Verticillium Wilt, and Aphanomyces. Don’t just grab the one with the most "HR" (High Resistance) ratings. Think about your specific field. Is it a bit low-lying and stays wet after a rain? Then Phytophthora resistance is non-negotiable. Ignoring this is like building a house in a floodplain without insurance.

Finally, be honest about your primary use. Are you making dry hay for dairy goats that need high protein? Or are you turning a mixed herd of cattle and sheep out to graze it? A variety bred for high yields and fine stems, perfect for hay, may have a high crown that gets damaged easily by grazing animals. A grazing-tolerant variety, on the other hand, has a lower-set crown and is bred to withstand hoof traffic and repeated browsing. Choosing the wrong type is a recipe for a thinning stand.

Vernal Alfalfa: The Gold Standard for Hardiness

If you’re looking for a proven, no-frills workhorse, Vernal is it. This is the variety your grandfather probably planted, and for good reason. It’s incredibly winter-hardy (typically an FD 2) and known for its persistence in less-than-ideal conditions. It’s a forgiving plant that can handle tougher soils and less intensive management than some of the newer, high-performance hybrids.

The tradeoff for all that toughness is yield. Vernal won’t win any tonnage contests against modern varieties, and its feed quality, while good, won’t match the premium "HQ" types. But for a hobby farmer who needs a reliable stand that will survive a harsh winter and stick around for five or more years with minimal fuss, Vernal is a rock-solid, economical choice. It establishes well and provides dependable forage without demanding perfect conditions.

WL 354HQ: Unmatched for High-Quality Yields

When your goal is maximum production of top-tier feed, you look at a variety like WL 354HQ. The "HQ" stands for High Quality, and it delivers. This plant is bred to produce leafy, fine-stemmed hay with high relative feed value (RFV), which is exactly what you need for animals with high nutritional demands, like lactating dairy animals or young, growing stock.

This performance comes with expectations. WL 354HQ is a high-input alfalfa. It needs well-drained, fertile soil with the right pH to reach its potential. It’s also typically less persistent than a variety like Ranger or Vernal, often lasting three to four years in a heavy cutting schedule. Think of it as a sprinter, not a marathon runner. If you have good ground and are committed to soil testing and proper fertilization, this variety will reward you with some of the best hay you can grow.

Alfagraze 600 RR: Specifically for Tough Grazing

Grazing alfalfa is a different game than haying it, and Alfagraze was designed to play. Its key feature is a low-set crown and a more branched root system. This structure helps it withstand the constant stress of animal traffic and repeated defoliation. While other varieties get weakened and die out under heavy grazing, Alfagraze is bred to bounce back.

The "RR" in the name means it’s a Roundup Ready (GMO) variety, which is a significant management advantage for weed control, especially during establishment. For a small operation, being able to cleanly control weed pressure with a single herbicide can be the difference between a thick stand and a field of thistles. Of course, this isn’t for everyone, and non-GMO grazing varieties exist. But for pure function and ease of management in a pasture system, Alfagraze 600 RR is tough to beat.

This variety is about resilience over sheer tonnage. You’re trading a bit of top-end yield for a plant that will actually survive and thrive in a real-world grazing scenario. It’s the perfect choice for the core of a rotational grazing system.

Ranger Alfalfa: For Long-Lasting, Persistent Stands

The biggest hidden cost in forage production is reseeding. Ranger alfalfa is for the farmer who wants to plant it and forget it—or at least, not worry about it for a good long while. This is another old-school, reliable variety known for one thing above all else: persistence. It’s a tough, winter-hardy plant that can produce for five, six, or even seven years.

Like Vernal, Ranger isn’t going to top the yield charts. It’s a multi-purpose variety that provides good, solid forage without breaking any records. Its strength lies in its longevity. For a part-time farmer, not having to tear up and re-establish a hayfield every few years is a massive saving in time, fuel, and money.

Think of Ranger as an investment in stability. It’s an excellent choice for a permanent hayfield or a mixed pasture where you want a dependable legume component that won’t disappear after a couple of hard seasons. It provides a consistent, long-term foundation for your forage program.

Ameristand 407TQ: Superior Disease Resistance

A beautiful stand of alfalfa can be wiped out in one wet season by root rot. Ameristand 407TQ is built like a tank to prevent that. Its main selling point is a top-of-the-line disease resistance package, offering high resistance to virtually all major alfalfa diseases. This is your insurance policy in a bag.

The "TQ" stands for Traffic and Quality, meaning it’s also bred to withstand wheel traffic from haying equipment while still producing high-quality forage. This is a crucial but often overlooked trait. Every pass with the tractor, baler, or manure spreader compacts the soil and stresses the plant crowns. A variety that can handle this traffic will stay productive longer.

You’d choose a variety like this if you farm in a wetter region, have heavy clay soils, or have had disease problems in the past. While it costs more upfront, it can easily pay for itself by preventing a single lost cutting or, worse, a total stand failure. It’s about managing risk and ensuring your investment in seed and fertilizer is protected.

Ladino 444: The All-Purpose Pasture Favorite

Okay, this one is technically a ladino clover, not an alfalfa, but it fills a similar role so well that it belongs in the conversation. For a mixed-use pasture that sees a lot of grazing, Ladino 444 is an absolute star. It’s a large-leaved, aggressive white clover that spreads by stolons (above-ground runners), allowing it to fill in gaps and handle heavy traffic.

Unlike alfalfa, ladino clover has a much lower risk of causing bloat in ruminants, making it a safer choice for continuous grazing. It’s also more tolerant of acidic soils and wetter conditions than alfalfa. It thrives when mixed with grasses like orchardgrass or fescue, creating a dense, highly palatable, and resilient pasture.

While it won’t produce the tonnage of a pure alfalfa stand for hay, it’s not meant to. Ladino 444 is the ultimate team player. It fixes nitrogen that feeds the surrounding grasses and provides a high-protein boost for livestock all season long. For the hobby farmer wanting a versatile, low-maintenance, "do-it-all" pasture, this is a must-have component.

Planting Tips for a Successful Alfalfa Stand

Getting a great stand starts long before the seed hits the dirt. The single most important step is a soil test. Alfalfa demands a soil pH between 6.5 and 7.0. If your soil is acidic, you must apply lime, ideally six months before planting, to give it time to work. Don’t skip this; planting alfalfa in acidic soil is like trying to grow tomatoes in the dark.

Your seedbed needs to be firm, fine, and free of weeds. A lumpy, loose seedbed is a leading cause of establishment failure. The goal is a surface firm enough that your boot print only sinks about half an inch. For small plots, a pass with a tiller followed by a roller or cultipacker does the job perfectly. This ensures good seed-to-soil contact.

Don’t forget the inoculant. Alfalfa seed must be inoculated with a specific type of rhizobia bacteria to fix nitrogen. Most seed comes pre-coated, but if you buy raw seed, you must buy the correct inoculant and mix it in right before planting. Plant shallow—no deeper than a quarter to a half-inch. Planting too deep is another common and fatal mistake. A successful stand is all in the prep work.

Ultimately, the best alfalfa seed is the one that fits your specific piece of ground and your goals. Don’t get sold on yield numbers alone; consider hardiness, disease resistance, and how you plan to use it. By matching the right variety to your farm, you’re not just planting a crop—you’re investing in years of high-quality, homegrown feed.