6 Herb Garden Companion Planting Charts Old Farmers Swear By

You’ve walked out to your garden to find your cabbage leaves riddled with holes and your tomato plants looking stressed. It’s a familiar, frustrating sight. Before you reach for a spray bottle, it’s worth remembering that the old ways often hold the simplest solutions. For generations, farmers have known that the garden is a community, and the right neighbors can make all the difference.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Understanding Herb Companion Planting Principles

Companion planting isn’t just folklore; it’s a strategy for building a small, resilient ecosystem. The core idea is to pair plants that help each other thrive. This works in a few key ways.

Some herbs release strong scents that mask the aroma of vulnerable vegetables, effectively hiding them from pests. Others exude compounds into the soil that deter nematodes or fungal diseases. It’s a subtle, preventative form of pest control that works around the clock without any effort on your part.

Beyond defense, some herbs attract beneficial insects. Flowering dill or borage act as landing pads for pollinators, boosting yields on your squash and cucumbers. They also draw in predatory insects like ladybugs and lacewings, which are a free, self-propagating security force against aphids and other pests.

Finally, certain pairings are thought to improve the health and even the flavor of their neighbors. While the science on this is less concrete, countless gardeners will tell you that a tomato grown near basil is a sweeter tomato. The goal isn’t magic—it’s about creating a diverse, balanced system where plants support each other.

Chart 1: Aromatic Herbs for Pest Deterrence

Strong-smelling herbs are your first line of defense. Their volatile oils confuse insects that hunt by scent, making it harder for them to find their target. Planting these around the borders of your garden beds or interspersing them among vulnerable crops is a simple, effective tactic.

Think of it as camouflage. A cabbage moth is looking for the specific scent of a brassica. If that scent is mixed with the powerful aroma of rosemary or thyme, the moth is more likely to get confused and fly on by. This won’t stop every single pest, but it significantly reduces the pressure.

Here are some of the heaviest hitters and the pests they’re known to deter:

• Basil: Repels tomato hornworms and whiteflies. A classic partner for tomatoes.
• Rosemary: Deters cabbage moths, bean beetles, and carrot rust flies.
• Thyme: Helps ward off cabbage worms.
• Mint: A powerhouse against ants, flea beetles, and aphids. Plant it in a container, as it will aggressively take over any bed it’s planted in.
• Chives & Garlic: Their strong sulfur compounds deter aphids and Japanese beetles. Excellent around roses and fruit trees.

Chart 2: Attracting Pollinators & Predators

A garden buzzing with life is a healthy garden. Attracting the right kind of insects is just as important as repelling the wrong ones. Many herbs produce small, clustered flowers that are perfect for beneficial insects, from tiny parasitic wasps to hardworking bees.

You’re not just planting for yourself; you’re building a habitat. These herbs provide nectar and pollen that sustain populations of predatory insects. When an aphid outbreak starts, your resident ladybugs and lacewing larvae are already on-site to manage the problem. This is how a garden starts to regulate itself.

Incorporate these "good bug" magnets throughout your garden:

• Borage: Famous for attracting bees and tiny predatory wasps. Its flowers are also edible.
• Dill & Fennel: The umbrella-shaped flowers are a favorite of ladybugs, lacewings, and hoverflies. Let a few plants go to seed.
• Chamomile: Draws in hoverflies and predatory wasps.
• Yarrow: A hardy perennial whose flat-topped flowers provide a perfect landing pad for ladybugs and parasitic wasps.
• Lemon Balm: Great for attracting honeybees. Like its cousin, mint, it’s best kept in a pot unless you want it everywhere.

Chart 3: Herbs that Improve Neighboring Flavor

This is where companion planting leans more into art than science, but it’s a tradition that many seasoned gardeners swear by. The theory is that the same aromatic oils that deter pests can be subtly absorbed by neighboring plants, enhancing their flavor. It’s a low-risk experiment with a potentially delicious payoff.

Don’t expect a night-and-day difference. The effect is subtle, more of a slight boost to a plant’s natural character. It’s about creating ideal growing conditions where a plant is less stressed and can put more energy into producing the sugars and compounds that create great taste.

Consider these classic flavor pairings:

• Basil & Tomatoes: The most famous pairing. Gardeners claim it improves tomato growth and flavor while repelling hornworms.
• Summer Savory & Beans: Traditionally called the "bean herb," it’s said to improve bean growth and flavor while deterring bean beetles.
• Chamomile & Cabbage: Known as the "plant doctor," a little chamomile is thought to improve the vigor and taste of brassicas like cabbage and broccoli.
• Marjoram: Widely believed to improve the flavor of most vegetables it’s planted near.

Chart 4: Best Herb Companions for Vegetables

Moving from theory to practice, this is about creating productive partnerships in your vegetable patch. The goal is a multi-layered defense and support system. A single herb can protect multiple vegetables from different threats.

When planning your layout, think in terms of guilds. A "tomato guild" might include tomatoes, basil (for hornworms), and borage (for pollinators). A "cabbage guild" could have cabbage, dill (to attract predatory wasps for cabbage worms), and thyme (to deter cabbage moths). This approach turns rows of monoculture into a diverse and confusing landscape for pests.

Here’s a quick reference chart for common garden vegetables:

• Tomatoes: Plant with Basil, Chives, or Parsley. Basil is the star player here.
• Cabbage Family (Broccoli, Kale, Cauliflower): Pair with Rosemary, Dill, Thyme, or Sage. These aromatic herbs help confuse the destructive cabbage moth.
• Carrots & Parsnips: Plant with Rosemary and Sage to help deter the carrot rust fly.
• Cucumbers: Borage is an excellent companion for attracting pollinators. Dill is also a good partner.
• Lettuce: Chives and Mint can help repel the aphids that often plague lettuce patches.
• Potatoes: Horseradish is a traditional companion said to deter potato beetles. Marjoram is also a good general companion.

Chart 5: Pairing Herbs for a Thriving Herb Bed

Not all herbs play well together, mostly because they have different needs. Grouping herbs by their preferred growing conditions is the key to a low-maintenance, productive herb garden. Forcing a water-loving herb to live in dry soil next to a Mediterranean native is a recipe for failure.

The most significant division is between the sun-loving, dry-soil herbs from the Mediterranean and the herbs that prefer richer soil and more consistent moisture. Plan your herb bed around these two distinct groups. It makes watering and care far simpler.

Create zones in your herb garden based on these needs:

• The Mediterranean Club (Full Sun, Well-Drained, Drier Soil): These herbs thrive on a bit of neglect.
  • Rosemary
  • Thyme
  • Sage
  • Oregano
  • Marjoram
  • Lavender
• The Moisture Lovers (Richer Soil, More Water): These herbs will wilt and struggle in the dry conditions the Mediterranean herbs love.
  • Parsley
  • Basil
  • Cilantro
  • Chives
  • Mint (in a pot!)

Chart 6: Common Antagonistic Herb Pairings

Just as some plants help each other, others actively hinder their neighbors. This is often due to a phenomenon called allelopathy, where a plant releases biochemicals into the soil that inhibit the growth of other plants. Knowing these bad pairings is crucial for avoiding frustration.

Some plants are just bullies. They may compete too aggressively for water and nutrients, or they might attract the same pests and diseases, creating a concentrated problem area. The most notorious offender is fennel, which seems to dislike almost everything and is best grown in isolation.

Keep these plants separated to ensure a peaceful garden:

• Fennel: Keep it far away from almost everything, especially dill (they can cross-pollinate, ruining the flavor of both) and beans.
• Dill & Carrots: They are in the same family and can attract the same pests, like carrot rust flies and spider mites.
• Sage: Avoid planting it near cucumbers, as it can stunt their growth.
• Rue: A powerful herb, but it can inhibit the growth of basil and sage.
• Mint & Parsley: Mint’s aggressive roots can easily choke out the more delicate parsley.

Observing and Adapting Your Planting Plan

These charts are excellent starting points, but they are not universal laws. Your specific soil, climate, and local pest pressures will determine what works best. The most important tool you have is observation.

Pay attention to your plants. Do the tomatoes next to the basil really look healthier than the ones planted alone? Is there less aphid damage on the lettuce near the chives? Keep a small notebook or take photos with your phone to track what works and what doesn’t from year to year.

Don’t be afraid to experiment. If a traditional pairing doesn’t seem to be doing much in your garden, try something different next season. Companion planting is a dynamic process. The goal is to learn the unique language of your own plot of land and build a plan that works for you.

Ultimately, companion planting is about shifting your mindset from simply growing plants to cultivating a garden ecosystem. By using herbs strategically, you create a more resilient, self-sufficient, and productive space. It’s a small investment in planning that pays off all season long.