6 Water Trough Materials Comparisons That Prevent Common Issues

You’ve seen it before: a green, slimy film coating the inside of a water trough, or a persistent muddy patch in the pasture from a slow leak you can’t seem to find. A bad water trough isn’t just an eyesore; it’s a time-sink and a potential health hazard for your animals. Choosing the right material from the start is one of the smartest investments you can make to save yourself work and worry down the road.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Choosing Troughs to Avoid Algae and Leaks

A water trough’s primary job is simple, but its failures create major headaches. The two most common problems—algae growth and leaks—are directly tied to the material the trough is made from.

Algae thrives with sunlight and a porous surface to cling to. Opaque and dark-colored materials block the sunlight that fuels algae blooms, while smooth, non-porous surfaces are far easier to scrub clean. Leaks often start at seams, drain plugs, or from cracks caused by sun exposure, freezing temperatures, or a well-placed kick from a cow.

Your goal is to find a material that naturally discourages algae and can withstand the unique pressures of your farm. This means considering your climate, the type of animals you have, and whether the trough needs to be permanent or portable. A cheap solution now can cost you dearly in time spent scrubbing and patching later.

Behlen Galvanized Steel Troughs for Longevity

Galvanized steel is the classic, time-tested option for a reason. These troughs are incredibly durable, resisting damage from both livestock and the sun’s harsh UV rays. They can last for decades with minimal care.

The zinc coating on galvanized steel does more than just prevent rust; it also naturally inhibits algae and bacterial growth, keeping water cleaner for longer. This is a significant advantage, reducing how often you need to do a full scrub-out. While they are heavy and difficult to move, their weight also means they won’t get pushed around by cattle or horses.

The main vulnerability of a steel trough is the galvanized coating itself. If it gets deeply scratched or chipped, rust can set in. Be mindful of using salt blocks or mineral supplements directly in the trough, as the salt can accelerate corrosion and shorten its lifespan significantly.

Tuff Stuff Poly Troughs: Lightweight & Versatile

Polyethylene, or "poly," troughs have become incredibly popular on hobby farms. Their biggest advantage is their weight. You can easily flip one over to dump and scrub it, or haul it to a new pasture without needing heavy equipment.

These troughs are seamless, which eliminates a common point of failure for leaks. They won’t rust or corrode, and they have some flex, allowing them to absorb impacts from animals without cracking. For algae prevention, always choose a dark color like black or dark green, as lighter-colored poly can be translucent enough to let sunlight in and encourage growth.

The tradeoff for this convenience is durability over the very long term. While modern poly is UV-stabilized, it can eventually become brittle after many years in direct sun. They are also light enough that determined animals can nudge them, potentially spilling water or damaging plumbing connections if you have a float valve installed.

Fortiflex Rubber Tubs Resist Cracking in Winter

If you farm in a place with harsh winters, you know the destructive power of ice. Frozen water expands, and that expansion can easily crack rigid plastic or even split the seams on a steel tank. This is where rubber troughs shine.

Made from reinforced rubber, these tubs are flexible enough to handle freezing and thawing cycles without breaking. You can often stomp on the side of a frozen rubber tub to break the ice loose without worrying about damaging the container. This feature alone makes them a top choice for cold-climate farms.

They are, however, typically smaller than steel or poly troughs, making them better suited for smaller herds like goats and sheep, or for use in individual stalls. They are also surprisingly heavy for their size, which keeps them stable but makes them a bit more work to move than a poly tub of similar capacity.

Bohlmann Concrete for Permanent Installations

For a truly permanent, "set it and forget it" solution, nothing beats concrete. A concrete trough is an anchor in your pasture. It won’t be pushed around, damaged by animals, or affected by weather.

One of concrete’s best features is its thermal mass. The thick walls insulate the water, keeping it noticeably cooler in the summer heat. Cooler water is more appealing to livestock and can help reduce the growth rate of bacteria and algae.

The downsides are significant but straightforward. Installation is a major undertaking requiring a level pad and equipment to move the trough into place. And once it’s there, it’s there. Its porous surface can also give algae a foothold if not scrubbed periodically, though many modern concrete troughs come with a smoother interior finish to help mitigate this.

Hastings Fiberglass Tanks Resist Rust, Corrosion

Fiberglass tanks represent a step up in both performance and price. They combine many of the best qualities of other materials into one package. They are lighter than steel but more rigid and durable than poly.

The key benefit of fiberglass is its completely non-porous, smooth interior surface. This makes it extremely easy to clean and highly resistant to algae growth. Unlike steel, it will never rust or corrode, even if you mix supplements or electrolytes directly into the water. It also stands up well to UV exposure over the long haul.

While they are an excellent all-around choice, their higher upfront cost can be a barrier. For operations where hygiene is a top priority or where you simply want a long-lasting trough with minimal cleaning hassles, the investment in fiberglass can pay for itself over time.

Ritchie Stainless Steel for Ultimate Hygiene

When absolute hygiene is non-negotiable, stainless steel is the undisputed champion. Used extensively in dairy operations, its non-porous surface is the most resistant to bacterial growth and the easiest to sanitize. Nothing sticks to it, making cleaning incredibly fast and effective.

Like fiberglass, stainless steel is completely immune to rust and corrosion, so it’s safe for any type of supplement. It reflects sunlight, helping to keep water a bit cooler. Many stainless steel troughs are also available in heated, automatic-filling models, representing the peak of watering technology.

The primary drawback is, of course, the cost. Stainless steel is by far the most expensive option, and its price tag often places it outside the budget of a typical hobby farm. However, if you are raising sensitive animals, producing milk, or simply want the cleanest possible water source with the least amount of effort, it is the ultimate choice.

Matching Trough Material to Your Climate & Herd

There is no single "best" trough material; the right choice depends entirely on your specific needs. The key is to match the material’s strengths to your farm’s challenges.

Use these factors as a simple decision-making framework:

• For Cold Winters: Rubber is the clear winner for its ability to flex with ice.
• For Hot Summers: Concrete excels at keeping water cool. Dark-colored poly or fiberglass are also good choices.
• For Portability/Rotational Grazing: Poly is unmatched. Its light weight makes it easy to move with your animals.
• For Durability & Longevity: Galvanized steel and concrete are the top contenders for permanent or semi-permanent setups.
• For Ultimate Cleanliness: Fiberglass offers a great balance of hygiene and cost, while stainless steel is the premium, no-compromise option.

Think about your biggest frustration. Is it scrubbing algae, dealing with winter ice, or moving a heavy tank? Start there. A heavy-duty steel trough is perfect for a permanent cattle pasture but a terrible choice for rotating sheep through different paddocks. A lightweight poly tub is ideal for goats but might not last a season with destructive hogs. Choose the tool that solves your most persistent problem.

Your water trough is a daily tool, and investing in the right one pays you back every day in saved time, effort, and peace of mind. By thinking through your climate, animals, and management style, you can choose a material that works for you, not against you, for years to come.