6 First Year Goat Breed Mistakes For Milk and How to Avoid Them

You’ve built the milk stand, cleared the pasture, and your dreams are filled with fresh chevre and creamy lattes. The final step is choosing your first dairy goats, a decision that feels both exciting and permanent. But the breed you bring home will shape your daily chores, your farm’s budget, and your overall success for years to come.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why Your First Dairy Goat Breed Choice Matters

Choosing your first dairy goat isn’t like picking a paint color you can easily change. This is a long-term commitment to a living, breathing animal that will become part of your farm’s ecosystem. The right breed fits your land, your goals, and your personality, making chores a joy. The wrong one can lead to frustration, unexpected costs, and a steep, stressful learning curve.

Think of it as hiring an employee for a very specific job. You wouldn’t hire a miniature pony to pull a heavy plow, and you shouldn’t choose a goat breed without understanding its core strengths and weaknesses. This single decision impacts everything from your feed bill and fencing requirements to the very quality of the milk in your pail. Getting it right from the start saves you time, money, and heartache.

Ignoring Butterfat for High Volume Breeds

It’s easy to get seduced by the numbers. Breeds like Saanens and Alpines are famous for producing a gallon or more of milk per day, and that sounds incredible. But milk isn’t just water; its value often lies in its components, specifically the butterfat and protein content. High-volume breeds often produce milk with lower butterfat, which can be thin and less ideal for rich dairy products.

If your goal is making cheese, butter, or thick, creamy yogurt, butterfat is your best friend. A smaller quantity of high-butterfat milk from a Nigerian Dwarf or Nubian will yield far more cheese than a larger quantity of lower-fat milk. A gallon of 6% butterfat milk is a cheesemaker’s dream. A gallon of 2.5% butterfat milk is better suited for drinking.

Don’t just ask, "How much milk does she make?" Instead, ask, "What kind of milk does she make?" For homesteaders focused on quality over sheer quantity, a breed known for high components is almost always the better choice. You’ll work smarter, not harder, getting more finished product from every drop in the bucket.

Underestimating the Size of Standard Breeds

That adorable 15-pound Alpine kid will not stay that way. A full-grown standard-sized doe (like an Alpine, Saanen, Nubian, or LaMancha) can easily weigh 130-175 pounds and stand nearly three feet tall at the shoulder. This has massive implications for your infrastructure and your ability to handle the animal.

A goat that size is a powerful animal. They require stronger, taller fencing—48 inches is the bare minimum, and 60 inches is better. They need more space in their shelter, consume significantly more hay, and can be physically intimidating to manage, especially for a new owner. Wrestling a stubborn 150-pound goat is a very different experience than managing a 75-pound one.

This is where miniature breeds like the Nigerian Dwarf shine for smaller homesteads. Their smaller stature means they eat less, require less space, and are far easier to handle. Before you fall in love with a standard breed, be brutally honest about your physical space and your comfort level with managing a large, strong animal.

Overlooking a Breed’s Unique Temperament

Goats are not generic. Each breed was developed for a purpose, and their temperaments often reflect that history. Ignoring these ingrained personality traits is a classic rookie mistake that directly impacts your daily enjoyment.

Nubians, for example, are famous for being the "divas" of the goat world. They are vocal, often dramatic, and demand attention, but are also known for being incredibly affectionate and personable. In contrast, LaManchas are famously calm, even-keeled, and unflappable—excellent for a busy or noisy farmstead. Alpines tend to be curious, independent, and all-business on the milk stand.

Think about what you want from your daily interactions. Do you want a quiet companion or a chatty "in-your-pocket" pet? A loud, needy goat can be charming to one person and a complete nuisance to another, especially if you have close neighbors. Match the temperament to your own personality, not just the production stats.

Selecting a Breed Lacking Local Availability

Falling in love with a rare or uncommon breed from a picture online is easy. The reality of owning one can be a logistical nightmare. If you can’t find other breeders within a reasonable driving distance, you’ve created a significant long-term problem for yourself.

Where will you find an unrelated, quality buck for breeding when the time comes? Who can you call for advice when you encounter a problem specific to that breed? Finding a mentor who knows the quirks of your chosen breed is invaluable, and that’s nearly impossible if you’re the only one in three counties raising them. Even finding a veterinarian with experience in that specific breed can be a challenge.

Stick with breeds that have a solid presence in your region. You’ll benefit from a network of experienced breeders, a larger genetic pool to choose from, and a community of people who can help you succeed. The "cool factor" of an obscure breed wears off quickly when you’re facing a problem alone.

Ignoring Breed-Specific Health Considerations

Not all goats are created equal when it comes to hardiness. Some breeds are better suited to hot, humid climates, while others thrive in cold, dry regions. Choosing a breed that is a poor match for your environment is setting yourself up for a constant battle with health issues.

For instance, breeds developed in dry, mountainous regions may have lower resistance to the heavy parasite loads common in wet, warm climates like the American Southeast. Some lines within certain breeds may also have genetic predispositions to specific conditions. Doing your homework on what thrives in your local area can save you a fortune in vet bills and a world of stress.

Talk to local goat keepers and large-animal vets. Ask them which breeds they see the most and which ones seem to have the fewest problems in your specific climate. Choose a breed known for thriving in your backyard, not one you’ll have to constantly struggle to keep healthy.

The Pitfalls of Buying Unregistered Stock

For a first-timer, the temptation to save a few hundred dollars on an unregistered goat is strong. This is almost always a mistake. Registration papers from a reputable association like the ADGA (American Dairy Goat Association) are more than just a fancy piece of paper; they are your best insurance policy.

Registered stock comes with a known history. You know the animal’s lineage, which helps you avoid inbreeding and select for desirable traits. Often, you can look up the production records of its dam and grand-dams, giving you a strong indication of its genetic potential for milk production. With an unregistered "farm goat," you’re gambling. You have no idea if her mother was a great milker or a terrible one.

Furthermore, buying registered animals connects you to a community of serious breeders who are invested in improving the breed. These are the people who can become your mentors. While a healthy, productive unregistered goat is certainly possible, the risk of getting an animal with poor genetics, low production, or conformational faults is dramatically higher. Pay for the predictability; it’s worth every penny in the long run.

Matching the Breed to Your Farm’s Long-Term Goals

Ultimately, the perfect breed is the one that aligns with your vision for your farm. Before you look at a single goat, you need to define what "success" means to you. The answer will point you directly to the right breed.

Are you simply trying to provide enough milk for your family’s daily needs? A pair of Nigerian Dwarfs or a single Mini-Mancha might be perfect, providing a manageable amount of high-quality milk without overwhelming you. Or are you planning a small, commercial creamery? In that case, a small herd of high-producing Alpines or Saanens, which are known for their long, steady lactations, would be a more logical choice.

Consider these different goals and how they match up with common breed strengths:

• Family Milk & Pets: Nigerian Dwarf, Mini-LaMancha (Easy handling, rich milk, efficient).
• Homestead Cheesemaking: Nubian, Nigerian Dwarf (High butterfat is key).
• High Volume for Drinking/Soap: Alpine, Saanen, LaMancha (High production, steady lactation).
• Showing & Breeding Stock Sales: Any breed, but requires buying from top-tier, proven genetics.

Don’t choose a breed because your neighbor has it or because you saw a cute picture. Choose the breed that is the best tool for the job you are asking it to do. This clarity of purpose is the single most important factor in making a choice you’ll be happy with for years.

Your first goats are a foundational investment in your homestead’s future. By avoiding these common pitfalls, you move beyond just buying an animal and start building a productive, sustainable, and enjoyable dairy herd. Choose wisely, and you’ll be rewarded with a full milk pail and a fuller heart.