7 Metal Shed Vs Plastic Shed For Equipment Storage On a Homestead Budget

That new tiller is a back-saver, but leaving it out in the rain is a fast track to a pile of rust. You need a dedicated space for your equipment, but a full-blown barn isn’t in the budget. This is where the humble storage shed becomes one of the most important investments on a small homestead.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Arrow Sheds vs. Lifetime Sheds: The Core Trade-Offs

When you start shopping, you’ll quickly see the market divides into two camps: thin-walled steel sheds, like those from Arrow, and double-walled plastic (or resin) sheds, like those from Lifetime. The choice isn’t just about materials; it’s a fundamental decision about your time, your climate, and your tolerance for maintenance. This is the classic battle of upfront cost versus long-term convenience.

A metal Arrow shed will almost always be cheaper for the same square footage. That immediate savings is tempting when you have a long list of other homestead needs. But that lower price comes with a bill later—in assembly time, in the need for a perfectly level foundation, and in the constant fight against rust.

A plastic Lifetime shed, on the other hand, asks for more money upfront. In return, it offers a much simpler assembly and a structure that is fundamentally immune to rust and rot. You’re essentially paying a premium to buy back your future weekends.

• Metal Sheds (Arrow): Lower initial cost, higher dent resistance, more assembly complexity, requires rust prevention.
• Plastic Sheds (Lifetime): Higher initial cost, rust and rot proof, easier assembly, potentially less secure.

Arrow Newport Steel Shed: Superior Dent Resistance

Steel sheds have one major structural advantage: they handle blunt force better. When you’re tired at the end of the day and carelessly lean a heavy t-post or a shovel against the wall, a steel shed will likely just get a small dent. It might not be pretty, but the wall’s integrity remains.

This is a real consideration for how we actually use things on a homestead. We’re not always careful. A plastic shed, especially in cold weather, can become brittle. A sharp impact from the corner of a cultivator could potentially puncture or crack a plastic wall, leading to a much more difficult repair. The thin steel of an Arrow shed is tougher than it looks against the kind of abuse a working tool shed endures.

Suncast Tremont Resin Shed: Resists Rust and Rot

The single greatest enemy of any metal structure on a farm is moisture. It’s in the air, on the ground, and on the tools you put away after a morning dew. This is where a resin shed, like a Suncast Tremont, truly shines. It simply cannot rust.

This isn’t a small benefit; it’s a game-changer. You don’t have to worry about scratches in the paint becoming rust blooms. You don’t have to stress about the base wicking moisture and rotting out the bottom panel. If you live in a humid climate, a plastic shed eliminates a massive, ongoing maintenance headache before it even starts.

You can even wash it out with a hose without a second thought. Try that with a metal shed, and you’re just inviting rust into every seam and screw hole. For storing anything sensitive to dampness, from seed bags to animal feed, the weather-tight, rot-proof nature of plastic is a clear winner.

Assembling a Rubbermaid Shed: Snap-Together Ease

Never underestimate the value of your time. Assembling a metal shed is a notoriously frustrating project involving hundreds of tiny screws, sharp edges, and panels that refuse to align perfectly. It’s a two-person job that can easily consume an entire weekend, and every single one of those screws is a potential failure point for water to get in.

In stark contrast, many plastic sheds, especially models from brands like Rubbermaid, are engineered for the homeowner. They often feature snap-together panels, pre-drilled holes that actually line up, and instructions that make sense. A reasonably handy person can often assemble a medium-sized plastic shed alone in a single afternoon.

This isn’t just about convenience. A shed that goes together easily is also more likely to be assembled correctly, resulting in a more weather-tight and durable structure from day one. You’re not just buying a shed; you’re buying a much less frustrating Saturday.

ShelterLogic Steel Sheds: The Need for Rust Proofing

The sticker price on a steel shed is deceptive. To get a decent service life out of one, you must build a proper foundation. Placing it directly on the ground is a death sentence; moisture will wick up and begin corroding the base almost immediately.

At a minimum, you need a treated wood frame or a gravel pad that allows for drainage. This adds cost and labor to the project. Furthermore, you should plan to seal the inside seams along the base with a quality silicone caulk during assembly. This simple step is rarely emphasized in the instructions but is crucial for keeping wind-driven rain and ground moisture out.

Keter Factor Plastic Shed: Security Limitations

Here is the biggest drawback of plastic: security. While great against weather, a resin wall offers little resistance to a determined thief. A simple utility knife or a small handsaw can cut through the wall of many plastic sheds, especially the single-walled models.

The locking mechanisms are also a weak point. Most plastic sheds rely on a simple plastic hasp that slides through slots in the doors, secured with a padlock. This is a visual deterrent at best. The hasp itself can often be pried or broken off with minimal effort.

If you are storing high-value equipment like chainsaws, generators, or expensive power tools, a metal shed offers a significant security advantage. While not a fortress, a locked steel shed requires more noise and effort to breach, which is often enough to deter casual theft.

Duramax Metal Sheds: Lower Upfront Homestead Cost

Let’s be realistic: budget is king. For the price of a small 8×6 plastic shed, you can often get a much larger 10×8 or even 10×12 metal shed. On a homestead where every dollar is allocated, getting more secure, covered square footage for less money is a powerful argument.

This choice allows you to protect more of your equipment—the lawn tractor, the tiller, the wheelbarrows—under one roof right now. You are trading future maintenance for immediate utility. For many, this is the right call. It’s better to have a slightly-less-perfect shed protecting all your gear than a perfect shed that only fits half of it.

Final Verdict: Lifetime Plastic for Low-Maintenance

After weighing the trade-offs, the recommendation for most time-strapped hobby farmers is a quality, steel-reinforced, double-walled plastic shed. The higher upfront cost is an investment in peace of mind and, more importantly, in your own time. A homestead has an endless list of chores that are far more critical than repainting a shed or sealing rust spots.

The ease of assembly means you get your storage solution built and functional in a fraction of the time. Its immunity to rust and rot means you can place it and largely forget about it. While a metal shed wins on initial cost and security, the low-maintenance, "good enough" nature of a quality plastic shed better serves the practical realities of a busy homestead.

Ultimately, your shed’s job is to make your life easier by protecting your tools without becoming another demanding project. Choose the option that best frees you up to do the actual work of farming.