6 Broiler Chick Sourcing And Selection For First-Year Success

That first look at a hatchery catalog can be overwhelming. Dozens of breeds, shipping dates stretching for months, and terms like "straight run" and "cockerels" can make your head spin. But the choices you make before your chicks even hatch will define your entire season. Getting your sourcing and selection right is the single most important step toward a freezer full of clean, healthy meat.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Key Broiler Types: Cornish Cross vs. Rangers

Your first major decision isn’t where to buy, but what to buy. This choice comes down to two main camps: the fast-growing Cornish Cross and the more active Ranger-type birds. Each serves a completely different purpose and demands a different management style.

The Cornish Cross is a production powerhouse, an eight-week miracle of feed conversion. It’s bred for one thing: to convert high-protein feed into breast meat with incredible efficiency. This bird is the right choice if your primary goal is maximum meat in minimum time within a controlled, clean environment like a chicken tractor on a lawn. The tradeoff is their fragility; they are prone to leg and heart issues if mismanaged or grown past their ideal processing window.

Ranger-type broilers (often sold as Freedom Rangers, Red Rangers, or similar names) are a different animal entirely. They take longer to mature, typically 9 to 12 weeks, and have a less dramatic feed conversion ratio. What you gain is resilience. These birds are excellent foragers, far more heat-tolerant, and better equipped to handle the challenges of a true pasture environment. If your system involves more rugged terrain or you value a more active, "chicken-like" bird, the Ranger is your clear choice.

Ordering from National Hatcheries for Variety

When you want a specific breed on a specific date, national hatcheries are your go-to source. They offer an unparalleled selection of genetics, from the fastest-growing Cornish strains to various Ranger types, all scheduled months in advance. You place your order online or by phone, and the day-old chicks ship directly to your local post office.

This method requires planning. Hatcheries sell out of popular breeds and ship dates early, so ordering in winter for a spring arrival is standard practice. Be aware of order minimums, which are typically 15 to 25 chicks to ensure the birds stay warm enough during transit. While shipping is a stressful event for tiny chicks and you may experience a few losses, it’s often the only way to get the exact genetics you want for your system.

Buying Day-Olds from Your Local Feed Store

Walking into a feed store and seeing a brooder full of peeping chicks is a classic sign of spring. This is by far the most accessible and lowest-risk way to get started. There are no shipping concerns, no order minimums, and you can visually inspect the chicks before you buy them.

This convenience comes with a major tradeoff: lack of choice. Your local store will almost certainly be selling Cornish Cross, and you won’t have a say in the specific hatchery or strain. For a first-year grower just wanting to raise 10 or 15 birds without the commitment of a large hatchery order, this is a perfect entry point. It allows you to learn the brooding and grow-out process on a small, manageable scale.

Sourcing from Local Breeders for Resilience

For those prioritizing hardiness, sourcing chicks from a local breeder is an excellent option. These birds are often from parent stock that is already adapted to your specific climate, pests, and regional challenges. You’re not just buying a chick; you’re buying genetics proven to work right where you live.

Finding a reputable local breeder requires more effort than a simple online order. You’ll need to network, check local farming groups, and be prepared to ask questions about biosecurity and flock health. The supply can be limited and less predictable than a commercial hatchery. However, the ability to see the parent flock and their living conditions provides a level of transparency you can’t get anywhere else, often resulting in exceptionally vigorous birds.

Assessing Chick Vigor and Health Upon Arrival

The first hour after you get your chicks home is the most critical. Whether you’ve picked them up from the post office or the feed store, your immediate assessment can prevent future problems. A healthy chick is active, alert, and noisy.

Before placing them in the brooder, check each one individually. Look for these key signs:

• Active and alert: They should be trying to get away from you, not lethargic.
• Dry and fluffy: No wet, matted down, or sticky feathers.
• Clean vents: The area below the tail should be clean, with no caked-on droppings, a condition known as "pasty butt."
• Clear eyes and nostrils: No swelling or discharge.
• Straight legs and toes: No obvious deformities that would hinder mobility.

Gently dip each chick’s beak in their waterer to teach them where to drink, then place them under the heat source. A healthy flock will quickly start exploring, drinking, and pecking at food. Any chick that seems weak or listless should be monitored closely and, if necessary, separated to prevent the spread of potential illness.

Understanding Straight Run, Pullets, and Cockerels

When you order chicks, you’ll see options for how the flock is sorted by sex. Understanding these terms is crucial for managing your flock’s growth and your budget.

For broiler chickens, the most common option is straight run. This means you get the chicks just as they hatched, with a mix of males and females that is roughly 50/50. This is the most economical and straightforward choice, and it’s what you’ll almost always get at a feed store.

You may also see options for pullets (females) or cockerels (males). For meat production, ordering all cockerels can be advantageous. Males of broiler breeds grow faster and larger than females, so an all-male flock will reach a uniform processing weight more quickly. An all-pullet flock is almost never offered or desired for meat birds. For your first time, stick with a straight run to keep things simple.

Matching Broiler Breed to Your Pasture System

The phrase "pasture-raised" means different things to different people, and your specific system should dictate your breed choice. A Cornish Cross thrives in a low-stress environment where it doesn’t have to work hard for its food. They are perfectly suited for "chicken tractors"—mobile floorless pens moved daily across a flat, clean pasture or lawn. This system minimizes their movement and protects their fragile legs while still providing fresh forage.

Ranger-type birds, on the other hand, are built for a more active life. If your "pasture" is a rugged hillside, a food forest, or a multi-species paddock, Rangers are the superior choice. They will actively forage for insects and plants, handle uneven terrain without issue, and are more savvy about potential predators. Putting a Cornish Cross in this kind of dynamic environment is setting it up for failure, while a Ranger will thrive.

Calculating Your Flock Size for Feed Efficiency

It’s tempting to order 50 chicks your first year, but starting small is the key to success. Your flock size should be determined by your available space, time, and budget—not just your desired freezer inventory. Overcrowding is a primary cause of stress, disease, and poor growth.

Work backward from your resources. First, consider brooder space (0.5 sq. ft. per chick) and grow-out space (at least 1.5-2 sq. ft. per bird in a tractor). Then, do the math on feed. A single Cornish Cross will eat roughly 10 pounds of feed to reach a 5-pound processing weight. Multiplying that by 25, 50, or 100 birds reveals that feed is your single largest expense.

For a first-year project, a flock of 15 to 25 birds is a perfect size. It’s large enough to make the effort worthwhile and provide a significant amount of meat, but small enough to be managed without becoming overwhelmed. This size keeps feed costs reasonable, makes daily chores manageable, and ensures processing day is a productive learning experience rather than a frantic ordeal.

Ultimately, successful broiler raising begins long before the chicks arrive. It starts with an honest assessment of your land, your goals, and your management style. By choosing the right breed, sourcing from a reputable supplier, and starting with a manageable flock size, you set the foundation for a successful and rewarding season.