6 Hay Testing For Nutritional Value That Prevents Winter Feed Issues

You stand there in late fall, looking at a stack of hay that represents months of work and a significant investment. It looks good, smells sweet, and feels right. But what is it really worth to your animals? Relying on your senses alone is a gamble, and in farming, a gamble in the fall can lead to a crisis by late winter. Hay testing is the single most effective tool for turning that gamble into a calculated plan, ensuring your livestock thrive through the coldest months.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why Visual Hay Inspection Isn’t Enough

We all do it. We grab a handful of hay, check for a nice green color, give it a good sniff for sweetness, and check for dust or mold. These are important quality checks, but they tell you almost nothing about the hay’s actual nutritional content. That beautiful, green hay might be low in protein because it was cut late, after the plant had matured and put its energy into seed heads instead of leaves.

A slightly sun-bleached or brownish hay might look unappealing, but it could have been cut at peak maturity and simply got a little sun on the outside of the bale. Its core nutritional value could be far superior to the prettier hay next to it. Visuals can’t detect mineral deficiencies, high nitrate levels from over-fertilization, or the subtle differences in fiber digestibility that determine whether an animal thrives or just survives. Judging hay by its cover is one of the most common and costly mistakes a farmer can make.

Proper Core Sampling for Accurate Results

The old saying "garbage in, garbage out" has never been more true than with hay testing. A poorly taken sample will give you useless, misleading information. Grabbing a handful from the side of a bale won’t work; you’ll only get the most weathered, least representative part of the hay. To get a true picture, you need to invest in a proper hay probe or corer.

The process is straightforward but requires discipline. For each "lot" of hay—meaning hay cut from the same field at the same time under the same conditions—you need to sample between 10 and 20 bales. Push the probe deep into the short side of a square bale or toward the center of a round bale to get a cross-section of the flakes. Combine all the core samples from that lot into a single zip-top bag, mix it thoroughly, and pull out a subsample to send to the lab.

It’s absolutely critical to test each lot separately. Your first-cutting orchard grass from June is a completely different feed than your third-cutting alfalfa from August. Mixing them into one sample gives you an average that represents nothing you are actually feeding, making it impossible to balance a ration accurately.

Crude Protein (CP): Fueling Growth and Production

When you get your test results, Crude Protein (CP) is often the first number people look for, and for good reason. Protein is the essential building block for muscle development, fetal growth, and milk production. Think of it as the engine-building material for your livestock. Without enough of it, everything else slows down or stops.

The key is matching the CP in your hay to the specific needs of your animals. A mature gelding or a dry ewe might only need 8-10% CP to maintain their condition. However, a lactating dairy goat, a pregnant mare in her last trimester, or rapidly growing lambs need a much higher level, often in the 14-18% range. Knowing your hay’s CP tells you if it meets those needs or if you need to supplement.

Feeding too little protein is a recipe for unthrifty animals, poor growth rates, and weak offspring. On the flip side, feeding excess protein is like throwing money away. The animal’s body will just break down the extra protein and excrete it, which can be hard on their system and your wallet. The hay test lets you find that "just right" balance.

Measuring Energy: TDN, RFV, and RFQ Explained

After protein, energy is the next critical component. It’s the fuel that runs the engine. A test report gives you a few different ways to measure this, and it’s easy to get lost in the alphabet soup. The most important ones to understand are TDN, RFV, and RFQ.

Total Digestible Nutrients (TDN) is the simplest measure. It’s a straightforward percentage representing the total amount of digestible energy-providing components in the feed. A higher TDN means more "gas in the tank" per pound of hay. It’s a reliable, old-school number that’s easy to use for ration balancing.

Relative Feed Value (RFV) was developed to create an index for comparing different alfalfa hays. It predicts intake and digestibility, but it’s less accurate when comparing grasses to legumes. Relative Forage Quality (RFQ) is the modern, more accurate replacement. RFQ uses a direct measure of fiber digestibility, making it a much better tool for comparing any type of forage, from straight grass to mixed hay. If your test provides RFQ, it’s the most reliable number for predicting animal performance.

ADF and NDF: Understanding Hay Fiber Content

Fiber is not just filler; it’s the foundation of a healthy ruminant or hindgut-fermenter’s diet. The hay test breaks fiber down into two key numbers: ADF and NDF. Understanding them is key to knowing how your hay will perform.

Neutral Detergent Fiber (NDF) represents the total fiber content, including the good, the bad, and the ugly. Think of NDF as a measure of "fullness." The higher the NDF, the longer the hay stays in the rumen, and the quicker the animal feels full. A high NDF hay limits how much an animal can physically eat, which can prevent them from getting the calories and protein they need, even if the hay is otherwise decent.

Acid Detergent Fiber (ADF) measures the least digestible parts of the plant, primarily cellulose and lignin. Think of ADF as a direct indicator of digestibility. A lower ADF number is always better. As a plant matures, it becomes more woody and its ADF increases, making it harder for the animal to extract energy from it. A low ADF means more of the hay is converted into usable energy.

Mineral Analysis: Calcium, Phosphorus, and More

Protein and energy get all the attention, but mineral imbalances can cause some of the most frustrating and hard-to-diagnose health problems on a small farm. A basic mineral analysis is an inexpensive add-on to a standard hay test and provides invaluable information. It moves you from guessing with a generic mineral block to knowing exactly what your animals need.

The most critical relationship to watch is the Calcium (Ca) to Phosphorus (P) ratio. For most livestock, especially small ruminants, this ratio should be around 2:1. Legume hays like alfalfa are naturally high in calcium, while many grains are high in phosphorus. If the ratio gets inverted, with more phosphorus than calcium, it can lead to urinary calculi—painful and often fatal blockages—in male animals like wethers, bucks, and rams.

Your test will also show levels of other vital minerals like magnesium, potassium, and sulfur. Knowing these levels helps you choose the right free-choice mineral supplement. If your hay is low in magnesium, you’ll know to provide a high-mag mineral in late winter to prevent grass tetany when the new grass comes in. Without a test, you’re just flying blind.

Decoding the Numbers on Your Forage Test Results

When the report arrives, it can look like a spreadsheet from another planet. Don’t be intimidated. You only need to focus on a few key values to make smart decisions. First, look for the "Dry Matter" (DM) column; all the important values are calculated on a dry matter basis to provide an apples-to-apples comparison.

Next, find your primary targets: Crude Protein (CP) and an energy value like TDN or RFQ. Ask yourself: Are these numbers high enough for my most demanding group of animals (e.g., lactating does, growing lambs)? Or is this more of a "maintenance" hay for my idle animals?

Then, check your fiber numbers, ADF and NDF. Are they low enough to indicate good digestibility and intake? Finally, look at the Calcium (Ca) and Phosphorus (P) levels. Calculate the ratio (divide the Ca % by the P %) to ensure it’s in a safe range, ideally above 1.5:1. By focusing on these five or six key numbers, you can quickly build a complete profile of your forage and what it offers.

Balancing Rations Based on Your Hay’s Profile

The hay test isn’t just an academic exercise; it’s a practical roadmap for winter feeding. Your goal is to use your hay as the foundation of the diet and supplement only what is missing. This approach saves money, prevents waste, and keeps your animals in peak condition.

For example, your test comes back showing your grass hay is 9% CP with a good TDN of 56%. This is a perfect feed for your dry ewes, who will do great on it with just a quality free-choice mineral. However, your lactating ewes with twins need closer to 16% CP. Instead of feeding them more grain (which primarily adds energy they don’t need), you now know to supplement with a targeted protein source like alfalfa pellets or soybean meal.

In another scenario, your beautiful first-cutting alfalfa tests at an impressive 19% CP, but it got rained on and the TDN is a low 52%. This hay has plenty of protein, but it lacks energy. For animals in late gestation, you’ll need to supplement with an energy source like beet pulp or corn to prevent them from losing body condition. The test empowers you to make these precise, cost-effective decisions, preventing problems before they start.

Ultimately, testing your hay is the cheapest insurance you can buy for your livestock. It replaces guesswork with data, allowing you to be a proactive manager who anticipates needs rather than a reactive one who is always trying to catch up. That knowledge is power, providing peace of mind through the winter and healthier, more productive animals come spring.