5 Steps for Harvesting Potatoes With A Broadfork Your Grandparents Knew

The potato vines have yellowed and collapsed, a sure sign that the growing season is ending. Below the surface, a hidden treasure awaits, but getting it out without damage is the real challenge. This isn’t about brute force; it’s about a technique that respects the soil and the crop, a method our grandparents understood well.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Timing the Harvest: When Potato Vines Die Back

The most reliable signal for harvesting storage potatoes is the state of the vines. When the plants have finished their work of creating tubers, the foliage will naturally begin to yellow, wither, and die back completely. This is your cue that the potatoes have reached maturity and are entering a dormant phase.

Don’t rush to dig the moment you see the first yellow leaf. After the vines have fully died back, it’s best to leave the tubers in the ground for another two to three weeks, provided the soil isn’t waterlogged. This waiting period allows the potato skins to "set" or thicken, making them far more resistant to scuffs and bruises during harvest. A thicker skin is the first line of defense against rot in storage.

Be mindful of the cause of dieback. If vines die early due to blight or disease, you may need to harvest sooner to salvage the crop. However, for a healthy crop, patience is key. Harvesting too early results in thin-skinned potatoes that won’t store well, while waiting too long, especially into wet fall weather, invites rot and pest damage.

Using the Broadfork: Straddle the Row Technique

The proper way to begin is by positioning your body, not just the tool. Stand over the potato row, straddling the area where the plant’s main stem enters the ground. This stance gives you maximum balance and leverage while ensuring you don’t compact the very soil you’re about to lift.

With your feet planted firmly on either side of the row, drive the broadfork‘s tines into the ground about six to eight inches away from the center of the plant. You want to go alongside the main cluster of tubers, not directly into them. Use your body weight to sink the tines straight down as deep as they will go. This parallel placement is the secret to avoiding accidental spearing.

Leveraging the Tines to Gently Lift the Soil

Once the tines are fully sunk, the real work begins, and it’s all about leverage. Pull the handles back towards you, using your body weight as a counterbalance. You should feel the entire section of soil heave and lift upwards. The goal is not to flip the soil over like you would with a digging fork, but to gently fracture and raise the earth.

This lifting action loosens the soil structure around the potatoes without violent agitation. You’ll often see the ground crack and swell as the tubers are raised closer to the surface. For particularly compacted soil or long rows, you may need to repeat this process on both sides of the row to ensure the entire root zone is loosened. The broadfork acts like a gentle lever, not a sharp shovel.

Hand-Gathering Tubers from the Loosened Earth

With the soil lifted and fractured, the potatoes are now accessible. This is where the hands-on part begins. Gently work your fingers through the loosened earth, feeling for the firm, round shapes of the tubers. They will often be clustered near the main stem but can sometimes spread out, so be thorough.

As you pull the potatoes out, gently brush off the excess dirt and place them carefully into a harvest basket or bin. Avoid tossing them, as even a short drop can cause bruising that may not be visible until weeks later in storage. Leave the harvested potatoes on the surface of the soil for a few hours to let the skins dry, but no longer—prolonged exposure to sunlight will cause them to turn green and produce solanine, which is toxic.

Curing Your Potatoes to Toughen Up the Skins

Harvesting is just the first step; curing is what prepares potatoes for long-term storage. This process allows minor cuts and scrapes to heal over and the skins to toughen up significantly. An uncured potato is a fragile thing, highly susceptible to moisture loss and rot.

To cure them, find a place that is dark, relatively humid (around 85-95%), and moderately warm (55-65°F or 13-18°C). A garage, shed, or covered porch out of direct sun can work well. Spread the potatoes out in a single layer on newspaper or in shallow crates, ensuring good air circulation. Let them sit like this for one to two weeks. This step is non-negotiable for a successful winter supply.

Proper Cellar Storage for a Winter Potato Supply

After curing, the ideal storage conditions change. Your goal now is to keep the potatoes dormant. Move them to a location that is dark, cool, and maintains some humidity. The perfect temperature range is between 38-45°F (3-7°C).

A root cellar is the classic solution, but an unheated basement corner, an insulated garage, or a bulkhead can serve the same purpose. Store them in wooden crates, burlap sacks, or even cardboard boxes with holes for ventilation. The key is air circulation and darkness. Check your supply periodically and remove any potatoes that show signs of sprouting or softening to prevent them from affecting the others. Also, never store potatoes near apples, as the ethylene gas released by apples will cause your potatoes to sprout prematurely.

Why a Broadfork Minimizes Tuber Damage

The fundamental difference between a broadfork and other digging tools is how it interacts with the soil. A spading fork or shovel is designed to pierce and slice. When you miss your mark, you inevitably spear or chop a potato, creating a wound that invites rot and renders that tuber useless for long-term storage.

A broadfork, by contrast, is a tool of leverage. Its multiple long tines distribute pressure across a wide area, lifting an entire section of soil at once. Instead of attacking the ground, you are prying it open. This action gently loosens the earth around the potatoes, freeing them with minimal direct contact and a drastically lower chance of impact damage. You are harvesting the soil block, and the potatoes just come along for the ride.

This gentle approach not only protects the current harvest but also benefits your soil structure. It avoids the aggressive turning and mixing that can destroy soil aggregates and harm microbial life. By lifting instead of inverting, you preserve the soil’s natural layers, making it a better tool for the long-term health of your garden.

Choosing a Broadfork: Tine Length and Material

Not all broadforks are created equal. The two most important factors to consider are tine length and the materials used in construction. Your choice should be guided by your soil type and your physical strength.

Tine length determines how deep you can work.

• 10-12 inch tines: Excellent for established beds with already loose or loamy soil. They are lighter and easier to handle.
• 14-16 inch tines: Better for breaking new ground or working in compacted, clay-heavy soils. The extra length provides more leverage to fracture dense earth.

The construction material affects both durability and user comfort. All-steel broadforks are incredibly strong and are the best choice for rocky or tough soil conditions. Models with wooden handles, often ash, provide natural shock absorption, which can reduce fatigue on your hands and shoulders during a long day of work. While a good broadfork is an investment, it’s a lifetime tool that makes a physically demanding job significantly more efficient and enjoyable.

Using a broadfork for the potato harvest is more than just a technique; it’s a philosophy of working with the soil, not against it. It yields a cleaner, less damaged crop ready for a long winter in the cellar. This is the kind of practical wisdom that ensures the work you put in all season pays off at the table.