6 Best Horse Treats For Training Young Horses That Trainers Trust

Training a young horse is a conversation, and a well-chosen treat can be a powerful way to say "yes, that’s exactly what I wanted." But not all treats are created equal, especially when you’re trying to build focus and good manners. The right treat reinforces a lesson without creating a pushy, sugar-crazed partner.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

What to Look for in a Young Horse Training Treat

The first thing to consider is size and texture. For repetitive training, you need something small and easy to chew. A big, sticky treat that takes a full minute to eat will completely derail the flow of your session.

Look for a treat you can deliver quickly so the horse immediately connects the reward with the action. It should be small enough to fit a good number in your pocket or treat pouch without turning into a crumbly mess. This is about efficiency; the reward should punctuate the moment, not become the entire event.

Ingredient quality is also crucial. Young horses don’t need a lot of extra sugar, which can lead to energy spikes and a loss of focus. Low-sugar, forage-based treats are often a better choice for foundational work. Palatability is the final piece—if the horse won’t work for it, it’s not a reward.

Manna Pro Nuggets: Ideal Size for Repetition

When you’re working on basics like leading, yielding to pressure, or standing tied, you’ll be giving a lot of small rewards. Manna Pro Nuggets are the workhorse for this kind of training. They are small, uniform, and hold their shape well in a pocket.

Their main advantage is speed. You can deliver the reward, the horse can eat it in a second, and you can immediately ask for the next repetition. This creates a smooth, efficient learning cycle. There’s no fumbling with a large, crumbly biscuit or waiting for a long chew to finish.

These apple-flavored nuggets are highly palatable for most horses but aren’t so high-value that they cause frantic, pushy behavior. They strike a great balance for everyday schooling, keeping the horse engaged and motivated without getting them overly excited.

Standlee Alfalfa Cubes: A High-Fiber Option

Sometimes the simplest solution is the best one. Breaking up Standlee Alfalfa Cubes into small, thumbnail-sized pieces creates a healthy, high-fiber reward. This is a fantastic option for owners who want to avoid processed treats and added sugars entirely.

This approach requires a little prep work. You’ll need to break the cubes apart before your session, but the payoff is a cost-effective and gut-friendly treat. It’s essentially just a compressed bite of hay, which is ideal for horses with metabolic sensitivities or those on a strict diet.

Using a forage-based reward also helps reinforce a calm mindset. You’re rewarding the horse with a version of its normal food, which can prevent the development of a "treat monster." It’s a practical, no-frills option that puts the horse’s health first.

Purina Nicker Makers: Highly Palatable Crunch

Nicker Makers have a distinct crunch and aroma that horses find hard to resist. This makes them a great mid-level reward when you need to keep a young horse’s attention on a new or slightly challenging task. The audible "crunch" provides an extra layer of sensory feedback that seems to help mark the behavior.

Because they are more enticing than a simple forage pellet, they work well for stretching a horse’s comfort zone. Think of using them when you’re introducing a scary object or asking for more effort. Their high palatability helps create a positive association with something new.

They do contain molasses, so they fall into the "use strategically" category. They aren’t the best choice for a horse with sugar sensitivities or for endless repetitions. But as a step-up reward to capture focus, they are a trusted tool in many trainers’ pockets.

Buckeye No-Sugar Treats for Sensitive Horses

Training a horse with metabolic issues like Equine Metabolic Syndrome (EMS) or Polysaccharide Storage Myopathy (PSSM) requires careful management of sugar intake. Buckeye’s line of no-sugar-added treats is specifically designed for this purpose. They allow you to reward your horse without risking their health.

These treats are formulated with alternative flavors that horses enjoy, proving that a reward doesn’t have to be sweet to be effective. They provide peace of mind, ensuring your training program doesn’t conflict with your horse’s dietary needs.

Even for horses without a specific diagnosis, a low-sugar diet is a smart practice. It promotes stable energy levels and focus, preventing the sugar-induced highs and lows that can make a young horse difficult to train. Keeping a horse’s mind calm and level is half the battle.

Stud Muffins: A High-Value, Molasses-Based Reward

Every trainer needs a "jackpot" reward in their arsenal. Stud Muffins are exactly that. They are dense, chewy, and packed with molasses and other tasty ingredients that make them exceptionally high-value for most horses.

These are not your everyday training treats. You save them for major breakthroughs—the first time loading onto a trailer, crossing a scary water obstacle, or a perfect execution of a difficult maneuver. Using such a high-value reward for a significant achievement makes the lesson stick.

Due to their size and chewy texture, they take longer to eat. This can be a useful way to give the horse a "breather" to process a big win. Always break them into smaller, safer pieces to prevent choking and make the reward last longer.

German Horse Muffins: Soft and Easily Breakable

German Horse Muffins offer a unique soft, moist texture that sets them apart from dry cookies. This makes them incredibly easy to break into whatever size you need, from a tiny morsel for a quick "yes" to a larger piece for a bigger effort.

Their soft consistency is perfect for young horses just learning to accept treats gently, as well as for older horses who might have dental issues. There’s no sharp crunch, just a satisfying chew. They feel like a more substantial, special reward.

These muffins are a great mid-to-high-value option. They’re more exciting than a standard pellet but not as intense as a pure molasses treat. This makes them versatile for rewarding sustained focus or celebrating a try, even if it wasn’t perfect.

Using Treats Effectively in Your Training Sessions

A treat is a tool for communication, not a bribe. The key to effective treat training is timing. The reward must be delivered within a second or two of the desired behavior for the horse to make the connection. A late reward just teaches the horse that you randomly hand out food.

Keep treats hidden in a pouch or pocket until the moment you deliver them. A horse that sees or smells the food will focus on getting the treat, not on the lesson. This leads to mugging, nipping, and other bad habits. The treat should be a surprise that follows the correct action, not an enticement that precedes it.

Finally, remember that treats are just one type of reward. A wither scratch, a moment of rest, or a kind word can be just as, if not more, powerful. Over-reliance on food rewards can create a horse that is only willing to work when food is present. A truly well-trained horse works for the partnership, with treats serving as an occasional and well-earned bonus.

Ultimately, the best treat is the one that motivates your individual horse while supporting your training goals. By having a few different options on hand, from low-value basics to high-value jackpots, you can tailor the reward to the task. This thoughtful approach will help you build a responsive, well-mannered, and willing young partner.