6 Best Hay Spears For Round Bales Old Farmers Swear By

There’s nothing more frustrating than trying to move a 1,200-pound round bale with a front-end loader bucket and a prayer. The bale rolls, the twine snaps, and you spend the next hour cleaning up a mess. A good hay spear turns a difficult chore into a simple, one-person job, saving you time, hay, and a whole lot of aggravation.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Choosing the Right Hay Spear for Your Tractor

The most important rule of hay spears is this: the attachment must match the machine. A heavy-duty spear on a sub-compact tractor is not only useless, it’s dangerous. You’ll lift the front wheels off the ground before you lift the bale, losing steering and control. Your tractor’s lift capacity is the absolute limit.

Most spears for hobby farms mount in one of two ways: on the 3-point hitch at the rear or on the front-end loader. A 3-point spear is fantastic for smaller tractors because it puts the bale’s weight on the strong rear axle and acts as a counterweight. A front-end loader spear, usually with a universal skid steer quick attach (SSQA) plate, is better for stacking bales in a barn or feeding into a ring, but it requires a tractor with sufficient front-axle strength and hydraulic power.

Don’t just look at the sticker price; look at the specs on your tractor. Know your 3-point lift capacity and, more importantly, your loader’s lift capacity at the pivot pin. A 1,000-pound bale plus a 200-pound spear attachment can easily max out a smaller compact tractor. Safety and stability should always be your first consideration.

Titan 49" Conus 2 Spear: The Heavy-Duty Choice

When you just need a tough, no-frills spear that can handle big bales day in and day out, the Titan 49" spear is a common sight on many farms. It’s built around the "Conus 2" taper, a standardized size for the spear itself, which means it’s thick, strong, and can be replaced easily if you ever manage to break one. This is a tool designed for work, not for show.

This spear is best suited for tractors in the 40-75 horsepower range with a solid front-end loader. The 49-inch length is ideal for penetrating to the core of a 5-foot round bale, giving you a secure, balanced lift. The frame is typically heavy steel, which adds to the stability but also adds to the total weight your loader has to lift.

The tradeoff for its brute strength is its weight. On a smaller compact tractor, the weight of the spear itself can eat up a significant chunk of your usable lift capacity. But if your machine can handle it, the Titan offers an incredible amount of strength for the price. It’s a simple, effective tool that doesn’t pretend to be anything else.

Worksaver SS-248 Spear for Skid Steer Loaders

Worksaver has a reputation for building equipment that lasts, and their single bale spear is no exception. The SS-248 is designed specifically for the universal skid steer quick attach mount, making it a perfect fit for modern compact and utility tractors. The hookup is fast, secure, and keeps the work directly in your line of sight.

This isn’t the cheapest spear on the market, but the quality of the welds and the strength of the steel backplate justify the cost. It’s a prime example of getting what you pay for. A well-designed backplate prevents the bale from rolling back onto your loader arms, which is a critical safety feature often overlooked on cheaper models.

The single-spear design is simple and effective, allowing you to easily stab into the center of a dense bale. It’s an ideal choice for the farmer who values efficiency and wants a reliable tool that connects in seconds. If your tractor has the SSQA system, this is a clean, purpose-built solution for moving and stacking hay.

CountyLine 3-Point Spear for Compact Tractors

For many folks with smaller tractors, a 3-point hitch spear is the smartest and safest way to move round bales. The CountyLine spear, often found at local farm supply stores, is an accessible and affordable entry into this category. It’s designed to do one job: lift a bale from the rear and transport it.

The genius of the 3-point spear is how it uses the bale’s weight. Instead of putting a heavy load on your front axle and loader, it places it on the powerful rear axle, effectively turning the bale into ballast. This dramatically improves traction and stability, especially on hills or soft ground. For tractors under 40 horsepower, this is often the only safe way to handle a full-size round bale.

The downside is purely operational. You have to back up to the bale to lift it, and you can’t stack bales high in a barn. It’s a tool for transport, not for high-density storage. But for moving bales from the field to a feeder, it’s an incredibly stable and safe system that works with the tractor’s design, not against it.

SpeeCo S16113800 Tapered Forged Steel Spear

Sometimes the best tool isn’t a complete unit, but the critical component to build or repair your own. The SpeeCo forged spear is just that—the tine itself. Many old-timers and resourceful farmers prefer to weld their own frame, customizing it perfectly for their tractor and needs.

This isn’t just any piece of steel. A proper hay spear is forged and heat-treated. This process aligns the grain structure of the steel, making it incredibly strong and resistant to bending. Trying to use a simple steel rod is a recipe for a bent, useless tool. Buying a quality replacement tine like a SpeeCo ensures you have the strength where it matters most.

This is the ultimate practical choice. If you find a solid, used bale spear frame with a bent tine, you can replace it for a fraction of the cost of a new unit. Or, if you have some steel and a welder, you can build a heavy-duty spear for less than half the price of a store-bought one. It’s about knowing where to spend your money—and the forged tine is the heart of the whole implement.

Everything Attachments Single Bale Spear V2.0

Everything Attachments has built a strong following by making high-quality, well-engineered attachments specifically for the compact tractor market. Their single bale spear is a perfect example of this philosophy. It’s designed to be strong without being excessively heavy, preserving your tractor’s precious lift capacity.

This spear often features smart design choices, like a high-visibility backplate and heavy gusseting at stress points. The SSQA mounting plate is usually cut from thick steel and fits perfectly, eliminating the slop you might find in some budget brands. The "V2.0" in the name suggests they listen to customer feedback and continuously improve their products, which is a good sign.

This is the spear for the hobby farmer who wants to buy a tool once and be done with it. It’s not the cheapest option, but it’s engineered to perform well and last for decades. It represents a balanced approach, providing professional-grade quality in a package that’s perfectly sized for the capabilities of a modern compact tractor.

Horst BMG Double Tine Spear for Stability

While a single spear is the standard, a double tine spear offers one major advantage: stability. The Horst BMG Double Tine Spear, or similar designs, uses two smaller tines mounted below the main spear. This setup is all about preventing the bale from spinning while you’re driving.

Anyone who has carried a round bale across a bumpy pasture knows the feeling of a bale slowly rotating on the spear. It can throw off your balance and, in a worst-case scenario, cause the bale to fall off. The two lower tines lock the bale in place, keeping it secure even on uneven terrain. This is a significant safety and convenience feature.

The tradeoff is that it can be slightly more difficult to stab into a very tight, net-wrapped bale, as you have to align three points instead of one. The frame is also heavier and more complex, which means it costs more. However, for those moving bales long distances or who simply want the most secure lift possible, the stability offered by a double tine system is well worth the investment.

What to Look For: Taper, Length, and Mount

When you strip it all down, three things matter most: the taper of the spear, its length, and how it mounts to your tractor. Getting these three things right for your specific situation is the key to a useful and safe tool.

First, look at the taper. Most quality spears use a "Conus" taper, which is a standardized cone shape that fits into a welded sleeve on the frame. This allows the spear to self-tighten under load but also makes it easy to replace. A "Conus 2" is a common, heavy-duty size you’ll see on spears rated for 3,000 lbs or more. This design provides immense strength at the base where the stress is highest.

Next is length. For standard 4-foot or 5-foot diameter round bales, a spear between 43 and 49 inches is ideal. This length allows you to pierce the bale to its center of gravity, providing a balanced and secure lift. Using a spear that’s too short is dangerous, as it can allow the bale to tear off and fall.

Finally, the mount is non-negotiable. It must match your tractor.

• 3-Point Hitch: Best for smaller tractors or those without a front-end loader. It’s stable and uses the tractor’s inherent strength.
• Front-End Loader (SSQA or Pin-On): Best for stacking and feeding. It requires a tractor with enough lift capacity and front-axle strength to handle the load safely.

Ultimately, the best hay spear isn’t the heaviest or the most expensive. It’s the one that safely matches your tractor’s capabilities and makes your specific chores easier. Match the spear to the tractor and the bale, and you’ll have a tool that will serve you well for years to come.