6 Wood Post And Rail Fencing For Horses That Old Farmers Swear By

You can tell a lot about a farm by its fence lines. A sagging, patched-up fence tells a story of quick fixes and constant problems. A straight, sturdy fence, on the other hand, speaks to foresight and a job done right the first time. When it comes to keeping horses safe, that fence line is your most important insurance policy, and choosing the right wood is the foundation of it all.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Pressure-Treated Pine: The Affordable Standard

Pressure-treated (PT) pine is the workhorse of modern farm fencing for a reason: it’s affordable and available everywhere. The chemical treatment forces preservatives deep into the wood, protecting it from the rot and insects that would otherwise make short work of it. This makes it a practical choice for long stretches of pasture where cost is a major factor.

The biggest tradeoff is that horses, especially bored ones, love to chew on it. That soft pine is like candy to them. You’ll need to stay vigilant about cribbing and consider adding a hot wire or using anti-chew sprays to protect your investment.

Also, be aware of the chemicals used in the treatment. Modern treatments are safer than the old arsenic-based ones, but it’s still something to consider. For posts, always choose wood rated for ground contact; it has a higher concentration of preservatives precisely where you need it most—at the soil line where rot begins.

Split Rail Cedar for Natural Rot Resistance

There’s a reason you see old cedar split rail fences still standing after decades of neglect. Cedar contains natural oils that make it inherently resistant to rot and insects. This means you get longevity without the chemical treatments of PT pine.

The rustic, uneven look of split rail is beautiful, but it’s not the strongest fence. The rails are designed to sit in the post notches, not be nailed down tight. This makes it a poor choice for a small paddock with a pushy herd or along a busy road.

Think of cedar split rail as a great perimeter or cross-fencing option for calm, respectful horses. It defines a boundary beautifully without creating a harsh visual barrier. It’s a statement of trust in your animals as much as it is a physical barrier.

Classic Oak Board Fencing for Maximum Strength

When you need a fence that says "do not cross," you build it out of oak. Oak is dense, heavy, and incredibly strong. A horse leaning or kicking on an oak board will think twice before trying it again. This is why it’s the classic choice for stallion paddocks, riding arenas, and high-traffic areas.

The strength of oak comes with a higher price tag and more demanding installation. Oak boards are heavy and can warp or twist if not properly cured and installed. You need to use high-quality, galvanized fasteners to prevent black streaks from tannins reacting with the metal.

But when done right, a four-board oak fence is both beautiful and formidable. It provides excellent visibility, which helps prevent a spooked horse from running into it blindly. It’s an investment in safety and peace of mind, especially if you have young or spirited horses.

Black Locust Posts: The Gold Standard for Longevity

If you ask an old-timer what the best fence post is, they’ll likely say black locust without a moment’s hesitation. This wood is legendary for its ability to resist rot. A properly set black locust post can easily outlast the person who installed it, often lasting 50 years or more in the ground without any chemical treatment.

The wood is incredibly dense and hard, which also makes it difficult to work with. It eats up drill bits and saw blades, and driving staples into it is a real chore. It’s also not always easy to find, and when you do, it commands a premium price.

Think of black locust as a lifetime investment for your corner posts and gate posts—the critical anchor points of your entire fence system. Using it for every post might be overkill for your budget, but using it strategically ensures the backbone of your fence will never fail you. It’s the definition of "buy once, cry once."

Lodgepole Pine Round Rail for a Traditional Look

Lodgepole pine fencing gives a property that classic, rustic ranch look. The uniform round posts and rails are visually appealing and create a very sturdy structure. Because the rails are round, they are less appealing for horses to chew on compared to the sharp edge of a pine board.

Like other pines, lodgepole needs to be treated to last. The treatment process is key, and you want to ensure you’re getting posts and rails that have been properly preserved for ground contact and outdoor exposure. It’s a great choice for round pens and arenas where a horse might come into contact with the fence regularly.

The main drawback can be the cost and the installation, which requires precise drilling of the posts to fit the rails. It’s not as simple as nailing a board to a post. But for a high-visibility area where aesthetics matter as much as function, it’s a fantastic and durable option that stands out.

Creosote-Treated Posts: An Old-School Solution

You’ll still find old railroad ties and telephone poles used as fence posts on farms that have been around for a century. These were often treated with creosote, a tar-like substance that makes wood practically impervious to rot and insects. The stuff works, and those old posts are a testament to its effectiveness.

However, we now know that creosote is a hazardous material. It’s messy, smells strong, and can cause skin irritation. There are also environmental concerns about it leaching into the soil and water. For these reasons, its use is heavily restricted, and it’s no longer a recommended material for new farm fencing, especially for animals that might chew on it.

While you might be tempted to use reclaimed creosote posts you find for cheap, it’s best to avoid them. They represent an old way of thinking that prioritized longevity above all else. Modern, safer alternatives like PT pine or naturally rot-resistant woods like black locust are the responsible choice today.

Setting Posts Deep for a Fence That Lasts Decades

The best wood in the world won’t matter if the posts are set poorly. A post hole should be three times the width of the post and one-third the length of the post deep. In cold climates, that means getting below the frost line to prevent heaving in the winter.

For corner posts, gate posts, and any post under tension, use concrete. For line posts, tamping gravel in around the post is often better. Gravel allows water to drain away from the base of the post, which is the number one defense against rot, even for treated wood.

Don’t rush this step. A fence with shallow, wobbly posts will start to lean in a few years, putting stress on your boards and creating a safety hazard. Taking the time to set every post deep, straight, and solid is the most important work you’ll do. It’s the difference between a 5-year fence and a 30-year fence.

Wood Fence Maintenance Tips for Horse Safety

A wood fence is not a "set it and forget it" project. It requires regular inspection to keep your horses safe and protect your investment. Walk your fence lines at least once a season, specifically looking for potential problems.

A little preventative maintenance goes a long way. Your regular checklist should include:

• Checking for loose or broken boards. Replace them immediately. A single broken board can be an invitation for a horse to test the rest of the fence or get a leg caught.
• Looking for protruding nails or screws. As wood weathers, fasteners can work their way out. Pound them back in or replace them to prevent nasty cuts.
• Addressing chewing and cribbing spots. You can cover problem areas with metal flashing or use a safe, non-toxic anti-chew product. Adding a single strand of electric wire along the top is often the most effective deterrent.
• Managing vegetation. Don’t let weeds and vines grow up along your fence line. They trap moisture against the wood, accelerating rot and hiding problems from view.

Treating your fence with a horse-safe stain or paint every few years can dramatically extend its life. It seals the wood from moisture and UV damage. It’s a big job, but it’s far cheaper than replacing the entire fence a decade sooner than you should have to.

In the end, the right fence is the one that fits your land, your budget, and your horses. There’s no single perfect answer, only a series of smart tradeoffs. By choosing the right materials and committing to proper installation and maintenance, you’re not just building a fence—you’re building a safe, secure environment that will serve you and your animals for years to come.