5 Soap Making Oils That Prevent Common Soap Making Issues

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Choosing Oils to Avoid Common Soap Problems

The oils and fats you use are the foundation of your soap. They determine everything from the bar’s hardness and lather to how it feels on your skin. Getting the oil blend right is the single most important step to avoiding disappointment.

Common problems like a soft, mushy bar, a disappointing lather, or a soap that cracks as it cures are all symptoms of an unbalanced recipe. One oil might create fantastic bubbles but be terribly drying, while another creates a gentle, conditioning bar that takes forever to harden. The goal is not to find one perfect oil, but to create a team of oils that work together.

Each oil has a unique fatty acid profile, which dictates its properties in soap. Some contribute long-lasting hardness, others create big, fluffy bubbles, and some add moisturizing qualities. Understanding the role of a few key staples is far more valuable than chasing after dozens of exotic, expensive oils.

Olive Oil: The Key to a Gentle, Moisturizing Bar

Olive oil is the classic, foundational soap making oil for a reason. It produces an incredibly gentle, mild, and moisturizing bar that’s kind to even sensitive skin. A soap made with 100% olive oil is called Castile soap, famous for its mildness.

The main tradeoff with olive oil is time. A high-olive oil soap needs a long cure—we’re talking six months to a year for the best results. A young bar will be soft and can even feel a bit slimy in the shower. But with patience, it hardens into a beautiful, long-lasting bar with a low, creamy, lotion-like lather.

If your goal is to create a soap that cleans without stripping moisture, olive oil is your non-negotiable starting point. It’s the primary contributor to a soap’s conditioning value. Use it as the largest percentage of your recipe for a bar that prioritizes gentleness above all else.

Coconut Oil for a Hard Bar and Abundant Lather

If you want big, bubbly, cleansing lather, coconut oil is your workhorse. It adds fantastic hardness to the final bar and creates those satisfying, sudsy bubbles that most people expect from soap. A little bit goes a long way in transforming the feel of your lather.

However, coconut oil‘s cleansing power is a double-edged sword. Used in high amounts (typically over 30% of your recipe), it can be stripping and leave skin feeling dry. It’s so effective at grabbing oil—including the natural oils on your skin—that it can be irritating.

The key is balance. Keep coconut oil between 15% and 30% of your total oils. This gives you the benefits of a hard bar and a great bubbly lather without the harsh, drying downside. It’s the perfect counterpart to the gentle conditioning of olive oil.

Palm Oil for Hardness and a Stable, Creamy Lather

Palm oil is the great stabilizer in a soap recipe. It contributes to a very hard, durable bar that lasts a long time in the shower. While coconut oil gives you big, flashy bubbles, palm oil helps create a thick, stable, and creamy lather that persists.

It’s impossible to talk about palm oil without addressing the environmental concerns. When you buy it, it’s crucial to source from suppliers who provide sustainably produced, RSPO-certified palm oil. This ensures it’s grown and harvested responsibly. If you’re not comfortable using it, lard or tallow are excellent animal-fat alternatives that provide similar properties.

Think of palm oil as the bridge between olive and coconut. It provides the hardness that olive oil lacks and the creamy, stable lather that coconut’s big bubbles need. A recipe containing these three oils is a classic for a reason: it’s balanced, reliable, and produces a fantastic bar of soap.

Castor Oil: Your Secret to a Rich, Bubbly Lather

Castor oil is not a primary oil, but a secret weapon used in small amounts. Its magic lies in its ability to supercharge your lather. It acts as a humectant, drawing moisture to itself, which results in a uniquely rich, dense, and bubbly lather that feels wonderfully luxurious.

If you’ve made a batch of soap and the lather feels a bit thin or disappears too quickly, adding a touch of castor oil to the next recipe is the fix. It boosts and stabilizes the bubbles created by other oils like coconut, making the lather feel more substantial and slippery.

You only need a little. A good rule of thumb is to use castor oil at 5-8% of your total oil weight. Using too much can make the final bar feel soft or sticky. It’s a supporting player that makes the star oils perform even better.

Shea Butter to Prevent Cracking and Boost Moisture

Shea butter is a luxury ingredient that adds incredible conditioning properties and a silky feel to your soap. It’s often used to increase the "superfat" of a recipe—the amount of free-floating oils left in the soap after saponification—which makes the bar extra moisturizing.

One of its most practical benefits is helping to prevent cracking. Soaps with high olive oil content, or those cured in very dry environments, can sometimes develop cracks on the surface. The high percentage of unsaponifiables in shea butter (components that don’t turn into soap) gives the bar more flexibility and helps it stay smooth.

Adding shea butter at 5-15% transforms a functional bar into a premium one. It doesn’t contribute much to lather, but it makes the bar feel creamier and more nourishing on the skin. It’s the perfect addition for a facial bar, a winter soap, or any recipe where moisture is the top priority.

Balancing Your Recipe with a Soap Calculator

You can’t just throw these oils together and hope for the best. Every oil requires a specific amount of lye (sodium hydroxide) to turn into soap, a property known as its saponification (SAP) value. Guessing is not just ineffective; it’s dangerous, as it can result in a lye-heavy, skin-burning bar.

A soap calculator is an essential and non-negotiable tool. You plug in the weight of each oil you plan to use, and it tells you the exact amount of lye and water needed to create a safe, balanced bar of soap. There are many free, reliable options online.

Beyond safety, a good soap calculator will also predict the qualities of your finished bar. It will give you estimated numbers for hardness, cleansing, conditioning, and lather type. This allows you to tweak your percentages on paper—adding a little more olive for conditioning or a bit of castor for bubbles—before you ever commit your precious ingredients.

Creating a Reliable Soap Recipe with These Staples

With these five ingredients, you can create an endless variety of fantastic soaps. A classic and reliable starting point for many soapers is a blend of olive oil, coconut oil, and palm oil (or lard). This trio provides a perfect balance of conditioning, cleansing, and hardness.

A typical recipe might look something like this:

• 40% Olive Oil (for gentleness)
• 30% Coconut Oil (for bubbles and hardness)
• 30% Palm Oil (for creamy lather and longevity)

From this solid base, you can begin to customize. Want more moisturizing properties for a winter bar? Swap out 10% of the palm oil for shea butter. Looking for a more luxurious, bubbly lather? Reduce the olive oil to 35% and add 5% castor oil.

Mastering how these core oils interact is the key to creative and reliable soap making. Once you understand this foundation, you can confidently predict how your soap will turn out. You’ll spend less time fixing problems and more time enjoying the craft.

Ultimately, crafting a great bar of soap isn’t about using the most exotic or expensive oils. It’s about intelligently blending a few reliable workhorses to create a bar that is perfectly balanced for your needs.