6 Sheep Barn Leak Repairs That Old Farmers Swear By

There’s no sound more frustrating than the steady drip… drip… drip onto a hay bale in the middle of a downpour. A leaky barn roof isn’t just an annoyance; it’s a threat to your flock’s health, promoting foot rot and respiratory issues in the damp. Keeping your sheep dry is non-negotiable, and thankfully, the old-timers figured out some rock-solid fixes that don’t require a team of contractors.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Pinpointing the Source: The First Crucial Step

You can’t fix a leak you can’t find. The tricky part is that where you see the drip inside is rarely right below the hole on the outside. Water can travel along rafters and roof decking for yards before it finally decides to fall.

The best way to hunt it down is with a partner during a steady rain. Have one person inside the barn with a powerful flashlight, looking for the telltale sheen of water tracking along the wood. The person outside can help narrow the search area, but be safe on a wet roof. If the sky is clear, a garden hose can do the job, but it takes more patience.

Once you spot the source from inside, mark it immediately. Push a piece of wire or a long nail straight up through the hole so it’s visible from the roof. Or, if it’s a wet spot on a rafter, have your partner on the roof measure from a landmark like a vent pipe or the roof peak. A clear mark saves you from searching all over again when you’re up there with tools and materials.

The Hot Tar Patch: A Time-Tested Roof Sealant

For cracks in rolled roofing or splits around flashing, nothing beats hot tar. This is a messy, old-school fix, but it creates a thick, waterproof seal that lasts for years. It’s not pretty, but a sheep barn is about function, not fashion.

The process is simple but requires care. First, you must clean the area around the leak until it’s free of all dirt, gravel, and loose material. Use a wire brush to get it really clean. Then, carefully heat the roofing tar in a metal bucket until it’s the consistency of thick pancake batter.

Using a disposable brush or a trowel, apply a heavy layer of the hot tar over the crack, spreading it at least a few inches beyond the damaged area on all sides. Work it into the crack to ensure a complete seal. This method is incredibly effective, but always be extremely cautious when working with hot tar.

Applying a Tin Patch with Sealant and Screws

When you’re dealing with a significant hole in a metal roof, a simple sealant won’t do. You need a mechanical patch. A piece of scrap tin or galvanized steel is the perfect solution for a permanent, structural repair.

Start by cutting a piece of metal that’s at least four inches larger than the hole on all sides. Clean the roof surface around the hole thoroughly. Apply a thick, continuous bead of high-quality roofing sealant around the perimeter of the hole itself.

Firmly press the metal patch into the sealant, creating a gasket. Then, use self-tapping roofing screws—the kind with the little rubber washers—to secure the patch to the roof. Drive screws every few inches around the patch’s edge. For a truly bulletproof fix, run another bead of sealant around the outside edge of the patch, covering the screw heads.

Sealing Nail Holes and Seams with Silicone Caulk

Sometimes a leak isn’t one big failure but a death by a thousand cuts. Over time, the rubber washers on roofing nails dry out, crack, and fail. Seams between metal panels can also work themselves slightly loose, creating a tiny gap for water to exploit.

This is a tedious job, but it’s often the solution to those mysterious, widespread damp spots. Get a few tubes of 100% silicone caulk or a dedicated roofing sealant designed for metal. The key is to clean every single nail head or seam you plan to seal. Any dirt or rust will prevent a good bond.

Apply a generous dab of sealant directly on top of each suspicious screw or nail head, making sure to completely cover the washer and the fastener. For seams, run a clean, steady bead along the entire length where the panels overlap. It’s slow work, but it’s far cheaper and easier than replacing an entire roof section.

The Cement and Fabric Method for Tougher Tears

For a nasty tear in asphalt or rolled roofing, you need more than just a liquid sealant. You need reinforcement. This method uses roofing cement and a strong fabric to create a patch that’s both waterproof and incredibly durable.

Think of it like putting a cast on a broken bone. First, clean the area around the tear with a stiff brush. Apply a thick layer of asphalt roofing cement, spreading it a good four to five inches around the entire tear.

While the cement is still wet, press a piece of fiberglass reinforcing fabric or even heavy-duty burlap into it. Use your trowel to embed the fabric completely. Finally, apply a second, generous layer of cement over the top of the fabric, feathering the edges. This creates a laminated patch that moves with the roof and resists future damage.

Replacing Damaged Shingles or Metal Panels

Sometimes, a patch is just a temporary fix for a bigger problem. If a shingle is completely curled, cracked in half, or missing, it needs to be replaced. The same goes for a metal panel that is badly dented, rusted through, or has been lifted by the wind.

For a single asphalt shingle, the job isn’t too hard. You’ll need a flat pry bar to gently pop the nails from the damaged shingle and the one directly above it. Slide the old one out, slip the new one in, and secure it with four roofing nails. Place the nails so they will be covered by the overlapping shingle above, and add a dab of sealant on the nail heads for good measure.

Replacing a full metal panel is more involved but follows the same logic. You must remove all the screws holding the damaged panel, lift it carefully out from under the overlapping ridge cap or adjacent panel, and set the new one in place. Always use new screws with fresh washers; re-using old ones is asking for another leak down the road.

Clearing Gutters to Stop Damaging Water Backup

Your leak might not be on the roof at all. A clogged gutter is one of the most common causes of water getting into a barn. When leaves and debris create a dam, rainwater has nowhere to go but up and over, seeping behind the fascia and under the edge of your roof.

Before you spend a day on the roof hunting for a phantom hole, check your gutters. If they are full of muck, that’s almost certainly your problem. Water that backs up can rot the roof decking and rafter ends, creating a much bigger job than the one you started with.

Make it a habit to clean your barn gutters twice a year, especially after the leaves fall. It’s a ten-minute job that can prevent thousands of dollars in water damage. A clean gutter directs water where it’s supposed to go: away from your foundation and out of your barn.

Regular Inspection: Your Best Leak Prevention

The most effective repair is the one you make before the water ever gets in. Small issues—a lifted shingle, a cracked bead of caulk, a nail backing out—are easy to fix. It’s when they’re ignored for a season or two that they turn into major structural problems.

At least twice a year, in the spring and fall, do a full walk-around and get on a ladder for a closer look.

• Check for any popped or missing fasteners.
• Look for cracks in any existing sealant or tar patches.
• Scan for shingles that are curling, cracked, or have lost their granules.
• Inspect flashing around chimneys, vents, and roof valleys, as these are common failure points.

A quick look after a major wind or hail storm is also a smart move. Catching a small piece of lifted metal or a cracked shingle right after it happens means you can fix it on a sunny afternoon. Waiting until the next rainstorm means you’ll be trying to fix it in the middle of a downpour.

A dry barn is a healthy barn, and you don’t need fancy tools or expensive materials to keep it that way. These tried-and-true repairs rely on common sense and a bit of effort. Stay vigilant, fix small problems before they become big ones, and your flock will thank you for it.