6 Starting Onion Seed Saving From Heirlooms That Preserve Traditions

You pull a perfect, firm ‘Red Wethersfield’ onion from storage in late winter, its skin like paper and its flavor sharp and sweet. Instead of just slicing it for dinner, you see it as the parent of next year’s crop, a living link to a gardening tradition stretching back centuries. Saving heirloom onion seed is more than just a frugal practice; it’s an act of preserving history and building resilience right in your own backyard.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Selecting Ideal Heirloom Bulbs for Seed Stock

The entire seed-saving process hinges on this first step. You are not just picking onions; you are selecting the genetic traits you want to see in future generations. A beautiful, large onion that rotted by December is a poor candidate, while its smaller, firmer neighbor that stored perfectly is a genetic treasure.

Look for bulbs that best represent the variety’s ideal characteristics. This includes proper size, classic shape, and excellent skin quality. Most importantly, select for superior storage ability. Any bulb that shows early sprouting, soft spots, or signs of disease should be destined for the kitchen, not the seed patch. You are actively curating your future crop’s health and reliability with every choice you make.

Avoid the temptation to save bulbs from plants that bolted (sent up a flower stalk) in their first year. This tendency to bolt prematurely is a heritable trait you don’t want to encourage. Your goal is to select bulbs that followed the proper biennial lifecycle, focusing their first year’s energy entirely on producing a high-quality bulb for storage.

Overwintering Onion Bulbs for Second-Year Growth

Onions are biennials, a fact that’s easy to forget when we harvest them as annuals. To produce seed, they must complete their two-year life cycle. This requires a period of cold dormancy to trigger the hormonal shift that initiates flowering.

The most reliable method for a hobby farmer is to harvest all your chosen bulbs in the fall and cure them as you would for eating. Store them in a cool, dark, and dry location like a root cellar, unheated garage, or basement. The ideal temperature is just above freezing, typically between 34-40°F (1-4°C), which provides the necessary chill without risking damage.

In milder climates (Zone 7 and warmer), you can sometimes leave the bulbs in the ground over winter. This is less work but comes with significant tradeoffs. You lose the ability to inspect the bulbs for rot, and they are more vulnerable to soil-borne pests and disease. Pulling, curing, and storing your seed stock gives you far more control over the outcome.

Spacing and Planting for Optimal Seed Harvest

When you replant your selected bulbs in the spring, forget everything you know about spacing for bulb production. These plants will become massive, top-heavy giants. They need space—a lot more than you think.

Give each onion bulb at least 18 to 24 inches of space in every direction. This seems excessive at first, but it’s crucial for two reasons. First, the plant will produce a large, bushy foliage base and a flower stalk reaching three to five feet tall. Second, wide spacing ensures excellent air circulation, which is your best defense against the fungal diseases that can plague the dense flower heads in humid weather.

Plant the overwintered bulb so that its top is just level with or slightly below the soil surface. Don’t bury it deep. This shallow planting provides a solid, stable anchor for the tall, heavy flower scape that will soon emerge.

Staking the Flower Scapes to Prevent Breakage

An onion flower stalk, or scape, is hollow and surprisingly brittle. The developing seed head, called an umbel, becomes incredibly heavy with moisture and developing seeds. A single strong thunderstorm or gust of wind can easily snap the scape, instantly ending your seed-saving effort for that plant.

Staking is not optional; it’s essential insurance. The simplest method is to drive a sturdy stake, like a bamboo pole or a wooden lath, into the ground a few inches from the bulb shortly after planting. As the scape grows, loosely tie it to the stake in two or three places using soft garden twine or strips of cloth.

Stake your plants before they need it. Don’t wait for the scape to start leaning. By the time the flower head is fully formed and blooming, the plant is already at risk. Proactive staking prevents the heartbreak of finding your most promising seed heads snapped and lying on the ground.

Ensuring True-to-Type Seeds via Isolation

Onions are insect-pollinated and will readily cross with any other onion variety (Allium cepa) that is flowering at the same time. This includes other heirloom onions, bunching onions, or shallots that might be flowering in your or your neighbor’s garden. Without proper isolation, you won’t be saving pure ‘Stuttgarter Riesen’ seed; you’ll be creating an unknown hybrid.

For absolute purity, different varieties need to be isolated by a significant distance—often a quarter-mile or more, which is impractical for most small homesteads. This leaves the hobby farmer with a few realistic options:

• Grow only one variety for seed per year. This is the simplest method of temporal isolation.
• Coordinate with neighbors. If you’re on good terms, you can agree on who grows which variety for seed each year.
• Use physical isolation. You can build a cage of fine insect netting around a small group of plants. You’ll then need to either hand-pollinate the tiny florets with a small paintbrush or introduce pollinators like houseflies or mason bees inside the cage.

It’s also important to acknowledge the alternative. If you can’t guarantee isolation, you can embrace the cross-pollination. Over several generations of saving seed from the best resulting plants, you will develop your own unique "landrace" variety perfectly adapted to your specific climate and soil. Just be honest with yourself and others about what you are saving.

Harvesting Umbels When Seeds Begin to Show

Harvesting onion seed is all about timing. The umbel is a sphere composed of hundreds of tiny individual flowers. These flowers don’t all mature at once, so you have to watch the head carefully for the right moment.

The primary signal for harvest is when the small, dried flower capsules begin to split open, revealing the tiny, hard, black seeds inside. You don’t want to wait until all the seeds are shattering, but you need to see that a good portion of them are mature and visible. The umbel itself will feel dry and papery to the touch.

To harvest, use sharp snips or shears to cut the scape about 6-12 inches below the seed head. Gently place the head directly into a paper bag, bucket, or deep tray. Handle them with care, as ripe seeds can dislodge easily. Cutting a long stem allows you to hang them for curing and makes handling easier.

Curing and Threshing to Separate Onion Seeds

After harvest, the seed heads need to cure completely to ensure the seeds are fully mature and dry. Hang the bags containing the umbels, or the stems themselves, in a dry, well-ventilated location out of direct sunlight for at least two to three weeks. A garage, barn, or covered porch is perfect.

Once the heads are bone-dry and brittle, it’s time to thresh. This is the process of separating the seeds from the chaff (the dried flower parts). For a small batch, you can simply crush the umbels between your hands inside the paper bag or over a clean bucket. The small, heavy seeds will fall away from the lighter plant material.

To clean the seeds further, a process called winnowing works wonders. On a calm day or in front of a fan on its lowest setting, slowly pour the seed-and-chaff mixture from one bucket to another. The heavy seeds will fall straight down into the lower bucket, while the lightweight chaff will be carried away by the breeze. Repeat a few times until you have mostly clean seed.

Long-Term Seed Storage for Maximum Viability

Your hard work culminates in this final step. Onion seeds are not long-lived compared to other vegetables; their viability drops significantly after just one or two years if not stored properly. Your goal is to protect them from their enemies: heat, light, and moisture.

The rule for seed storage is cool, dark, and dry. A small, airtight glass jar with a good lid is the ideal container. To combat moisture, toss in a silica desiccant packet (you can reuse the ones that come in vitamin bottles or shoe boxes). This will absorb any lingering humidity and keep the seeds perfectly dry.

Label the jar immediately and thoroughly. Include the variety name, the year of harvest, and any relevant notes, such as whether it was from an isolated or open-pollinated crop. Store the jar in the most stable, cool, and dark place you have. A refrigerator provides excellent conditions, but a cool corner of a basement or a root cellar also works well. Proper storage ensures that the genetic legacy you’ve carefully preserved will be ready to plant for years to come.

Saving your own heirloom onion seed closes a loop, transforming you from a simple consumer of seeds into a steward of genetic history. It’s a deliberate, rewarding process that deepens your connection to your food and anchors your garden in the traditions of the past. The jar of tiny black seeds you hold at the end is not just potential food; it’s a promise of self-sufficiency and a story waiting to be retold next season.