6 Sheep Milk Cheese Making Basics Grandparents Used to Know

Before cheese came in plastic wrap, it came from a cool cellar, the result of daily chores and patient waiting. Our grandparents didn’t see cheesemaking as a gourmet hobby; it was a practical way to preserve the rich milk from their flock. Reclaiming this skill connects us to a more resilient way of living, turning a perishable resource into something timeless and nourishing.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Reclaiming the Art of Farmstead Cheesemaking

Making cheese on a small farmstead used to be as common as baking bread. It wasn’t a science experiment conducted in a sterile lab but a kitchen craft, passed down through observation and practice. The goal was simple: transform an abundance of summer milk into a food that would last through the winter.

This tradition is worth reviving, not just for nostalgia, but for its practical benefits. When you make your own cheese, you control every ingredient, from the milk your animals produce to the salt that preserves it. It’s a powerful act of self-sufficiency that deepens your connection to your farm’s output.

Forget the images of stainless-steel dairies. The essence of farmstead cheesemaking is about process, not pristine equipment. Cleanliness is non-negotiable, but "sterile" is unrealistic and unnecessary. A well-scrubbed kitchen, dedicated pots and utensils, and a respect for the basic principles of food safety are all you truly need to begin.

Sourcing Fresh, High-Fat Ewe’s Milk Daily

Sheep milk is liquid gold for a cheesemaker. Its high butterfat and protein content yield more cheese per gallon than cow or goat milk, resulting in a rich, creamy texture and complex, nutty flavors. But this richness also makes it more delicate; it must be handled with care and used quickly.

Ideally, you make cheese with milk that is still warm from the morning’s milking. This is the absolute peak of freshness, teeming with beneficial bacteria and enzymes that contribute to a superior final product. If you don’t have your own flock, find a local shepherd you trust and arrange to pick up milk on the day they milk.

Don’t underestimate the impact of the animal’s diet on your cheese. Milk from ewes grazing on diverse pasture will produce cheese with grassy, floral, and herbaceous notes that change with the seasons. This is the "terroir" of your farm, a unique flavor profile you can never replicate with store-bought milk. It’s the true taste of your land.

Using Simple Kitchen Tools for Coagulation

You do not need a specialized cheese vat to make excellent cheese. Our ancestors certainly didn’t have one. A large, heavy-bottomed stainless steel or unchipped enamel stockpot is the single most important piece of equipment you’ll own. It must be non-reactive, as the acidity developed during the process can leach metallic flavors from aluminum or cast iron.

Beyond the pot, the list of essential tools is refreshingly short and likely already in your kitchen.

• A long-handled stainless steel spoon or ladle for stirring.
• A reliable instant-read or candy thermometer.
• A set of measuring cups and spoons.
• A long, thin knife for cutting the curd.
• A colander lined with cheesecloth.

While old-timers developed a "feel" for temperature, a good thermometer is your best friend for consistency. Hitting the precise temperatures for warming the milk and adding the rennet is crucial for achieving the right curd structure. It’s the one modern tool that removes significant guesswork and dramatically increases your chances of success.

Setting the Curd with Traditional Animal Rennet

The magic of cheesemaking happens when milk transforms from a liquid into a solid curd. This is achieved with rennet, an enzyme complex that coagulates the milk’s proteins. For centuries, the standard was animal rennet, derived from the stomach lining of a young ruminant like a calf or lamb. It’s what your grandparents would have used, and it’s known for producing a firm, stable curd and contributing to the complex flavors that develop during aging.

Using rennet is a delicate step. It must first be diluted in a small amount of cool, non-chlorinated water, as chlorine can deactivate the enzymes. Once diluted, it’s stirred into the warmed milk with a gentle but thorough motion for no more than a minute. Over-stirring can shatter the fragile protein network as it begins to form. After stirring, the pot must be left completely still for the curd to set properly.

While vegetable and microbial rennets are available and work well, they are a modern invention. Traditionalists argue that animal rennet provides a depth of flavor that is hard to match, especially in aged cheeses. The choice is yours, but understanding the traditional method provides a baseline for what makes classic sheep cheeses so distinct.

The Gentle Art of Cutting and Stirring Curds

Once the milk has set into a solid, custard-like mass, the next step is to cut the curd. The purpose of cutting is to release the liquid whey from the solid curds. The size of the cut is one of the most important factors in determining the final cheese’s moisture content and texture. For a hard, aged cheese like a Pecorino, you’ll want tiny, rice-sized curds; for a softer, moister cheese, you’ll cut larger, walnut-sized cubes.

A long, sanitized knife that reaches the bottom of the pot is all you need. Make a series of parallel cuts in one direction, then turn the pot 90 degrees and repeat, creating a checkerboard pattern. Finally, hold the knife at an angle to cut the vertical columns diagonally. The goal is to create uniformly sized cubes without mashing or tearing the delicate structure.

After a brief rest, you’ll begin stirring the curds very gently. This helps the curds expel more whey and prevents them from clumping back together into a solid mass. Some recipes require you to slowly raise the temperature while stirring, a process called "cooking," which firms the curds even further. This is a stage of quiet observation, not vigorous action.

Draining and Pressing Whey with Simple Weights

After cutting and stirring, the curds and whey must be separated. The first step is to let the curds settle to the bottom of the pot, then carefully ladle or pour off the whey. Don’t throw this liquid out! Whey is nutritious and can be used to make ricotta, supplement animal feed, or fertilize your garden.

For hard cheeses, the drained curds are placed into a cheesecloth-lined mold and pressed to expel the remaining whey and knit the curds together. You don’t need an expensive cheese press. A simple DIY setup works just as well: place a "follower" (like a small plate or a custom-cut piece of wood) on top of the curds, and add weight. Clean bricks, jugs filled with water, or even hand weights are effective.

The key to successful pressing is to apply pressure gradually. Start with a light weight for the first hour, then incrementally increase it over the next 12 to 24 hours, flipping and re-dressing the cheese periodically. This slow, steady pressure ensures the whey channels can escape, preventing a sour and brittle cheese. Rushing this step will trap moisture and ruin your hard work.

Salting and Aging Cheese in a Cool, Dark Cellar

Salt is more than just a seasoning in cheesemaking; it’s a critical preservative that slows down microbial activity, helps draw out the last bits of whey, and encourages the formation of a protective rind. The two most common methods are dry salting, where you rub coarse salt directly onto the surface of the pressed cheese, or brining, which involves soaking the cheese in a saturated saltwater solution for several hours or days.

Your "cellar" doesn’t need to be a stone-lined cavern. What you need is a space with a consistent, cool temperature—ideally between 50-55°F (10-13°C)—and relatively high humidity. A basement, a root cellar, or even a small wine fridge can be adapted for aging cheese. The stable environment allows the complex flavors to develop slowly and gracefully.

During aging, your cheese needs regular attention. It must be flipped every day or two to ensure even moisture distribution and prevent it from sticking to the shelf. You’ll also need to wipe down the surface to manage the growth of molds, encouraging the desirable ones while brushing away any unwanted visitors. This daily ritual is part of the art, connecting you to the living, breathing process of affinage.

The Patience and Reward of Homemade Sheep Cheese

Cheesemaking is the antithesis of modern, instant-gratification culture. It is a slow, deliberate process that demands patience and rewards observation. From the moment you warm the milk to the day you finally cut into a finished wheel, you are participating in a timeless cycle of transformation.

For our grandparents, this wasn’t a hobby; it was a fundamental part of the farm’s rhythm. It was how they captured the fleeting abundance of spring and summer pastures and turned it into stable, life-sustaining calories for the winter. Each wheel of cheese was a testament to their skill, their animals, and their land.

The ultimate reward is a food that is truly your own. The flavor tells a story of your pasture, the health of your flock, and the care you took in every step. It’s a dense, flavorful, and deeply satisfying product that simply cannot be bought, a tangible link to a more resourceful and resilient past.

Start small with a simple, fresh cheese to understand the feel of the curds. This craft isn’t about perfection on the first try; it’s about learning the rhythm of milk, time, and temperature. The skills you build are as valuable and lasting as the cheese you create.