7 Canning Onions Pickled Recipes Your Grandparents Knew

You’ve pulled the last of your storage onions, and the curing racks are full. It’s a satisfying sight, but you know some won’t make it through the winter in a root cellar. This is where our grandparents’ wisdom comes in, turning a potential loss into a pantry staple.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why Our Grandparents Pickled Their Onions

Before reliable refrigeration and sprawling grocery stores, food preservation was not a hobby; it was a critical survival skill. A full pantry meant security through the lean months. Onions that were too small, slightly bruised, or simply part of a bumper crop were never wasted.

Pickling was a primary method for extending the harvest. Using vinegar, salt, and sugar, they could transform a perishable vegetable into something that would last for a year or more on a cool, dark shelf. This wasn’t about creating a fancy condiment, but about ensuring there was food on the table in February.

This mindset is just as relevant for the modern hobby farmer. Every onion you can, every jar you fill, is a step toward self-sufficiency. It’s about respecting the work you put into the soil and ensuring none of that effort goes to waste.

The Classic Sweet and Sour Pickling Method

This is the foundational recipe, the one most people think of when they imagine pickled onions. It’s a straightforward balance of white vinegar and sugar, often with a bit of salt and some simple pickling spices like mustard seed and peppercorns. The goal is a crisp, tangy onion that still has a hint of sweetness.

The beauty of this method is its versatility. It works well with almost any standard yellow or white onion, sliced or whole if you’re using small boilers. The brine is simple to prepare, and the results are predictable and delicious. This is your go-to when you have a mixed batch of onions and need a reliable way to put them up.

There’s no magic here, just a solid technique. The key is getting the vinegar-to-sugar ratio right for your taste. Start with a 2:1 vinegar-to-sugar ratio by volume and adjust from there. This recipe is less about a specific flavor profile and more about pure, effective preservation.

Spicy Dilled Pearl Onions: A Garden Staple

Pearl onions can feel like a lot of work for a small reward, but this recipe is where they truly shine. The combination of fresh dill, garlic, and a kick from red pepper flakes turns these tiny onions into flavor powerhouses. They hold their shape and firm texture perfectly, making them a fantastic addition to relish trays or savory dishes.

The biggest hurdle is peeling the onions. The trick is to blanch them in boiling water for about 60 seconds, then plunge them into an ice bath. The skins will slip off much more easily. It’s still tedious work, so put on some music or a podcast.

The tradeoff is clear: more prep work for a unique, bite-sized result. Don’t feel you need perfectly uniform, store-bought pearl onions. Use the small, odd-sized ones from your own harvest that are too small for much else. This recipe gives them a distinct and valuable purpose.

Sweet Bread-and-Butter Style Onion Slices

If you’ve ever made bread-and-butter pickles with cucumbers, this recipe will feel familiar. It uses a much sweeter brine than a classic sour pickle, balanced with mustard seed, celery seed, and turmeric for that characteristic color and flavor. This is an excellent way to use up large, sweet onions like Vidalia or Walla Walla types.

The process often involves salting the onion slices and letting them sit for a few hours to draw out excess water. This step is crucial for ensuring the final product is crisp, not soggy. It’s an extra step, but it makes a world of difference in the texture.

This style isn’t for everyone; some find it too sweet. But for sandwiches, burgers, or chopped into a potato salad, they are unbeatable. Think of these less as a sharp pickle and more as a sweet, tangy condiment. They are a perfect example of adapting a popular preservation technique to a different vegetable from the garden.

Old-World Mustard and Turmeric Pickled Onions

This recipe has a distinctly savory, earthy profile that feels rooted in Northern European traditions. It relies on a heavy dose of mustard seed and turmeric, creating a pungent, golden-yellow brine that completely transforms the onion. The flavor is bold and complex, far from a simple sweet-and-sour pickle.

Often, the brine for this style is slightly thickened with a bit of flour or cornstarch, creating a sauce that clings to the onions. This makes them a fantastic accompaniment to rich, fatty meats like pork or sausages. It’s a hearty, rustic pickle for a hearty meal.

This isn’t a subtle flavor, and that’s the point. It was designed to stand up to strong-tasting preserved meats and aged cheeses. If your palate leans toward sharp, savory, and complex flavors, this old-world method is well worth exploring.

Herbed Red Wine Vinegar Pickled Red Onions

This is where pickling starts to feel a bit more elegant. Using red wine vinegar not only provides a distinct, fruity tang but also enhances the beautiful color of red onions, resulting in a jewel-toned product that’s as pretty as it is tasty. Adding hardy herbs like thyme, rosemary, or bay leaves introduces another layer of complexity.

This method is less about long-term, hard-core preservation and more about creating a high-value condiment. The flavor profile is perfect for Mediterranean-style dishes, salads, and grain bowls. Because of the more delicate flavors, these are best made in smaller batches and enjoyed within a few months for peak quality.

The key consideration here is balance. The robust flavor of red wine vinegar can easily overpower delicate herbs. Use whole sprigs of thyme or rosemary and a single bay leaf per jar. Your goal is to complement the onion’s natural sweetness, not mask it.

Traditional Malt Vinegar Pub-Style Onions

If you want a truly sharp, assertive pickled onion, this is the one. This British classic uses malt vinegar, which has a deep, complex, and slightly sweet flavor from its barley origins. There’s very little sugar, if any, in this recipe—the focus is on the pure, pungent power of the vinegar.

These are the quintessential onions you’d find in a jar on a pub counter, served alongside a ploughman’s lunch or a pork pie. They are meant to cut through rich, heavy foods with a sharp, acidic bite. The recipe couldn’t be simpler: small peeled onions, hot malt vinegar, and maybe a few peppercorns.

The main tradeoff is the intensity. Malt vinegar is a love-it-or-hate-it ingredient, and its flavor is unmistakable. If you’re not a fan, this recipe won’t be for you. But for those who appreciate its robust character, there is no substitute.

Honey-Sweetened Pickled Onions with Cloves

This recipe harks back to a time when refined white sugar wasn’t always on hand, but a crock of honey might have been. Using honey instead of sugar lends a distinct floral note and a rounder, more mellow sweetness to the brine. Paired with the warm, aromatic spice of whole cloves, it creates a truly unique and old-fashioned flavor.

When canning with honey, it’s important to use a light, mild variety so it doesn’t completely overpower the other ingredients. The acidity of the vinegar is still the primary preserving agent, so the substitution is safe. This method works beautifully with sweet yellow onions or even shallots.

This approach is a great way to connect different parts of your homestead—using honey from your own hives to preserve onions from your garden. It’s a perfect example of the closed-loop systems our grandparents relied on. The result is a pickle that tastes not just of onions and spice, but of a specific time and place.

These recipes are more than just instructions; they are a link to a more resourceful past. Pick a method that suits the onions you have and the flavors you love. By filling your pantry shelves, you’re not just preserving food—you’re carrying on a legacy of practical, hands-on skill.