7 Goat Milk Replacers For Newborn Kids Old Farmers Swear By

It’s two in the morning and you find a shivering, weak kid the doe has rejected. The feed store is closed, and this little one needs calories, now. This moment is exactly why every goat keeper, no matter how small their herd, needs a reliable milk replacer plan before kidding season even starts. Having the right formula on hand—or at least a recipe for a temporary fix—can be the difference between life and death.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Key Factors in Choosing a Kid Milk Replacer

The single most important factor on a milk replacer bag is the protein source. Look for formulas that are "all-milk protein." This means the protein comes from whey or casein, which a kid’s delicate digestive system is built to handle.

Avoid formulas that use plant-based proteins, especially soy, as a primary ingredient. While cheaper, these can cause serious digestive upset, scours, and poor growth in young kids. Their systems simply aren’t ready to process it.

Beyond the ingredients, consider these practical points:

• Mixability: A good replacer dissolves easily in warm water without endless clumping. Lumps can clog a nipple and, worse, cause digestive blockages.
• Fat Content: Look for a fat content around 30% and protein around 25%. This ratio closely mimics a doe’s natural milk and provides the energy kids need to thrive.
• Availability: The best formula in the world does you no good if you can’t get it locally. Check what your nearby feed stores consistently stock.

Don’t just grab the cheapest bag on the shelf. The few dollars you save upfront can be quickly lost to vet bills or a lost kid. Investing in a quality, all-milk replacer is one of the smartest decisions you can make for the health of your herd.

Manna Pro Kid Milk Replacer: A Trusted Staple

You’ll find a bag of Manna Pro Kid Milk Replacer in just about every feed store, and for good reason. It’s a reliable, all-milk protein formula that has raised countless healthy kids over the years. For many old-timers, it’s the default choice they keep in the barn "just in case."

The formula is balanced and provides the essential fats, proteins, vitamins, and minerals needed for steady growth. It’s a solid, middle-of-the-road option that gets the job done without a premium price tag. If you need a dependable product you can find almost anywhere, Manna Pro is a safe bet.

However, some keepers find it can be a bit rich for particularly sensitive kids, sometimes leading to scours if not mixed with precision. Always use a whisk to ensure it’s fully dissolved, and follow the temperature guidelines on the bag exactly. Starting with a slightly more diluted mixture for the first couple of feedings can also help a new kid adjust.

Sav-A-Kid Milk Replacer for Easy Digestion

If you’re dealing with a weak, premature, or struggling kid, Sav-A-Kid is often the recommended choice. It’s specifically formulated to be gentle on the digestive system. This is its main selling point and where it truly shines.

The formula often includes probiotics to help establish healthy gut flora, which is crucial for an orphan or a kid that didn’t get enough colostrum. It also mixes into a very smooth, consistent liquid with minimal effort, which is a real blessing when you’re exhausted and fumbling with bottles in the middle of the night. For fragile kids, that ease of digestion can make all the difference.

Land O’Lakes Doe’s Match for Natural Nutrition

When you want to get as close as possible to the real thing, Land O’Lakes Doe’s Match is the top-tier option. As the name implies, its formulation is designed to closely mimic the nutritional profile of an actual doe’s milk. It has an excellent balance of fat and all-milk protein.

This is the replacer many serious breeders turn to for their most valuable kids. The results speak for themselves: kids raised on Doe’s Match often show excellent growth rates and beautiful, healthy coats. If you have a kid whose health and development is your absolute top priority, this is the formula to reach for. The downside, of course, is the price. It’s one of the more expensive options on the market, so it may not be practical for a large number of bottle babies on a tight budget.

The Classic Evaporated Milk Homemade Recipe

Every farmer should know an emergency recipe, and this is the most common one. It’s not for long-term use, but it will absolutely get a kid through a night or two until you can get proper replacer. This is a bridge, not a destination.

The recipe is simple:

• 1 can (12 oz) of whole evaporated milk
• 1 can of water (use the empty milk can to measure)
• 1 raw egg yolk (for fat and nutrients)
• 1 tablespoon of corn syrup or molasses (for quick energy)

Mix these ingredients thoroughly and warm the formula to about 102°F before feeding. The evaporated milk provides a high-fat, easily digestible base, while the egg yolk adds extra richness and the syrup gives a much-needed energy boost to a chilled or weak kid.

It is critical to understand this recipe lacks the balanced vitamins, minerals (especially copper and selenium), and probiotics found in a commercial formula. Using it for more than 48-72 hours will lead to nutritional deficiencies. Use it to solve a crisis, then switch to a proper kid milk replacer as soon as possible.

A Simple Whole Cow’s Milk Emergency Formula

If you find yourself in a real bind with nothing else in the house, whole cow’s milk from the grocery store can work for a feeding or two. Goat’s milk has a higher fat content than cow’s milk, so you need to modify it slightly. The goal is to bridge the gap until you can get a proper formula.

The simplest way to fortify it is to mix three parts whole cow’s milk with one part evaporated milk. This bumps up the fat and protein content to be a little closer to what a kid needs. Don’t use 2% or skim milk; a growing kid needs all the fat it can get. This is an even more temporary solution than the classic evaporated milk recipe.

DuMOR Kid Milk Replacer: The Reliable TSC Option

If you’re a regular at Tractor Supply Co., you’re familiar with their house brand, DuMOR. Their kid milk replacer is a solid, widely available option that stands up well against the bigger names. It is an all-milk protein formula, making it a safe and effective choice.

Many farmers use DuMOR and Manna Pro interchangeably, often buying whichever is on sale. It mixes well, kids seem to take to it readily, and it supports healthy growth. For the hobby farmer looking for a reliable product that’s easy to find and won’t break the bank, DuMOR is a perfectly respectable choice to keep on hand.

Meyenberg Goat Milk: A Whole Food Alternative

For those who prefer to avoid powdered formulas altogether, there is another path: using real goat’s milk from the grocery store. Meyenberg is the most common brand, available as whole evaporated milk in a can or as a powdered whole milk. This isn’t a replacer—it’s the real deal.

The primary advantage is digestibility. You’re giving a kid the exact type of milk their system was designed for, which can eliminate many of the digestive issues sometimes seen with powdered replacers. For a single, high-value pet or a particularly sensitive kid, this can be an excellent (though laborious) option.

The glaring disadvantage is the cost. Using store-bought goat milk is significantly more expensive than any commercial replacer, and the price adds up incredibly fast. It is not a sustainable choice for raising multiple kids. Think of it as a premium, short-term option for a special case, not a standard protocol for your herd.

Ultimately, the best milk replacer is the one you have on hand when you need it. Pick a quality commercial brand that’s readily available in your area and keep a small bag in a cool, dry place. Knowing one of the emergency recipes is your backup plan, ensuring you’re prepared for whatever challenges kidding season throws your way.