6 Calcium Supplements For Laying Hens Old-Timers Swear By

You reach into the nesting box and feel it—the dreaded soft-shelled egg, flimsy and fragile in your hand. It’s a clear signal from your hens that something is out of balance in their diet. Getting calcium right is fundamental not just for strong eggs, but for the long-term health and vitality of your entire flock.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why Strong Eggshells Depend on Proper Calcium

A hen’s body is a remarkable egg-making machine, but it follows a strict biological budget. To form a single eggshell, she must mobilize a significant amount of calcium carbonate. If her diet doesn’t provide enough, she will pull it directly from her own bones.

This isn’t a sustainable process. Over time, a calcium deficit leads to brittle bones, decreased laying, and a higher risk of becoming egg-bound, a life-threatening condition. Proper supplementation isn’t just about producing perfect eggs for your kitchen; it’s a cornerstone of responsible animal husbandry.

Think of calcium as the primary building block, but it doesn’t work alone. Your hens also need adequate Vitamin D3, often sourced from sunlight or fortified feed, to absorb the calcium effectively. They also require phosphorus in the correct ratio. A high-quality layer feed is formulated to provide this balance, but supplemental calcium is almost always necessary for consistent, strong shells.

Manna Pro Crushed Oyster Shell for Free Choice

Crushed oyster shell is the gold standard for a reason. It’s the go-to supplement you’ll find in every feed store, and its effectiveness has been proven over generations. The shell fragments are the ideal size for a hen’s gizzard to process gradually, providing a slow, steady release of calcium.

The key to using oyster shell is offering it "free choice." This means you don’t mix it into the feed. Instead, you provide it in a separate, dedicated container where hens can take what they need, when they need it. Chickens are surprisingly good at regulating their own calcium intake; a hen preparing to lay will seek it out, while others might ignore it.

This method prevents over-supplementation and respects the individual needs of each bird in your flock. A simple hanging feeder or a heavy ceramic dish placed in a covered area of the run works perfectly. The only real tradeoff is the recurring cost, but a 50-pound bag lasts a small flock a very long time, making it a reliable and low-effort solution.

Using Crushed Eggshells: The Homesteader’s Way

For those looking for a zero-cost, closed-loop system, using your own crushed eggshells is a fantastic option. It turns a waste product back into a valuable resource. However, you cannot simply toss raw shells back to your flock.

To do it safely, you must follow a few crucial steps. First, rinse the shells to remove any remaining membrane. Second, and most importantly, bake the shells until they are dry and brittle—a low oven for 10-15 minutes does the trick. This sterilizes them and changes their texture and smell, preventing your hens from associating them with fresh eggs and encouraging egg-eating behavior.

Once baked, crush the shells into small, unrecognizable pieces, roughly the size of a pinky fingernail or smaller. A rolling pin or a quick pulse in a blender works well. Like oyster shell, offer the crushed eggshells free choice in a separate dish. It’s a bit more work, but it’s a perfectly effective and sustainable practice.

Purina Layena+ Crumbles: Calcium in the Feed

Many high-quality commercial feeds, like Purina’s Layena+, are formulated with elevated levels of calcium built right in. This approach aims to provide a complete, all-in-one nutritional package that, in theory, eliminates the need for separate supplements. The calcium is often included in the form of calcium carbonate.

This method is incredibly convenient, especially for beginners or those with busy schedules. There are no extra containers to fill, and you can be confident that every bite of feed contains the necessary minerals. It simplifies your daily chores down to just providing feed and water.

The primary consideration here is that you lose the benefit of self-regulation. Every hen gets the same amount of calcium, regardless of her age, laying cycle, or foraging habits. For most backyard flocks, this works just fine. But for older hens, exceptionally productive layers, or flocks that get a lot of scratch grains and kitchen scraps, you may still find a free-choice supplement is necessary to fill the gaps.

Redmond Conditioner with Natural Aragonite Clay

Some keepers prefer supplements that offer more than just a single mineral. Redmond Conditioner is a popular choice in this category, blending natural aragonite—a highly bioavailable form of calcium carbonate—with bentonite clay and its associated trace minerals.

The idea behind a product like this is to support the hen’s overall health, not just her eggshell production. The trace minerals in the clay can aid in digestion and nutrient absorption, contributing to better feed conversion and overall vitality. It’s a more holistic approach to supplementation.

Like oyster shell, this conditioner is best offered free choice in a separate feeder. It’s a premium product with a higher price point, but those who use it often point to improved feather condition and general flock hardiness as benefits beyond just strong eggshells. It’s a good fit for homesteaders focused on providing a broad spectrum of natural minerals.

Durvet Liquid Calcium for Water Supplementation

Liquid calcium supplements are not your everyday solution; think of them as a targeted intervention tool. These products, added directly to the flock’s drinking water, provide a fast-acting, easily absorbed source of calcium for birds in immediate need.

This is the supplement to reach for in specific situations. For example:

• A hen recovering from being egg-bound.
• During an extreme heatwave when feed consumption drops dramatically.
• For an older, high-producing hen who consistently lays thin-shelled eggs despite other supplements.

Because it’s administered to the entire water source, it’s not ideal for long-term, flock-wide use. It’s a short-term boost to get a bird through a difficult period. Always follow the dosage instructions carefully and ensure waterers are cleaned frequently, as supplements can sometimes encourage bacterial growth.

Global Harvest Fine Ground Agricultural Lime

For the flock owner with a keen eye on the budget, agricultural lime can be an effective bulk source of calcium. However, this comes with a critical warning: you must use fine-ground agricultural lime (calcium carbonate), NOT hydrated lime (calcium hydroxide). Hydrated lime is caustic and will harm your birds.

Agricultural lime is essentially powdered limestone. Because it’s a fine powder, it’s not suitable for free-choice feeding in an open dish where it can be scattered and wasted. The best way to use it is by lightly top-dressing the daily feed ration, ensuring it mixes in and sticks to the crumbles or pellets.

This is the most economical option, especially for larger flocks, but it requires careful sourcing and application. You lose the self-regulation benefit of free-choice feeding, so you need to be confident in your measurements. It’s a practical, old-school solution for the discerning farmer.

How to Offer Supplements for Best Absorption

How you offer calcium is just as important as what you offer. For any particulate supplement like oyster shell, crushed eggshells, or mineral conditioners, the free-choice method is superior. Place the supplement in a separate hopper or dish, protected from the elements, and let the hens decide how much they need.

Timing also plays a role. A hen’s body does the hard work of forming an eggshell overnight. Ensuring that calcium is readily available in her digestive system during the afternoon and evening gives her the resources she needs for this demanding process. If you notice your free-choice feeder is empty, try to refill it midday rather than waiting until the next morning.

Finally, remember the bigger picture. Calcium doesn’t work in a vacuum. Ensure your flock has access to sunlight or a feed containing Vitamin D3 for absorption. A balanced layer ration will provide the necessary phosphorus. Strong shells are the result of a complete system, not just a single supplement.

Ultimately, there is no single "best" calcium supplement, only the one that best fits your management style, budget, and flock’s specific needs. Pay attention to your hens and their eggs—they will always tell you what’s working. By providing the right building blocks, you ensure their health and a steady supply of beautiful, strong-shelled eggs.