6 Choosing Quail Breeds For Eggs For First-Year Success

You’ve decided to raise quail, a smart move for anyone wanting a fast and efficient source of homegrown eggs. But staring at the list of available breeds can feel overwhelming, with names like Pharaoh, Jumbo, and Celadon all vying for a spot in your brooder. Choosing the right breed from the start is the single biggest factor in determining whether your first year is a success or a frustrating lesson.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Coturnix Japonica: The Foundation of Egg Quail

All the birds we’re about to discuss are varieties of a single species: Coturnix japonica, or the Japanese quail. This isn’t a separate breed you choose, but the family they all belong to. Understanding this simplifies everything; you’re not learning a dozen different species, just the unique traits of specialized lineages.

Think of Coturnix japonica as the blueprint. They are all fast-maturing birds, typically laying eggs as early as six to eight weeks of age. They are also highly efficient feed converters and thrive in relatively small spaces. The different "breeds" are simply variations that have been selectively bred for specific traits like size, egg color, feather pattern, or temperament.

Pharaoh Coturnix: The Classic and Hardy Beginner Bird

When you see "Coturnix quail" without any other descriptor, you’re likely looking at the Pharaoh. This variety has the "wild-type" coloration, a mottled brown pattern that provides excellent camouflage. This is the bird all other Coturnix varieties are measured against.

For a first-time owner, the Pharaoh is an outstanding choice. They are known for their hardiness and vigor, often being more resilient to minor stressors or beginner mistakes in husbandry. Their egg production is consistent and reliable, giving you a steady supply without the fuss of more specialized breeds. If you are unsure where to start, start with Pharaohs.

Jumbo Coturnix: Best for Dual-Purpose Egg and Meat

The term "Jumbo" refers to a size, not a specific breed with a unique color. These are Coturnix quail selectively bred to be significantly heavier than their standard counterparts. A standard Pharaoh might weigh 5-6 ounces, while a Jumbo can easily reach 10-14 ounces or more.

This size makes them the premier choice for anyone with a dual-purpose goal: eggs for the kitchen and meat for the table. The extra roosters, which are an inevitable part of hatching your own birds, grow out to a much more substantial size for processing. The tradeoff is feed consumption; larger birds eat more, so your cost per egg will be slightly higher. Their eggs are also larger, which can be a definite plus.

Italian Coturnix: Top Choice for Egg Production Rate

If your primary goal is the maximum number of eggs from the smallest footprint, the Italian is your bird. These quail are often lighter in color, a faint gold or cream, and have been selected relentlessly for one thing: prolific laying. They are the egg-laying machines of the quail world.

Italians tend to be slightly smaller and more streamlined than Pharaohs. They put all their energy into egg production, sometimes laying nearly an egg a day under ideal conditions. While hardy, they can be a bit more flighty and less docile than some other varieties. Choose this breed if you’re focused on efficiency and have your system dialed in for optimal light and nutrition.

Celadon Coturnix: Adding Blue Eggs to Your Basket

The defining trait of the Celadon is the recessive gene they carry that results in beautiful blue-shelled eggs. This is purely an aesthetic trait—the eggs taste and cook exactly the same as brown-shelled eggs. However, a basket of mixed brown-speckled and blue eggs is undeniably appealing.

Because they are bred for a recessive trait, it’s crucial to source Celadons from a reputable breeder. Poorly bred lines may have lower production rates or inconsistent blue coloring. True Celadons are reliable layers, but their primary appeal is the novelty and beauty of their eggs. They are a fantastic way to add variety and interest to your quail-keeping adventure.

Tibetan Coturnix: A Hardy, Dark-Feathered Choice

The Tibetan is a dark-feathered variety, ranging from a rich chocolate brown to nearly black. They are comparable in size and production to the standard Pharaoh, making them another excellent all-around choice. Their temperament is generally calm, and they are known for being just as hardy as their wild-type cousins.

One practical, though slightly grim, advantage of their dark plumage is for those planning to process birds for meat. Dark feathers don’t leave noticeable pinfeathers on the skin, resulting in a cleaner-looking final product. For many, the choice is simply aesthetic; the deep, uniform color of a Tibetan flock is quite striking.

Manchurian Golden: A Docile and Beautiful Producer

Known for their gorgeous golden-blond plumage, Manchurian Golden quail are often selected for their looks and their temperament. They tend to be one of the more docile and calm Coturnix varieties, making them a great fit for backyard setups where a quiet, less flighty bird is preferred.

While they are solid egg producers, their rate of lay can sometimes be slightly lower than that of a production-focused line like the Italian. They are a wonderful dual-purpose bird, similar in size to a Pharaoh, offering both consistent eggs and a reasonably sized carcass. If you value a calm disposition and beautiful birds in your covey, the Manchurian Golden is a top contender.

Pharaoh vs. Jumbo Coturnix: A Size Comparison

Choosing between the standard Pharaoh and a Jumbo line is one of the most common decisions for a new quail keeper. There is no right answer, only the best fit for your specific goals. The differences are straightforward but significant.

Here’s a direct breakdown:

• Primary Goal: If you want eggs with meat as a secondary byproduct, choose Pharaoh. If meat is an equal or primary goal, choose Jumbo.
• Feed Efficiency: Pharaohs are more efficient at converting feed into eggs. Jumbos require more feed to maintain their larger body size, increasing the cost per egg.
• Space: Jumbos are heavier but not necessarily taller. You can often keep them at similar densities, but they will tax deep-litter systems more quickly due to producing more waste.
• Egg Size: Jumbo quail lay larger eggs, typically 14-18 grams compared to the Pharaoh’s 10-13 grams. This can be a major selling point for culinary use.
• Growth Rate: Jumbos reach a processable weight faster than standard varieties, making them more efficient for meat production cycles.

Ultimately, the decision comes down to your priorities. Jumbos offer more food in total, while Pharaohs offer a more efficient egg-laying operation. For your first year, the hardiness of a good Pharaoh line can be more forgiving, but if processing birds is a definite part of your plan, starting with Jumbos makes perfect sense.

The best quail breed for you is the one that aligns with your goals for keeping them. Don’t chase a specific color or the absolute highest production number in your first year; instead, focus on a hardy, reliable bird like the Pharaoh or a practical dual-purpose line like the Jumbo. Master the fundamentals with a forgiving breed, and you’ll build the confidence and skill to explore the more specialized varieties later.