6 Suet For Titmice That Veteran Birdwatchers Swear By

You hear that sharp, cheerful peter-peter-peter call and see a flash of gray and white at the feeder. The Tufted Titmouse is a backyard favorite, a bold and acrobatic bird that brings life to even the quietest winter day. Providing the right food is the surest way to keep them coming back, and for these energetic little birds, nothing beats high-quality suet.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why Titmice Flock to High-Energy Suet Cakes

Titmice are tiny birds with incredibly fast metabolisms. They are constantly on the move, flitting from branch to branch, which burns a tremendous amount of energy, especially during the cold months when they need to maintain their body temperature.

Suet, which is rendered animal fat, is the most calorie-dense food you can offer. Think of it as pure fuel. While seeds provide protein and some fats, a suet cake offers a concentrated energy source that helps titmice, chickadees, and nuthatches survive frigid nights and long winters when their natural food source—insects—is gone.

Offering suet isn’t just a winter activity, either. During the spring nesting season, parent birds are exhausted from raising their young. A reliable suet feeder gives them an easy, high-energy meal, freeing up time and energy to forage for the insects their nestlings require.

C&S Peanut Delight: A Classic Titmouse Favorite

If you’re going to start with one suet, this is often the one. C&S Peanut Delight is a straightforward, no-frills blend of rendered beef suet and roasted peanuts. Titmice, with their strong beaks, have no problem breaking off chunks of peanut and flying away to cache them for later.

This suet’s simplicity is its greatest strength. It doesn’t contain a lot of cheap fillers like milo or cracked corn that smaller birds often ignore. The formula is consistent and widely available at a price that makes year-round feeding practical.

The main tradeoff with a popular classic like this is that everyone loves it. You’ll attract plenty of titmice, but you can also expect woodpeckers, nuthatches, and chickadees. Unfortunately, squirrels and larger birds like starlings are also big fans, which is why pairing this suet with the right feeder is so important.

Heath Bird’s Blend Suet Cake for More Variety

Sometimes you want to offer more than just a single food source. The Heath Bird’s Blend suet cake mixes classic rendered fat with a variety of seeds, typically millet and sunflower. This turns your suet feeder into more of a one-stop shop for a wider range of birds.

This approach is great for bringing more activity to your feeding station. While the titmice are there for the high-fat suet, you might also draw in finches or juncos who are attracted to the seeds. It creates a more dynamic and diverse feeding environment.

The downside is that what attracts some birds may not be ideal for others. The added seeds can sometimes make the cake crumble faster, especially in wet weather. It’s a great general-purpose suet, but if your primary goal is to cater exclusively to titmice and woodpeckers, a simpler peanut or nut-based blend is often more effective.

Pine Tree Farms Berry Suet for Year-Round Feeding

Adding berries to a suet cake is a smart way to appeal to a different set of nutritional needs. Pine Tree Farms Berry Suet blends rendered fat with berry flavorings or actual dried berries. This is particularly effective during the late summer and fall.

While titmice are primarily insect and seed eaters, they will consume fruit, and the variety can be a welcome change. More importantly, berry suet is a magnet for birds like bluebirds, mockingbirds, and robins—species that might otherwise ignore a standard suet feeder. It allows you to support a broader ecosystem in your backyard.

This isn’t the highest-energy option for the dead of winter, but it’s an excellent choice for the shoulder seasons. Think of it as a transitional food that bridges the gap between the insect-rich summer and the deep-freeze of winter when pure fat is king.

Audubon Park High-Energy Suet for Cold Winters

When the temperature plummets, a bird’s daily priority shifts from simple feeding to pure survival. Audubon Park’s High-Energy Suet is formulated specifically for this purpose. It typically features a very high concentration of fat, along with calorie-dense ingredients like sunflower hearts and peanuts.

This is the suet you put out when a winter storm is rolling in. The extra calories can make the difference between a small bird surviving a sub-freezing night or not. It’s less about variety and more about providing the most efficient fuel source possible in the harshest conditions.

Because of its rich formula, this suet is extremely attractive to all suet-eating birds. It will be consumed quickly, so it’s not the most economical choice for daily feeding in mild weather. Reserve it for when your birds need it most, and they will thank you for it.

St. Albans Bay Nuts & Berries Suet Dough Cake

Not all suet is a hard, dry cake. Suet "dough" has a softer, more pliable texture that is made by whipping the rendered fat. The St. Albans Bay Nuts & Berries dough is a premium example that small birds find especially easy to eat.

The soft texture means tiny beaks don’t have to work as hard to get a meal, which is a real advantage in freezing weather when hard suet can become rock-solid. This blend combines high-fat nuts with the appeal of berries, making it a favorite for titmice, chickadees, and even wrens.

The primary consideration here is placement. Because it’s softer, suet dough can get messy in very hot weather. It’s an outstanding choice for fall, winter, and spring, but you may want to switch to a "no-melt" formula in the heat of summer.

WBU SuperSuet: A Premium, No-Melt Suet Option

For those who want to feed suet year-round, even in warmer climates, a no-melt formula is essential. Wild Birds Unlimited (WBU) SuperSuet is a top-tier example, engineered with a higher melting point to prevent it from turning into a greasy mess in the summer sun.

These premium cakes are packed with the best ingredients—peanuts, almonds, pecans, and even mealworms. This isn’t just fat; it’s a complete nutritional powerhouse. The no-melt quality also means it won’t smear on birds’ feathers, which can be a problem with lower-quality suet in the heat.

The obvious tradeoff is cost. This is an investment in clean, convenient, high-quality feeding. It’s not the budget option, but if you’re tired of dealing with melted suet or want to offer the absolute best, a premium no-melt cake is the way to go.

Choosing the Right Suet Feeder for Small Birds

The best suet in the world won’t do you any good if the titmice can’t get to it. Larger, more aggressive birds like starlings and grackles can devour an entire suet cake in an afternoon, leaving nothing for the smaller birds. The feeder you choose is your best defense.

The single best investment for feeding titmice is an upside-down suet feeder. This design requires birds to cling to the bottom of the cage and feed upside down. Titmice, chickadees, and nuthatches are natural acrobats and have no problem with this, but bulky starlings simply can’t manage it.

Other effective options include:

• Basic Cage Feeders: Simple and inexpensive. They work, but offer no protection from larger birds or squirrels. Best used if you don’t have issues with feeder bullies.
• Feeders with a Cage-within-a-Cage: These feature a larger outer cage with openings big enough for small birds but too small for starlings or squirrels. They are highly effective but can be more difficult to clean.
• Tail-Prop Feeders: Designed for woodpeckers, these feeders have a long "tail prop" at the bottom. Titmice will happily use them, and they can sometimes deter starlings who prefer a more horizontal perch.

Ultimately, your feeder choice dictates who gets to eat. An upside-down feeder filled with a simple peanut suet is often more effective at feeding titmice than a premium suet in a feeder that allows starlings to dominate.

Choosing the right suet isn’t about finding a single perfect cake, but about adapting to the seasons and your specific backyard visitors. By pairing a high-quality, high-energy suet with a feeder designed for small birds, you can ensure your resident titmice have the fuel they need to thrive all year long. That cheerful peter-peter-peter call will be your constant reward.