6 Metal Vs Plastic Feed Scoops For Livestock That Old Farmers Swear By

You’ve been there. It’s five in the morning, the air is cold enough to see your breath, and the only thing standing between a herd of hungry animals and their breakfast is you and a feed scoop. It’s in these quiet, repetitive moments that you realize the quality of your simplest tools matters most. A cheap plastic scoop that cracks in the winter or a metal one that’s too heavy for the job can turn a simple chore into a daily frustration.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

The Humble Feed Scoop: A Farmer’s Essential Tool

A feed scoop is more than just a shovel for grain. It’s a measuring cup, an ice chipper, a bin scraper, and sometimes, a makeshift hammer. You’ll use it every single day, twice a day, for years. Choosing the right one isn’t about extravagance; it’s about efficiency and sanity.

The fundamental choice comes down to metal versus plastic. Old-timers often lean toward steel, valuing tools that can be passed down through generations. They see a galvanized scoop as a one-time purchase, a reliable partner for the toughest jobs. Yet, modern, high-quality plastics offer compelling advantages in weight, flexibility, and design that can’t be ignored.

This isn’t just about what the scoop is made of. It’s about what you need it to do. Are you breaking up frozen sweet feed for cattle or measuring out a precise ration for your goats? The answer determines whether you need a brute or a specialist.

Behrens Galvanized Steel Scoop: Built for a Lifetime

When you think of a classic farm tool, the Behrens galvanized steel scoop is probably what comes to mind. This isn’t a fancy piece of equipment. It’s a workhorse, designed for one purpose: to move material from one place to another without ever failing. Its heavy-gauge steel construction means you can use it to hack through a block of frozen molasses feed or scrape the last stubborn bits of grain from the bottom of a steel bin without a second thought.

The galvanization process gives it a rugged, corrosion-resistant finish. Leave it out in the rain? It won’t rust through. Drop it on the concrete floor? You’ll be more worried about the concrete. This is the definition of a "buy it once" tool.

The tradeoff for this incredible durability is weight and a certain lack of finesse. It’s heavy, which can be tiring if you’re filling multiple large feeders. The simple riveted handle isn’t designed for ergonomic comfort, but for sheer strength. It’s a tool that prioritizes function over form, and for many farmers, that’s exactly what’s needed.

Little Giant Steel Scoop: A Heavy-Duty Classic

The Little Giant steel scoop occupies a similar space to the Behrens, appealing to those who want uncompromising strength. Often found with a durable powder-coated finish, these scoops are built to withstand the daily abuse of farm life. The seams are welded or heavily riveted, ensuring the handle won’t separate from the scoop body, even under heavy load.

Like any steel scoop, its weight is a double-edged sword. It provides the necessary heft to break up compacted or frozen feed with ease. You can slam it against the side of a feed bag to loosen clumps without worrying about damage. This makes it ideal for handling bulkier feeds for cattle, horses, or hogs.

However, that same weight makes it less suitable for tasks requiring precision or endurance. If you’re measuring small, specific rations or have to carry feed a long distance, the fatigue can add up. It’s the right tool for heavy lifting, but not necessarily for delicate portion control.

Weaver Leather Aluminum Scoop for Lighter Loads

For those who want the durability of metal without the back-straining weight of steel, an aluminum scoop is the perfect middle ground. Weaver, a brand well-known in the equine world, makes an excellent example. An aluminum scoop is significantly lighter than its steel counterpart, making it much easier on the wrists and shoulders during long feeding sessions.

This lightweight nature makes it perfect for finer materials like poultry crumbles, goat pellets, or specialized grain mixes. It won’t rust, and it’s still tough enough to handle the occasional drop or bang. You get the satisfying feel and longevity of metal in a much more manageable package.

The key consideration here is that aluminum is not steel. It does not have the same brute strength. You can’t use it as an icebreaker or a pry bar. Attempting to chip away at a frozen water trough or break up rock-hard feed will likely result in a bent or dented scoop. It’s a tool for scooping, not demolition.

Fortiflex Flat Back Scoop: A Stable, Durable Pick

Now we move into the world of high-quality plastics, and the Fortiflex flat back scoop is a standout example of why plastic shouldn’t be dismissed. Its most brilliant feature is deceptively simple: one side of the bucket is completely flat. This design is a game-changer for efficiency. You can set the scoop down on any flat surface without it tipping over and spilling its contents.

The flat back also allows you to press the scoop flush against the wall of a feed bin or bag, ensuring you get every last bit of grain. Made from a thick, reinforced polyethylene, this scoop is incredibly durable and resists the brittleness that plagues cheap plastic in cold weather.

While it won’t shatter easily, it’s still plastic. A direct hit from a steer’s hoof or getting run over by a tractor will likely end its life. But for everyday use, its clever design and robust construction make it one of the most practical and user-friendly options available. It’s a perfect example of modern design improving a classic tool.

Miller DuraFlex Plastic Scoop: Flexible and Crack-Proof

The biggest fear with any plastic tool on the farm is that it will become brittle and shatter in the freezing cold. The Miller DuraFlex (often sold under the Little Giant brand) was engineered specifically to solve this problem. Its name says it all: the plastic is designed to be flexible, even at sub-zero temperatures.

You can drop this scoop, step on it, or even whack it against a fence post to knock out stuck feed, and it will bend rather than break. This resilience makes it a fantastic all-weather, all-purpose choice. It’s lightweight, quiet (no loud clanging against metal bins), and safe for use in any type of feeder without risking damage.

This flexibility does mean it lacks the rigidity of steel or even a heavy-duty plastic like the Fortiflex. It’s not the tool for chipping ice or scraping hard-packed material. Its strength lies in its ability to survive the accidental abuse that is an inevitable part of farm life.

Farm-Tuff Utility Scoop with Measurement Marks

Sometimes, the job isn’t about moving bulk material; it’s about precision. This is where a plastic scoop with molded measurement marks shines. For hobby farmers managing animals with specific dietary needs—a pregnant goat, a growing calf, or chickens needing a specific protein ratio—eyeballing feed amounts isn’t good enough.

These scoops have markings for quarts or pounds molded directly into the plastic, turning your scoop into a measuring cup. This eliminates the need for a separate scale for daily feeding, saving a crucial step in your routine. It streamlines the process and ensures your animals are getting consistent, accurate rations every single time.

The tradeoff is that these scoops are often built for utility, not extreme durability. The plastic is typically a standard grade, not the reinforced or flexible kind found in Fortiflex or DuraFlex models. They are a specialized tool for accurate feeding, not for heavy-duty labor. Treat it as a measuring instrument, and it will serve you well.

Making the Final Choice: Durability vs. Versatility

There is no single "best" feed scoop. The right choice depends entirely on your animals, your climate, and your chores. The decision boils down to a classic farm tradeoff: lifetime durability versus lightweight versatility.

Metal scoops, particularly steel, are a long-term investment in raw strength.

• Choose a steel scoop (Behrens, Little Giant) if your primary needs are breaking up frozen or compacted feed and you value a tool that will outlive you.
• Choose an aluminum scoop (Weaver) if you want the longevity of metal but need something lighter for smaller grains and less physical strain.

High-quality plastic scoops offer smart design features that solve real-world problems.

• Choose a heavy-duty plastic scoop (Fortiflex) for its stability and excellent bin-scraping ability, making it a fantastic all-arounder.
• Choose a flexible plastic scoop (DuraFlex) if you farm in a cold climate and your top priority is preventing a shattered scoop on a frigid morning.
• Choose a scoop with measurement marks (Farm-Tuff) if you need to deliver precise, repeatable rations to your livestock.

Many seasoned farmers end up with both: a trusty steel scoop for the heavy, dirty work and a lightweight plastic one for daily, measured feeding. Your tools should make your life easier, and having the right scoop for the right job is a small detail that makes a huge difference.

Ultimately, the feed scoop you reach for every morning should feel like an extension of your arm—reliable, effective, and perfectly suited to the task at hand. It’s a small investment, but choosing wisely pays you back with less frustration and more efficiency every single day. Don’t underestimate the value of getting this simple tool right.