6 Gas Smoker Vs Electric Smoker For Jerky That Old-Timers Recommend
Gas smokers offer rich flavor, while electrics provide stable, low heat ideal for jerky. See why old-timers are split between tradition and convenience.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Wood Flavor vs. Temp Control: The Old-Timer’s Dilemma
The choice between gas and electric for jerky comes down to a fundamental tradeoff. It’s about what you value more: authentic smoke flavor or dead-simple consistency. There’s no right answer, just the right answer for your setup and your schedule.
A gas smoker burns propane to heat a small pan of wood chunks or chips. This creates a rich, complex smoke that penetrates the meat deeply. It’s the kind of flavor you just can’t fake. The catch? You have to manage it. Wind, cold, and the propane level can all cause temperature swings, meaning you need to keep a closer eye on things.
Electric smokers, on the other hand, are masters of temperature control. You set a digital thermostat to 165°F, and a heating element holds it there for hours on end. This "set-and-forget" nature is a huge advantage when you have other chores calling your name. The flavor comes from smoldering wood chips in a small tray, which can sometimes taste a bit one-dimensional compared to the real burn of a gas unit.
This is the core of it. Do you want to be an active participant in the smoking process, chasing that perfect flavor? Or do you need a reliable tool that dries your meat perfectly while you’re busy elsewhere?
Masterbuilt 30-Inch: Consistent, Set-and-Forget Heat
When someone wants to make jerky without a lot of fuss, the Masterbuilt electric is often the first name that comes up. Its greatest strength is its simplicity. You plug it in, set the temperature on the digital panel, and let it work.
The internal thermostat is the key here. It cycles the heating element on and off to maintain a very stable temperature, which is critical for evenly dried jerky. You avoid the dreaded "case hardening," where the outside of the jerky gets tough and dry before the inside has a chance to cure properly. It takes the guesswork out of the most important variable.
The main drawback is the small wood chip loader. For a long, 8-hour jerky smoke, you’ll need to refill it a few times to keep a consistent level of smoke. But for the hobby farmer who needs to set a smoker and then go mend a fence or feed the chickens, the Masterbuilt’s reliability is its defining feature.
Bradley Smoker: Automated Wood Feed for Long Smokes
The Bradley takes the "set-and-forget" concept of an electric smoker and perfects it. Instead of a tray of chips you have to refill, it uses an automated system that feeds special wood "bisquettes" onto a burner every 20 minutes. This provides a consistent, clean smoke for up to nine hours without you ever having to open the door.
This is a game-changer for jerky. Maintaining consistent smoke and temperature without interruption is the secret to a great final product. Every time you open the door on another smoker, you lose heat and smoke, extending your drying time and creating fluctuations. The Bradley system eliminates that variable completely.
Of course, there’s a tradeoff. You’re locked into buying their proprietary bisquettes, which adds a recurring cost. But for folks who value their time and want absolute consistency from batch to batch, the Bradley’s automated system is a powerful tool. It turns a day-long process into something you can manage in the background.
Cuisinart COS-330: Insulated for Stable Temperatures
The Cuisinart electric smoker’s biggest advantage is less about fancy features and more about solid construction. It’s well-insulated, which means it holds its temperature incredibly well, even on a breezy or cool day. A less insulated smoker has to work harder, cycling its heating element more often and creating wider temperature swings.
For making jerky, that stability is everything. You’re operating at very low temperatures, where even a 10-degree swing can affect the drying process. The Cuisinart’s ability to lock in a temperature means your jerky dries evenly from edge to edge and from the top rack to the bottom.
This smoker is a straightforward, no-frills machine. It doesn’t have the automated wood feed of a Bradley, but it has three large racks, a simple temperature dial, and a build quality that just works. It’s a solid, efficient choice for someone who prioritizes a consistent drying environment above all else.
Camp Chef Smoke Vault: High Heat for Quick Drying
Enjoy effortless smoking with the Masterbuilt 30-inch Digital Electric Smoker. Digital controls and a side wood chip loader let you easily add wood-fired flavor without losing heat, while 710 square inches of cooking space accommodates large cuts of meat.
Switching over to gas, the Camp Chef Smoke Vault is a true workhorse. While it can hold the low temperatures needed for jerky, its real strength is its power and wide temperature range. That power translates into quick recovery. When you open the door to rotate racks or check on the jerky, a gas smoker like this gets back to your target temperature much faster than an electric one.
This model is built like a safe, and that sturdy construction helps it hold heat. You have precise control over the flame, allowing you to dial in that sweet spot around 170°F. And because you’re using real wood chunks, you get a deep, authentic smoke flavor that many people prefer.
The Smoke Vault also offers versatility. After you’re done with your low-and-slow jerky, you can crank the heat up to smoke a chicken or finish a brisket. It’s not just a jerky machine; it’s an all-around smoker, which is a big plus on a farm where every tool should serve more than one purpose.
Dyna-Glo Vertical Gas Smoker: Large Jerky Capacity
If you’re processing a significant amount of meat at once, capacity becomes the most important factor. The Dyna-Glo vertical gas smoker is all about maximizing space. Its tall, narrow design allows you to stack multiple large racks, letting you smoke 10, 15, or even 20 pounds of jerky in a single go.
Being a gas smoker, you get that great wood-smoke flavor and the power to fight a cold day. However, like most vertical gas smokers, it can have hot spots. You’ll need to learn your machine, rotating racks from top to bottom and front to back halfway through the smoke to ensure everything dries evenly. It requires a bit more hands-on attention than an electric model.
This isn’t a "set-and-forget" unit. You’ll be managing the flame, the wood chip box, and the position of the jerky. But when the goal is to turn a large harvest into shelf-stable food efficiently, the Dyna-Glo’s sheer volume is hard to beat.
Pit Boss 77435: Dual Burner Heat Control for Precision
The Pit Boss gas smoker brings a level of precision not always found in propane units. Its key feature is a dual-burner system. This allows you to fine-tune the heat output with much greater control than a single-burner smoker. For jerky, you can run one burner on its lowest setting to gently maintain that critical sub-200°F temperature.
This design helps minimize the temperature fluctuations that can plague some gas smokers. A stable heat source means a more consistent product, which is what we’re all after. You get the authentic flavor of burning wood chunks, but with a degree of control that starts to rival an electric smoker.
You still have to tend to it—checking the wood and making small adjustments to the flame—but the dual burners make that job much easier. It’s a great middle-ground for the person who wants the superior flavor of a gas smoker but also craves more precise temperature management.
Final Verdict: Matching Smoker to Your Jerky Style
There is no single "best" smoker for jerky. The right choice is the one that fits your workflow, your property, and your priorities. It’s a decision based on a simple set of questions.
Ask yourself this:
- How much time can I dedicate? If you need to set it and walk away for hours, an electric smoker like the Masterbuilt or Bradley is your best bet. If you enjoy the process of tending a fire and tweaking the smoke, a gas smoker like the Camp Chef or Pit Boss will be more rewarding.
- What’s more important: flavor or convenience? If you demand that deep, authentic wood smoke taste, you have to go with gas. If you’re happy with a good, consistent result and value ease-of-use above all, electric is the clear winner.
- How much jerky will I make at once? For huge batches from a whole deer or a quarter cow, the capacity of a large gas smoker like the Dyna-Glo is essential. For smaller, more frequent batches, any of the electric models will do just fine.
Ultimately, the old-timers are split for a reason. The purist who learned from his grandfather will swear by the flavor from a gas smoker. The practical farmer who has a hundred other things to do will praise the efficiency of his electric unit. Your job is to decide which of those two people you are.
Choosing a smoker is an investment in your self-sufficiency. It’s a tool for turning your hard work in the field or the pasture into food that will last. Whether you choose the convenience of electric or the flavor of gas, pick the one that you’ll actually use, and you’ll be enjoying the fruits of your labor for years to come.
