6 Best Composted Manure Spreaders For Small Farms On a Homestead Budget

Shoveling manure out of a wheelbarrow is a homesteading rite of passage, but it gets old fast. A manure spreader transforms one of the farm’s biggest chores into one of its most valuable assets. It turns a pile of waste into "black gold" for your pastures and gardens, saving your back and building your soil at the same time.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Choosing a Spreader for Your Homestead Needs

Finding the right spreader isn’t about buying the biggest one you can afford. It’s about matching the machine to your specific situation: your animals, your compost, and the vehicle you’ll use to pull it. A spreader that’s perfect for dry horse manure and an ATV might be useless for heavy, wet cattle manure behind a compact tractor.

The first big decision is ground-drive versus PTO-drive. Ground-drive models are simpler and cheaper, powered by the wheels turning, which is perfect for towing with an ATV or UTV. PTO (Power Take-Off) models hook up to your tractor’s drivetrain, giving you independent control over the spreading speed, which is a huge advantage for applying a precise, even layer.

Next, consider capacity and the material you’re spreading. Capacity is measured in bushels or cubic feet; a 25-bushel spreader is great for a couple of goats, but you’ll be making endless trips if you have five horses. More importantly, be honest about your compost. Fluffy, well-rotted material is easy on any machine, but wet, straw-filled manure requires aggressive beaters and a stronger drivetrain to avoid constant clogs.

The Newer Spreader 200: Ideal for Small Herds

The Newer Spreader is a common sight on small homesteads for a reason. It’s incredibly lightweight, simple to operate, and won’t rust. For someone with a few sheep, goats, or a pony, it’s often the perfect entry point into mechanical spreading.

Its main advantage is its construction. The poly-plastic tub is durable and completely resistant to the corrosive nature of manure, a problem that plagues steel spreaders. Being a ground-drive model, it can be pulled by almost anything—a good garden tractor, an ATV, or a UTV. You don’t need a tractor with a PTO, which opens it up to a lot of homesteaders.

The tradeoff is its light-duty nature. With a capacity of around 20 bushels, it’s not built for big jobs. It performs best with well-composted, fairly dry, and shredded material. Throwing in wet, clumpy, straw-heavy manure will likely lead to frustration and clogging. It’s a finesse tool, not a brute-force machine.

CMI Model 600: A Durable Ground-Drive Option

If you like the simplicity of a ground-drive spreader but need something tougher than a poly model, the CMI is a fantastic choice. Think of it as a heavy-duty version of the entry-level spreader, built with more steel and designed to take more abuse. It’s a true workhorse for those without a PTO tractor.

The CMI’s all-steel construction means it can handle heavier loads and tougher material without flexing or cracking. The apron chain and beater systems are generally simple and robust, designed for function over flash. This is the kind of machine that, with a little care, will last for decades.

Of course, steel requires maintenance. You must clean it out after each use to prevent the corrosive manure from eating away at the box and frame. It’s also heavier, so you’ll need a substantial UTV or a compact tractor to pull a full load, especially on hills. It strikes a great balance between durability and simplicity.

Agri-Fab Tow Spreader: Ultra-Budget Spreading

Let’s be clear: this is not a traditional manure spreader. An Agri-Fab tow-behind is a broadcast spreader, designed for seed and fertilizer. However, for the homesteader on an extreme budget, it can serve one very specific purpose: spreading perfectly composted, dry, and screened manure.

If you have the time to create a fine, uniform, almost pelletized compost, this tool can work for top-dressing a garden or small pasture. It hooks up to any lawn tractor and costs a fraction of a real manure spreader. It is, without a doubt, the cheapest mechanical "spreader" you can get.

The limitations, however, are severe. It will instantly clog with anything containing straw, clumps, rocks, or excessive moisture. Trying to force regular manure through it is a recipe for a broken spreader and a wasted afternoon. This is a budget hack for a niche application, not a versatile farm tool.

Millcreek 27+: Premium Build for Compact Tractors

Millcreek is a name that stands for quality in the spreader world, and their smaller models bring that reputation to the homestead scale. The 27+ is built like a tank but sized for compact tractors. This is the spreader for the homesteader who views their equipment as a long-term investment.

What you’re paying for is smart design and better materials. They often feature a thick poly floor that won’t rot out, mounted inside a heavy-gauge steel frame for rigidity. The beaters are more aggressive, the chains are heavier, and the overall fit and finish is a clear step up. Many models are available in either ground-drive or PTO, giving you options.

This isn’t the cheapest spreader, and it’s not trying to be. It’s for the person who has a solid compact tractor and wants a machine that can handle less-than-perfect manure without complaining. If you value reliability and plan to be farming for years to come, a Millcreek is a worthy investment.

Pequea 25G: A Reliable, Low-Maintenance Choice

Pequea has a well-earned reputation for building simple, reliable farm equipment, and their 25G manure spreader is no exception. This ground-drive model is a no-frills workhorse designed to do one job and do it well for a very long time. It’s a fantastic choice for the practical homesteader.

The key to the Pequea’s appeal is its focus on longevity. Many models feature galvanized steel sides, offering far better corrosion resistance than paint alone. The mechanicals are straightforward and easy to access, meaning you can actually perform maintenance and repairs yourself without needing a specialized shop.

With a 25-bushel capacity, it’s sized perfectly for a few horses, a small flock of sheep, or a family milk cow. It’s a spreader you buy for its dependability. It may not have the bells and whistles of more expensive models, but you can be confident it will be ready to work every spring.

Loyal Roth MSC80: Simple Design, Tough Results

When your "small farm" starts to feel a bit bigger, you need a spreader that can keep up. The Loyal Roth MSC80 is a PTO-driven spreader that offers a serious bump in capacity (around 64 bushels) while still being manageable for a larger homestead. It’s the bridge between hobby models and true agricultural equipment.

This machine is built for tougher jobs. The PTO drive gives you complete control over the application rate, allowing you to lay down a fine layer or a heavy one regardless of how fast you’re driving. The all-steel construction and aggressive beaters are designed to handle the heavy, wet manure produced by a small herd of cattle or a stable full of horses.

This is not a tool for an ATV. You need a compact utility tractor with a PTO and enough weight to handle a full load safely. It’s an investment for the homesteader who is serious about their soil fertility program and has the livestock numbers to justify a larger, more capable machine.

Maintaining Your Spreader for Long-Term Value

A manure spreader lives a hard life, dealing with corrosive materials and heavy, uneven loads. Neglecting maintenance is the fastest way to turn your valuable tool into a rusty lawn ornament. A little care goes a very long way.

The single most important thing you can do is clean it out after every single use. Scrape or hose it down to remove all leftover manure, which holds moisture against the steel and dramatically accelerates rust. This five-minute task can add years to your spreader’s life.

Beyond cleaning, follow a simple checklist before you put it away.

• Grease the bearings. All moving parts need lubrication to fight friction and moisture.
• Check the apron chain tension. Too loose and it can skip; too tight and it causes excessive wear on the sprockets and bearings.
• Inspect the beaters. Look for bent paddles or anything wrapped around the axle, especially after spreading bedding with twine in it.

Think of maintenance as protecting your investment. A well-maintained spreader will be ready to go when you need it, spreading valuable nutrients on your fields instead of sitting broken in the weeds.

Choosing the right spreader isn’t about finding the "best" one, but the right one for your homestead’s scale, budget, and needs. By matching the machine to your animals and your tractor, you turn a daily chore into a powerful engine for building soil fertility. A wise investment here pays you back every season with healthier pastures and more productive gardens.