6 Best Food Grade Butter Parchments For Cheese Making for Flawless Aging

You’ve spent weeks carefully nursing a wheel of cheddar, and now it’s time to wrap it for aging. The wrong paper can turn your masterpiece into a sweaty, moldy mess, undoing all your hard work. Choosing the right food-grade parchment isn’t just about wrapping; it’s a critical step in controlling moisture and developing the perfect rind.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

The Role of Parchment in Cheese Maturation

Wrapping a cheese for aging is a delicate balancing act. The goal is to let the cheese breathe without letting it dry out completely. A good parchment acts as a semi-permeable barrier, allowing excess moisture and gases like ammonia to escape while protecting the cheese from drying too quickly or picking up off-flavors from your cheese cave or refrigerator.

Think of it as a second skin for your cheese. For a hard cheese like a Gruyère or Parmesan, the paper’s job is primarily to keep the rind clean and prevent cracking from moisture loss. For a softer, bloomy-rind cheese like a Camembert, the paper must manage a much higher moisture level while allowing the white mold to flourish.

The material itself matters immensely. Standard wax paper or plastic wrap are poor choices because they trap moisture completely. This creates a swampy environment on the cheese surface, which is a perfect breeding ground for undesirable blue, green, and black molds, leading to spoilage and off-flavors. Proper cheese parchment is designed for breathability, which is the key to successful aging.

Formaticum Cheese Paper for Ideal Breathability

Formaticum is the specialist in the group, designed specifically for cheese. It’s a two-ply paper, combining a porous plastic inner layer with a breathable paper outer layer. This unique construction is engineered to wick away excess moisture while preventing the cheese from drying out.

This paper truly shines with soft-ripened and bloomy-rind cheeses. If you’re making a Brie or Camembert, Formaticum allows the rind to develop properly without getting slimy or suffocating the beneficial molds. It helps create that perfect, velvety rind everyone strives for.

The main tradeoff is cost and availability. You won’t find this at every grocery store, and it’s significantly more expensive than standard parchment. However, if you’ve invested time and high-quality milk into a delicate cheese, using a purpose-built paper is a worthwhile insurance policy against failure.

Reynolds Kitchens Parchment for Versatility

Reynolds parchment is the reliable workhorse you can find almost anywhere. While not specifically designed for cheese, its silicone-coated surface provides a non-stick barrier that works exceptionally well for many aging applications, particularly for hard cheeses.

This is my go-to for wrapping hard, aged cheeses like cheddar, Gouda, or even a simple farmhouse tomme. It’s sturdy enough to handle the weight and provides enough of a barrier to prevent the rind from drying into a rock-hard shell over several months. It’s predictable, affordable, and gets the job done without fuss.

Where it falls short is with very high-moisture cheeses. It doesn’t breathe as well as specialized papers, so you might see some surface moisture build-up on a younger, wetter cheese. For long-term aging of drier cheeses, however, its performance-to-cost ratio is unbeatable.

If You Care Unbleached Paper for Natural Aging

For cheesemakers who prioritize a natural, minimal-intervention approach, If You Care parchment is an excellent choice. It’s totally chlorine-free (TCF), unbleached, and compostable. This means you aren’t introducing any unwanted chemicals to the surface of your carefully crafted natural-rind cheese.

This paper is fantastic for cheeses where you want the natural rind to be the star. Think of a rustic clothbound cheddar or a washed-rind cheese. The paper protects the cheese from dust and pests in your cave while being gentle on the developing microflora of the rind.

The paper is slightly less non-stick than some silicone-coated competitors, but this is rarely an issue for hard cheeses. Its breathability is quite good, falling somewhere between standard parchment and specialized cheese paper. It’s a philosophical choice as much as a practical one, aligning your materials with your cheesemaking ethos.

King Arthur Parchment for High-Moisture Cheeses

King Arthur is a brand bakers trust for its quality, and that quality translates well to cheesemaking. This parchment is notably thick and strong, with excellent moisture resistance. It doesn’t get soggy or fall apart when faced with a bit of whey or butterfat.

This strength makes it ideal for younger, wetter cheeses that might weep a little during the initial stages of aging. A young Caerphilly or a freshly pressed cheddar can be wrapped in this without fear of the paper disintegrating. It holds its structure well, which is crucial when you’re handling and turning the cheese regularly.

While its breathability is standard for a silicone-coated parchment, its durability is its standout feature. If you’ve had issues with other papers tearing or becoming saturated, especially with washed-rind or blue cheeses that have a wetter surface, King Arthur’s paper is a significant step up in resilience.

Katbite Heavy Duty Paper for Durability

When you’re dealing with large, heavy wheels of cheese, you need a paper that won’t tear under the strain. Katbite’s heavy-duty parchment is thicker and more robust than almost any other consumer-grade option. This is the paper you use for a 10-pound wheel of cheddar destined for a year of aging.

The durability is the key selling point. It withstands the repeated handling, turning, and brushing that long-aged cheeses require. A flimsy paper can easily rip, exposing the cheese to contamination or rapid drying in one spot, creating an imbalance in the final product.

This paper is also great for cheeses with sharper corners or a rougher rind texture that might snag on thinner papers. While it may be overkill for a small, two-pound wheel, it provides peace of mind for your larger, more time-intensive projects. It’s about protecting your biggest investments of time and milk.

Zenlogy Parchment Rolls for Custom Sizing

Making cheese often means you’re not producing uniform sizes. One week you might make a small log of chèvre, and the next a large wheel of Gouda. Zenlogy parchment comes in wide rolls with a built-in slide cutter, offering unmatched flexibility.

The ability to cut a piece of parchment to the exact size you need is incredibly efficient. It eliminates waste and ensures you can get a clean, tight wrap on any shape of cheese without awkward folds or excessive overlap, which can trap moisture. The clean cut from the slide cutter is a small but satisfying detail that makes the wrapping process easier.

The paper quality itself is excellent—a solid, all-purpose parchment suitable for most hard cheeses. The primary benefit, however, is the format. For a hobbyist with limited space and a varied output, having one roll that can adapt to any project is a smart, practical solution.

Selecting the Right Paper for Your Cheese Type

There is no single "best" parchment; the right choice depends entirely on the cheese you are making. Matching the paper’s properties to the cheese’s needs is the final, crucial step in your cheesemaking process. Don’t just grab whatever is in the drawer.

Use this as a simple guide to make your decision:

• For bloomy or soft-ripened cheeses (Brie, Camembert): You need maximum breathability to manage moisture and support rind development. Formaticum is the clear winner here.
• For standard hard cheeses (Cheddar, Gouda, Tomme): A reliable, affordable, and versatile option is best. Reynolds or Zenlogy are perfect everyday choices.
• For natural-rind or washed-rind cheeses: You want a paper that’s gentle on the rind’s microflora and free of chemicals. If You Care is the philosophically and practically sound choice.
• For high-moisture or "weepy" cheeses: Strength and moisture resistance are paramount to prevent the paper from falling apart. King Arthur excels in these situations.
• For large, heavy, or long-aged wheels: Durability is non-negotiable to withstand handling and prevent tears. Katbite Heavy Duty is your safest bet.

Think about the journey your cheese is about to take in your aging space. A young, wet cheese has very different needs from an old, dry one. By selecting your paper with intention, you give your cheese the best possible environment to mature into something truly delicious.

Ultimately, the paper you choose is an active participant in the aging process, not just a passive wrapper. This small detail can make the difference between a good cheese and a flawless one. Choose wisely, and your patience will be rewarded.