7 Best Post Hole Spades For Raised Beds Old Farmers Swear By

You’ve built the perfect raised beds, filled them with beautiful soil, and now it’s time to install the corner posts for a trellis or a fence. You grab a standard shovel, plunge it in, and suddenly a quarter of your carefully mixed soil is heaved up and out of the box. There’s a better way, and it’s a tool that seasoned growers have relied on for generations.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why Old-Timers Prefer a Narrow Drain Spade

A drain spade, often called a post hole spade or transplanter, is not a shovel. A shovel is for moving loose material. A spade is for cutting into the ground. Its long, narrow blade is designed for surgical precision, not brute force excavation.

When you’re setting a 4×4 post in a raised bed, you don’t want to dig a wide, messy crater. You need a clean, vertical hole just big enough for the post and a bit of gravel. The narrow profile of a drain spade allows you to slice directly down, removing a neat plug of soil with minimal disturbance to the surrounding plant roots and soil structure. This is crucial in established beds where you’re adding supports mid-season.

This tool’s utility doesn’t stop at posts. It’s the perfect instrument for digging narrow trenches for irrigation lines or burying electrical conduit for lighting. It’s also unmatched for transplanting deep-rooted plants like comfrey or asparagus, allowing you to get well below the root ball without disrupting the entire bed. It’s a specialist tool that, once you own one, you’ll find a dozen uses for.

Bully Tools 92713: A Heavy-Duty Steel Workhorse

This is the spade you buy once and hand down to your grandkids. The Bully Tools drain spade is a single, solid piece of 14-gauge, American-made steel from the blade all the way through the D-handle. There are no weak points, no wooden handles to splinter, and no collars to loosen.

Its defining characteristic is its weight. This isn’t a lightweight, easy-to-swing tool; it’s a heavy-duty implement that uses its own mass to drive through tough ground. If you’re dealing with compacted clay, hidden rocks, or stubborn roots, the sheer heft of the Bully spade does half the work for you. You guide it, and gravity and steel do the rest.

The tradeoff for that power is fatigue. This is not the spade for a long day of light trenching if you’re not used to the work. But for the toughest jobs where other tools might bend or break, the Bully is the reliable workhorse you’ll be glad to have in the barn. It’s pure, simple function over form.

Fiskars D-Handle Spade for Ergonomic Digging

Fiskars approaches tool design from a different angle: the user’s body. Their D-handle spade is engineered to reduce the strain of digging. The shaft has a specific angle and the large D-handle is designed to keep your wrist in a neutral position, which makes a huge difference over the course of an afternoon.

This spade is significantly lighter than all-steel models, making it much easier to handle for repetitive tasks. The welded steel construction is plenty strong for most garden soils, from loamy beds to moderately compacted dirt. It’s a tool designed for efficiency and comfort, allowing you to work longer without paying for it with an aching back the next day.

However, it’s not a pry bar. While durable for digging, its lighter weight and construction mean it’s not the best choice for leveraging out large rocks or chopping through thick, woody roots. Think of it as the perfect spade for well-managed soil, where ergonomics and speed are more important than brute force.

Ames 2533600: A Classic Hardwood Handle Spade

There’s a reason tools were made with wood handles for centuries. A good hardwood handle, like the one on the Ames spade, has a feel that steel or fiberglass can’t replicate. It absorbs vibration and shock, providing a comfortable, secure grip that just gets better with age.

This is a traditionalist’s tool. It requires a bit of care—a coat of linseed oil on the handle once a year keeps it from drying out and splintering. In return, you get a tool that is balanced, effective, and connected to a long history of working the land. The steel blade is sturdy, and the connection to the handle is robust enough for serious work.

The potential downside is the wood itself. If you’re the type to leave tools out in the rain or use your spade as a fulcrum to pry out a boulder, a wood handle will eventually fail you. But for the farmer who maintains their equipment, the Ames offers a timeless blend of performance and classic design.

Spear & Jackson Traditional for English Garden Feel

If you value precision and a clean cut through the soil, the Spear & Jackson spade is worth a look. Often featuring a polished stainless steel head, this spade is designed to slide through heavy clay soils with less effort. Mud and sticky soil fall away from the blade easily, which means less time spent scraping it clean.

This brand embodies the English gardening tradition, where tools are often lighter and designed for more intricate work in established beds. The blade is sharp and the weatherproofed hardwood handle provides a classic feel and excellent control. It’s the perfect tool for carefully dividing perennials or planting bulbs in tight spaces without making a mess.

This is not a brute-force demolition tool. It’s a finely crafted instrument for a gardener who appreciates quality and works with a certain finesse. While strong enough for general use, its true value is in its ability to work cleanly and precisely in well-tended soil.

Corona AS 90324: Forged for Maximum Durability

Understanding the difference between a stamped blade and a forged blade is key here. A forged blade, like the one on the Corona drain spade, is made from a single piece of steel that’s heated and hammered into shape. This process creates a much stronger, more durable tool that resists bending and breaking under extreme stress.

This is the spade you grab when you know you’re going to hit something hard. Whether it’s rocky, unforgiving ground or a web of mature tree roots, the forged head can take the abuse. You can stomp on the turned steps, pry with confidence, and chop at roots without worrying about damaging the tool.

All that strength comes with a bit of extra weight and often a higher price tag. It’s likely overkill for someone working in sandy loam. But if your property is a constant battle against rocks and roots, investing in a forged spade like the Corona isn’t a luxury; it’s a necessity that will save you from breaking lesser tools.

Radius Garden 205 PRO: Easing Strain on Wrists

The most striking feature of the Radius Garden spade is the circular "O-handle." This patented design is a game-changer for anyone who experiences wrist or hand pain after a day of digging. It allows you to grip the tool in a variety of positions, using both hands in a more natural and powerful way.

This isn’t just a gimmick; it’s smart ergonomics. The design provides more leverage with less wrist strain, making it ideal for users with arthritis or anyone looking to minimize repetitive stress injuries. The resin-encased steel shaft and steel blade are plenty durable for garden tasks, but the real selling point is the comfort.

The non-traditional handle can take some getting used to, and it may feel odd at first if you’ve spent a lifetime using D-handles. But for those who prioritize comfort and joint health, the Radius Garden spade offers a modern solution to an age-old problem, allowing you to get the work done with significantly less pain.

Seymour S700: American-Made for Tough Soil Jobs

Seymour’s S700 series represents a modern approach to the classic spade, blending durability with practical design. The key feature is often a high-quality fiberglass handle. Fiberglass is an excellent compromise between wood and steel—it’s stronger and more weather-resistant than wood, but lighter and less jarring than solid steel.

This is a professional-grade tool built for daily use. It won’t rot, splinter, or dry out if accidentally left in the field. The cushioned grip adds comfort, and the tempered steel blade is designed to hold an edge and withstand the rigors of farm work. It’s a no-nonsense, reliable tool for someone who needs performance without the maintenance of wood or the extreme weight of all-steel models.

The "feel" of fiberglass isn’t for everyone; some traditionalists miss the feedback of a wood handle. But from a purely practical standpoint, a high-quality fiberglass handle like Seymour’s offers the best combination of strength, longevity, and low maintenance for the busy hobby farmer.

Ultimately, the best drain spade is the one that fits your body and your soil. A heavy steel spade is a lifesaver in rocky clay but a burden in sandy loam. The right tool feels like an extension of your own body, making the hard work of setting posts and digging trenches not just easier, but more satisfying.