6 Best Forge Hammers For Beginners Master Smiths Recommend

There’s a certain satisfaction that comes from shaping hot steel with nothing but a hammer and your own two hands. It connects you to a long line of folks who made and repaired their own tools out of necessity. But before you can make anything, you need the right hammer—the single most important tool in your shop.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Choosing Your First Essential Forging Hammer

Your first hammer is a big decision, but don’t overthink it. You’re looking for a reliable partner for the anvil, not a collector’s item. The most important factor for a beginner is weight. A hammer between 2 and 3 pounds (or about 1 to 1.5 kg) is the sweet spot. It’s heavy enough to move metal effectively but light enough that you won’t wear your arm out in ten minutes, allowing you to focus on control.

Look for a hammer with a traditional hickory handle. Wood absorbs shock far better than fiberglass or solid steel, which saves your joints over a long forging session. The hammer face should also be slightly "dressed" or crowned—meaning it has a very subtle curve. A perfectly flat face with sharp edges will leave ugly marks in your work, while a gentle crown helps create a smooth, clean finish.

Finally, you’ll see two main types recommended for beginners: the cross peen and the rounding hammer. A cross peen has a flat face for general forging and a wedge-shaped "peen" for spreading metal in one direction. A rounding hammer has one flat face and one domed, round face, which is incredibly versatile for moving metal in any direction. You only need one to start, and either is a fantastic choice.

Picard German Pattern Blacksmith’s Hammer

When you picture a classic blacksmith’s hammer, you’re probably thinking of something like the Picard. This is a German-style cross peen hammer, and it’s been a standard in forges for generations for a good reason. It’s a no-nonsense tool built for work.

The Picard hammers are known for their excellent balance and high-quality steel. The head has a slightly squared, crowned face on one side and a clean, well-defined cross peen on the other. This design feels natural in the hand, making it easier to learn how to strike accurately and consistently. It’s a tool that won’t fight you.

For a beginner, a 1000g or 1250g (about 2.2 to 2.75 lbs) Picard is a fantastic investment. It’s a professional-grade tool that you won’t outgrow. It will serve you just as well for making simple hooks and gate latches as it will for more complex projects down the road.

Estwing Sure Strike: A Reliable Cross Peen

You’ll find Estwing hammers in just about every hardware store, and their reputation for toughness is well-earned. The Sure Strike blacksmith hammer is forged from a single piece of steel, meaning the head and handle are one solid unit. You will never have to worry about the head flying off.

This single-piece construction is its biggest strength and its main tradeoff. It’s incredibly durable, but the steel handle transmits more vibration to your arm than a wood handle does. Some smiths don’t mind it, especially with the shock-dampening grip, while others find it fatiguing over long sessions.

If your top priority is durability and you want a hammer you can buy locally without much fuss, the Estwing is a solid contender. It’s a workhorse that can take a beating, making it a reliable, if less traditional, starting point.

Vaughan & Bushnell Sub-Zero Cross Peen

Vaughan is another one of those legacy American toolmakers that just gets it right. Their Sub-Zero Cross Peen hammer is a testament to straightforward, high-quality manufacturing. The "Sub-Zero" name refers to a heat-treating process that results in a very tough, durable tool steel.

This hammer feels solid and well-balanced, with a nicely finished hickory handle that fits comfortably in the hand. The faces are typically well-dressed right out of the box, saving you a bit of prep work. It’s the kind of tool that feels like an old friend from the first swing.

Like the Picard, this is a professional-quality hammer that a beginner can grow into. It’s a reliable tool for any general forging task, from drawing out tapers for a driveway gate hinge to shaping a new handle for the wood-splitter. It represents a great balance of quality, performance, and price.

Peddinghaus Swedish Style Cross Peen Hammer

The Swedish style hammer looks a little different from its German cousin, and it works a little differently, too. Peddinghaus, now owned by Ridgid, makes one of the most respected versions. The faces are often more rounded, and the peen is narrower and more pronounced.

This design excels at moving metal quickly and efficiently. The rounded face concentrates the force of your blow into a smaller area, making it fantastic for drawing out steel (making it longer and thinner). Many smiths feel the Swedish pattern allows for more control and finesse once you get used to it.

The learning curve might be a tiny bit steeper than with a German pattern hammer because of the crowned faces, but the payoff is significant. If you know you’ll be doing a lot of work that involves shaping and drawing out material, a Peddinghaus is an exceptional choice that will reward your developing skill.

NC Tool Co. Rounding Hammer for Versatility

The rounding hammer is a more modern design that has become incredibly popular, and the version from NC Tool Co. is a favorite among farriers and blacksmiths alike. Instead of a peen, it has one flat face and one heavily rounded, ball-like face. This simple change makes it a multi-tool in your hand.

The flat face works like any other hammer for planishing (smoothing) and general forging. The rounded face, however, is a game-changer. By changing the angle of your strike, you can use it to spread metal in any direction, essentially doing the work of both a cross peen and a straight peen. It’s incredibly efficient for initial shaping.

For a beginner who can only afford one hammer, the NC Rounding Hammer is arguably the most versatile option. It allows you to perform a huge range of tasks without ever having to switch tools. It’s a smart choice if you see yourself exploring everything from tool making to decorative ironwork.

Council Tool Blacksmith’s Cross Peen Hammer

Council Tool has been making high-quality striking tools in the USA for over a century, and their blacksmith hammer is a perfect example of their craft. It’s a classic American cross peen pattern—simple, effective, and built to last a lifetime.

What sets the Council Tool hammer apart is the attention to detail. The head is forged from high-quality tool steel, the heat treat is spot-on, and it comes hung on a premium hickory handle. It’s a tool made by people who understand what a good hammer should feel like.

There are no gimmicks here. It’s just an honest, well-made hammer that does its job exceptionally well. For a beginner looking for a reliable, American-made tool that embodies traditional quality, the Council Tool hammer is an excellent and dependable choice.

Hammer Maintenance and Proper Striking Technique

A good hammer is an investment, and a little care goes a long way. The most important task is "dressing" the faces. Use sandpaper or a file to slightly round any sharp edges on both the flat face and the peen. Sharp edges act like little chisels, leaving dings and cold shuts in your work. Keep the faces smooth and free of any dents, as any imperfection on the hammer will be transferred directly to your steel. Periodically, rub some linseed oil into the hickory handle to keep it from drying out and cracking.

More important than the hammer itself is how you swing it. Don’t try to muscle the steel into submission. A good hammer swing comes from the elbow and shoulder, not the wrist. You want to lift the hammer and let its weight do the work on the downswing. Focus on accuracy over power.

Your goal is to deliver consistent, square blows to the hot metal. A glancing blow is inefficient and can damage your workpiece. Practice on a piece of scrap or even a block of wood to develop your muscle memory. Good technique will save your arm, improve your work, and make forging a pleasure rather than a chore.

Ultimately, the best hammer is the one that feels balanced in your hand and allows you to strike true. Pick one of these recommendations, spend some time getting to know it, and then get to work. The skill is in the smith, not just the tool.