6 Best Grommet Pliers For Hobby Farmers That Prevent Tarp Tears

There’s nothing more frustrating than the sound of a tarp ripping in a storm, especially when it’s the one covering your seasoned firewood or a stack of hay. A cheap, torn-out grommet is often the culprit, turning a perfectly good cover into a useless piece of plastic. Investing in a quality set of grommet pliers isn’t about adding another tool to the shed; it’s about making your essential gear more reliable and saving money in the long run.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Choosing the Right Pliers for Farm Tarp Repair

Not all grommet tools are created equal. The flimsy pliers from a craft store are designed for paper and thin fabric, and they will fail spectacularly against the thick vinyl of a farm tarp. You need a tool built for leverage and durability.

The first thing to consider is the material you’re working with. A standard blue poly tarp is much thinner than a heavy-duty silver canvas or a custom-made shelter cover. The thicker the material, the more force you’ll need to set the grommet securely. Also, pay attention to grommet size. Most farm tarps use a #4 grommet, which has a 1/2-inch hole, so make sure your tool is compatible with that size.

The biggest mistake is focusing only on the tool and ignoring the grommets themselves. The grommets included in cheap kits are often thin steel that will rust in a single season, staining your tarp and failing quickly. Always opt for solid brass or stainless steel grommets for any outdoor application. They cost a little more but will outlast the tarp itself.

General Tools 71264: A Reliable All-in-One Kit

If you’re looking for one solid tool to keep in the truck or toolbox for general repairs, this is it. The General Tools kit is a fantastic balance of functionality, durability, and price. It’s the kind of tool that handles 80% of the grommet repairs you’ll face on a small farm.

The kit typically includes the pliers, a hole punch, and a starter supply of 1/2-inch grommets. The pliers have long handles that provide good leverage, making it relatively easy to crimp a grommet through a standard poly tarp without massive hand strength. It’s a self-contained solution, so you have everything you need for a quick field repair.

This isn’t the tool for high-volume work or extremely thick canvas, however. The force it generates is adequate for most tarps, but it will struggle with multiple layers of heavy material. Think of it as the perfect tool for fixing the cover on the woodpile, patching a chicken run roof, or adding a tie-down point to a piece of shade cloth. It gets the job done reliably without breaking the bank.

C.S. Osborne No. 500 for Heavy-Duty Canvas

When you move beyond standard tarps into serious materials like heavy canvas, oilcloth, or reinforced vinyl for animal shelters, you need more power. The C.S. Osborne No. 500 isn’t a pair of pliers; it’s a professional-grade grommet setter that you use with a mallet. This is the tool for creating permanent, load-bearing anchor points.

The system is simple but incredibly effective. You first punch a hole in your material using a separate cutting die, then place the two-piece grommet and use the setter die and a heavy hammer or mallet to lock it in place. The force of a mallet blow is far greater than what you can generate by squeezing pliers, resulting in a perfectly rolled, incredibly strong grommet that simply will not pull out.

The trade-off is speed and convenience. It’s a two-step process that requires a solid work surface, so it’s not ideal for a quick fix out in the pasture. But for projects where failure is not an option—like a winter shelter wall or a custom cover for expensive equipment—the C.S. Osborne provides a level of security that no plier-style tool can match.

VEVOR Hand Press: For High-Volume Grommet Work

If you find yourself setting dozens of grommets at a time, a hand press is a game-changer. This is for the hobby farmer who is making their own low tunnels, outfitting a market stand with custom banners, or fabricating multiple equipment covers. Repetitive squeezing on standard pliers gets old fast.

A hand press like the ones from VEVOR uses a long lever arm to generate massive mechanical advantage. Setting a grommet becomes an almost effortless, single-pull motion. This not only saves your hands but also ensures every single grommet is set with perfect, consistent pressure. Consistency is key to preventing weak points that can tear under stress.

This tool represents an investment in efficiency. It’s heavier, less portable, and more expensive than pliers. You’ll also need to buy the correct die set for each size of grommet you plan to use. But if grommeting is a regular part of your farm’s workflow, the speed and professional-quality results make it well worth the cost.

CO-Z Grommet Pliers: Best for Lighter Materials

Sometimes, brute force is the wrong approach. For lighter materials like shade cloth, insect netting, or lightweight row covers, a heavy-duty tool can actually damage the fabric around the hole. This is where a lighter-touch tool like the CO-Z grommet pliers shines.

These pliers are designed for ease of use. They are often lighter and require less hand strength to operate. A key feature on many models is the use of magnets in the jaws to hold the grommet and washer in place before you crimp. This small detail is a huge help, preventing fumbling and ensuring the pieces are perfectly aligned.

Be realistic about its limitations. This is not the tool for a heavy-duty vinyl tarp. Attempting to set a grommet in thick material will likely result in a weak crimp or even damage to the tool itself. But for those delicate, high-value fabrics where a clean, gentle set is paramount, this tool is the perfect choice.

Lord & Hodge 1772-P: Classic American-Made Tool

There’s something to be said for a simple tool that is built to do one job and do it for a lifetime. The Lord & Hodge 1772-P is exactly that. Made of forged steel in the USA, it’s a no-frills, heavy-duty set of pliers that feels like an heirloom tool the moment you pick it up.

You won’t find this in a fancy kit with a plastic case and a hundred low-quality grommets. It’s just the tool, built to an uncompromising standard. The action is smooth and the leverage is immense, allowing you to set 1/2-inch brass grommets into thick material with confidence. You will need a separate hole punch, but that’s part of the philosophy: use the best dedicated tool for each step of the job.

This is for the person who values quality and durability over all-in-one convenience. It’s a tool you’ll buy once and hand down to the next generation. For setting strong, reliable grommets year after year without fuss, the Lord & Hodge is a classic for a reason.

ABN Grommet Kit: Great Value for Multiple Sizes

On a small farm, you never know what you’ll need to fix next. One day it might be a large tarp, the next a smaller feed bag or a canvas bucket. The ABN Grommet Kit is an excellent value proposition for someone who needs versatility without wanting to buy three separate tools.

The main advantage of this kit is the inclusion of multiple interchangeable die sets. This allows you to set various grommet sizes (often 1/4", 3/8", and 1/2") with a single pair of pliers. For a general-purpose workshop tool, this flexibility is incredibly useful and cost-effective.

While it may not have the bombproof construction of a Lord & Hodge or the specialized ease of a CO-Z, it’s a competent jack-of-all-trades. The build quality is more than sufficient for occasional use across different tasks. If you want one kit to handle a wide range of potential repairs around the farm, the ABN kit offers fantastic utility for the price.

How to Set Grommets Perfectly to Avoid Tarp Tears

The best tool in the world won’t prevent a tear if you install the grommet incorrectly. The most common failure happens when a grommet is set into a single layer of tarp material. The plastic or canvas simply doesn’t have enough structural integrity to resist the pulling force of a rope or bungee cord.

The solution is simple: always reinforce the edge. Before you even think about punching a hole, fold the edge of the tarp over on itself to create a double-thick hem at least two inches wide. For ultimate strength, especially on a corner, you can even tuck a small piece of scrap canvas or nylon webbing inside the fold. This creates a robust foundation that distributes the load.

Once your hem is folded, punch your hole through both layers. Place the grommet pieces and ensure they are seated properly. Squeeze the pliers with firm, steady pressure until you feel the metal fully compress. A perfect set will have a smooth, rolled curl on the back, with no sharp edges or cracks. This clean finish isn’t just for looks—it’s a sign of a strong, secure grommet that will hold fast when the wind picks up.

Choosing the right grommet pliers is a small decision that pays big dividends in reliability. It’s about turning a point of failure into a point of strength. A well-set grommet protects your tarps, and in turn, your tarps protect your valuable feed, equipment, and shelters from the elements.