6 Best Cedar Compost Bins For Reducing Waste Old Farmers Swear By

You’ve just finished clearing out the garden beds for the season, leaving a mountain of spent tomato vines, corn stalks, and bolted lettuce. Your first instinct might be to haul it to the edge of the property, but every scrap of that organic matter is black gold in the making. Turning farm and kitchen waste into rich, living soil is one of the most satisfying jobs on a homestead, and the right compost bin makes all the difference.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why Cedar is the Gold Standard for Compost Bins

When it comes to building something that lives outdoors and spends its life holding damp, decomposing material, your choice of wood matters. Cedar is the undisputed champion for compost bins for a few simple, powerful reasons. Its natural oils make it inherently resistant to rot and decay, which is exactly what you want when your bin’s job is to encourage decomposition.

Unlike pressure-treated lumber, which can leach chemicals into your precious compost, cedar is completely natural and safe for organic gardening. It also repels many of the insects that might otherwise take up residence in your pile. While a plastic bin might seem like a maintenance-free option, it can become brittle and crack after a few years of sun and freezing temperatures.

A well-built cedar bin isn’t just a tool; it’s a piece of garden furniture that ages gracefully. It will weather to a handsome silvery-gray over time, blending into the landscape far better than a black plastic drum. It’s a long-term investment in a system that works with nature, not against it.

Greenes Fence Cedar Bin: A Farmstead Classic

You’ve seen this design a hundred times for a reason: it works. The Greenes Fence bin is the quintessential, no-frills square composter. It’s typically built with interlocking boards that stack up, often requiring no tools for assembly. This is simplicity at its best.

This single-bin system is perfect for a smaller homestead or for someone just getting serious about composting. It holds a surprising amount of material, from kitchen scraps to chicken bedding and garden waste. Its open-slat design provides good airflow, which is critical for healthy, aerobic decomposition that doesn’t smell foul.

The main tradeoff here is efficiency. With a single pile, you’re either doing "continuous" composting (adding to the top, harvesting from the bottom) or batch composting (building a full pile and letting it sit). Both methods are slower than a multi-bin system. Turning the pile requires a bit of muscle, as you’ll need to fork material out and back in to mix it properly.

Gardener’s Supply Co. 3-Bin Cedar System

When you’re ready to move from simply getting rid of waste to actively producing a steady supply of high-quality compost, the 3-bin system is the way to go. This is the workhorse of serious gardeners and small farmers. The logic is flawless: one bin for adding fresh materials, a center bin for the active, "hot" pile, and a third bin for curing finished compost.

This setup transforms composting from a passive activity into an efficient, manageable process. When the first bin is full, you turn its contents into the empty center bin, which ignites the decomposition process. While that pile is cooking, you start filling the first bin again. It creates a continuous, circular flow that ensures you always have compost in every stage of development.

Of course, a 3-bin system is a significant commitment in both space and cost. It’s not for the casual gardener with a few bags of leaves. This is for the hobby farmer who needs a reliable source of soil amendment for large vegetable beds, fruit trees, and new plantings. It’s an investment in your soil’s long-term fertility.

Yardfully Wood Compost Bin for Easy Assembly

Let’s be honest: sometimes you just need a solution that works right now, without a complicated project. The Yardfully bin and others like it are designed for exactly that. They often feature clever dovetail joints or interlocking corners that let you assemble the entire bin in minutes, without digging for a single screw or nail.

This focus on ease of assembly doesn’t mean it’s flimsy. These bins are typically made from thick, solid cedar boards that create a sturdy structure once put together. The design is clean and functional, providing the essential airflow and containment needed for a healthy compost pile.

This is the perfect choice for someone who values their time as much as their soil. If you’d rather spend your Saturday planting than building, this is your bin. It gets you up and running immediately, so you can start turning waste into wealth without any delay.

Forest-Built Expandable Cedar Composter

The needs of a homestead are never static. One year you have two goats, the next you have five. Your garden doubles in size. An expandable composter is built for this reality. These modular systems allow you to start with a single bin and add more units as your need for compost capacity grows.

Typically, these systems use shared posts, allowing you to add a second or third bin more affordably than buying a whole new setup. The front slats are often removable, which is a game-changer for turning the pile. Instead of lifting material up and over the wall, you can simply remove a few boards and easily access the pile with a pitchfork.

This flexibility is invaluable. You can adapt your composting system to the seasonal flows of your farm—a huge influx of soiled bedding in the spring, mountains of vines in the fall. It’s a system that grows with you, not one you outgrow.

Earth-Wise Slatted Bin for Superior Airflow

All compost piles need oxygen. Without it, you get a slimy, stinky, anaerobic mess instead of rich, earthy humus. The Earth-Wise bin, and others with a heavily slatted design, are engineered specifically to maximize airflow from all four sides.

The gaps between the boards allow air to penetrate deep into the pile, feeding the aerobic bacteria and fungi that do the heavy lifting of decomposition. This leads to a hotter, faster-working pile that breaks down materials more efficiently. A hotter pile also has the added benefit of killing more weed seeds and potential pathogens.

While you might lose a tiny bit of fine material through the gaps, the tradeoff is well worth it. This bin is for the person who wants to optimize the biological process. If you’ve ever struggled with a slow or smelly pile, a lack of air was likely the culprit, and this design is the solution.

Homestead Cedar Tumbler for Faster Results

For those short on space or seeking a more contained, pest-proof system, a cedar tumbler is an excellent alternative to a static bin. By enclosing the compost in a drum that you can rotate, you can mix and aerate the pile with a few simple turns. This frequent aeration dramatically speeds up the composting process, often yielding finished compost in a matter of weeks rather than months.

The enclosed design is its biggest advantage. It keeps out rodents, raccoons, and the neighbor’s dog. It also holds in heat and moisture more effectively, further accelerating decomposition. This makes it a great option for urban or suburban homesteads where open piles might be a concern.

The primary limitation is capacity. Tumblers are batch systems—you fill them, let the contents process, and then empty them. You can’t continuously add material like you can with a 3-bin system. They are best suited for managing kitchen scraps and smaller amounts of garden trimmings, not the large volumes of waste from a bigger operation.

Maintaining Your Cedar Bin for a Long Life

A cedar compost bin is a tough piece of equipment, but a little care will ensure it lasts for decades. The most important thing you can do is keep its feet dry. Place the bin on a foundation of gravel, bricks, or patio stones to allow air to circulate underneath and prevent the base boards from sitting in constant contact with wet soil.

Resist the urge to paint or seal it with a heavy varnish. Cedar needs to breathe, and sealing it can trap moisture, accelerating rot instead of preventing it. If you feel compelled to treat it, use a natural, non-toxic, penetrating oil like pure tung oil or raw linseed oil, and apply it only to the exterior surfaces.

Beyond that, maintenance is minimal. Once a year, check that any hardware is tight. The wood will turn a lovely silver-gray, which is a natural patina, not a sign of decay. Your cedar bin is a living part of your garden’s ecosystem; treat it as such, and it will serve you well for a very long time.

Choosing the right compost bin isn’t just a practical decision; it’s a statement about how you value your resources. By turning every last leaf and peel into nutrient-rich soil, you’re closing the loop and building a more resilient, self-sufficient homestead from the ground up.