6 Best Durable Cheese Presses With Springs For Small Farms Old-Timers Trust

There’s a quiet satisfaction in seeing a perfect wheel of cheese emerge from the press after a long day’s work. It represents more than just food; it’s the culmination of careful milking, patient stirring, and precise technique. For many of us on small farms, a reliable spring press isn’t just a tool, it’s a partner in turning good milk into great cheese.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why Spring Presses Endure on the Homestead

You can find all sorts of fancy, modern cheese presses, but the simple spring-loaded models remain a fixture in homestead kitchens for a reason. Their beauty lies in their simplicity. There are no weights to lose, no hydraulic fluid to leak, and no power cords to run.

The core function of a spring press is to provide consistent, hands-off pressure. Once you tighten the springs to the desired pressure, they maintain that force as the whey is expelled and the cheese compacts. This "set it and forget it" nature is invaluable when you have a dozen other chores calling your name. You aren’t tied to the kitchen, repeatedly tightening a screw press as the curds settle.

This reliability is why old-timers trust them. A well-made spring press is a lifetime investment. It’s a mechanical tool that does its job without fuss, year after year, turning the fruits of your labor into something that can be aged and enjoyed for months to come.

The NECS T-Handle Press for Consistent Pressure

New England Cheesemaking Supply (NECS) has been a go-to for home cheesemakers for decades, and their T-handle press shows why. It’s a thoughtfully designed piece of equipment built for precision. The T-handle gives you excellent leverage, making it easy to dial in the exact pressure you need without straining.

What really sets this press apart are the calibrated springs. The springs are marked with pressure indicators, taking the guesswork out of pressing. When a recipe calls for 50 pounds of pressure, you simply tighten the handle until the indicator lines up with the 50 lb mark. This level of accuracy is crucial for achieving consistent texture, especially with hard cheeses like cheddar or parmesan.

This press is ideal for the serious hobbyist who follows specific recipes and wants repeatable results. It bridges the gap between a basic homemade press and more complex commercial equipment. It’s sturdy, easy to use, and built to help you perfect your craft.

TSM Stainless Steel Press for Easy Sanitation

While traditional wooden presses have a certain charm, there’s a strong case to be made for stainless steel, especially if you ever plan to sell your cheese. The TSM (The Sausage Maker) press is a workhorse designed with food safety as a top priority. Its all-stainless-steel construction means it can be thoroughly cleaned and sanitized, leaving no place for unwanted bacteria to hide.

Wood is porous and can, over time, harbor milk solids and bacteria if not meticulously cared for. With stainless steel, a hot water rinse and a quick wipe with sanitizer is all it takes. This peace of mind is worth a lot, especially when you’re working with raw milk or making aged cheeses where wild molds are a constant concern.

The TSM press is also incredibly durable. It won’t warp, crack, or absorb odors over time. It’s a heavier, more substantial unit, which provides a stable platform for pressing. For the small farmer who values efficiency and uncompromising cleanliness, this press is a top contender.

The Stoltzfus Hardwood Press for Large Batches

When you graduate from two-gallon batches to five or even ten gallons of milk, you need a press that can handle the volume. The Stoltzfus family has been making robust, Amish-crafted equipment for years, and their hardwood cheese press is built for serious production. Made from solid maple, this press is a piece of functional art.

The key here is its size and strength. A larger wheel of cheese requires significantly more pressure to expel whey from the center, and the Stoltzfus press is engineered for that. It features heavy-duty springs and a large frame capable of accommodating molds up to 10 inches in diameter. This isn’t a press for a small wheel of chèvre; it’s for making a wheel of Swiss or Colby that will feed a family through the winter.

Choosing a press like this is a commitment to a larger scale of cheesemaking. It takes up more space and represents a bigger investment, but it delivers the power and capacity needed for self-sufficiency. It’s the kind of tool that gets passed down through generations.

Hoegger Supply’s Compact Press for Small Spaces

Not everyone is working with a commercial-grade kitchen. For many homesteaders, cheesemaking happens on a crowded counter right next to the sourdough starter. Hoegger Supply, long trusted by goat owners and smallholders, offers a compact press that understands this reality perfectly.

This press is designed for smaller batches, typically from one to three gallons of milk. Its smaller footprint means it can be easily stored in a cabinet or on a pantry shelf when not in use. It provides all the necessary function of a spring press without demanding a dedicated workspace.

Don’t mistake its smaller size for a lack of capability. It provides ample pressure for most common homestead cheeses, from feta to gouda. It’s the perfect starting press for someone just getting into hard cheeses or for the farmer who only has a few milking animals and values efficiency and space-saving design.

The Homesteader’s Basic Spring Press Kit

There’s a deep-seated instinct in many farmers to build it themselves if they can. For those folks, a basic spring press kit is the perfect solution. These kits typically provide the essential, hard-to-source components: the calibrated springs, the food-grade follower (pressure plate), and sometimes a set of plans.

The appeal is twofold: cost and customization. You can save a fair bit of money by building the frame yourself from scrap lumber you already have on the farm. More importantly, you can build it to your exact specifications—taller for bigger molds, wider for a different setup, or designed to fit a specific nook in your kitchen.

Of course, there are tradeoffs. This route requires basic woodworking skills, a few tools, and the time to put it all together. But for the homesteader who finds satisfaction in self-reliance, building your own press from a kit is a rewarding project that results in a tool perfectly suited to your needs.

Calibrating Springs for Accurate Pressing

A spring press is only as good as its pressure reading. While some presses come pre-marked, many don’t, and even those can lose accuracy over time. Knowing how to calibrate your springs is a fundamental skill for consistent cheesemaking.

The process is simpler than it sounds. All you need is a ruler and a basic bathroom scale. Place the press on the scale, making sure the follower (the plate that pushes on the cheese mold) is what’s touching the scale’s surface. Zero out the scale.

Now, begin tightening the T-handle or knobs. As you tighten, watch the scale and the springs.

• When the scale reads 25 pounds, use a permanent marker to make a mark on the press rod right at the edge of the spring plate.
• Continue tightening until the scale reads 50 pounds and make another mark.
• Repeat this for 75 pounds, 100 pounds, and so on, up to the maximum pressure you anticipate using.

You now have a permanently calibrated press. When a recipe calls for 50 pounds of pressure, you just tighten until the spring plate aligns with your 50-pound mark. This simple, ten-minute task transforms a good press into a precision instrument, ensuring your cheese texture is intentional, not accidental.

Ultimately, the best cheese press is the one that fits your scale, your space, and your cheesemaking ambitions. Whether it’s a gleaming stainless model or a homemade wooden frame, a reliable spring press is a gateway to a deeper level of craft. It empowers you to create something truly special from the simple gift of fresh milk.