6 Best Hay Bale Wagons For Market Gardens Perfect for Small Acreage

There’s a moment every season when you realize you’ve underestimated a simple task, and for many of us, it’s moving hay. That stack of 50 square bales for the goats or for mulching the garlic beds doesn’t seem like much until you’re carrying them one by one across a muddy field. A good hay wagon isn’t just for big farms; for a market garden or small homestead, it’s a back-saver and a massive time-saver that pays for itself in a single afternoon.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Choosing a Wagon for Your Small-Scale Hay Needs

The right wagon for a small acreage isn’t the biggest one you can find. It’s the one that fits through your gates, navigates the tight turns between garden beds, and can be pulled by your existing compact tractor or ATV. Forget the massive 20-foot wagons you see on commercial farms. You’re looking for something that can handle 30 to 70 square bales, serve double-duty hauling compost or firewood, and doesn’t require a dedicated barn for storage.

Think about versatility first. Will this wagon only move hay twice a year, or can you use it to haul harvest crates, fencing supplies, or bags of soil amendment? A wagon that serves multiple purposes is a much better investment of your limited funds and space. The best tool on a small farm is one that does three jobs well.

Consider your terrain. A flat, manicured lawn has different needs than a rolling pasture with dips and ruts. The stability of the wagon, determined by its width and axle type, becomes critical when you’re moving a top-heavy load of hay across uneven ground. A tippy wagon is more than an inconvenience; it’s a safety hazard and a frustrating waste of time.

Country MF T-300: Versatile Compact Hauler

This little wagon is more of a multi-purpose trailer, and that’s its greatest strength. At around 3.5 by 6 feet, it’s perfectly sized for navigating the narrow pathways of a market garden or a wooded homestead. It’s not a dedicated hay wagon, but it can easily handle 20-25 square bales, which is often plenty for mulching a large garden or feeding a few small animals through the winter.

What makes the T-300 stand out is its dump-cart functionality and removable sides. Hauling hay in the morning? Keep the sides on. Need to move a load of loose compost or mulch in the afternoon? Pull a pin, and it becomes a dump trailer. This adaptability is exactly what a small-scale operation needs, turning one piece of equipment into a solution for many different jobs. It’s ideal for the farmer who needs a workhorse for everything, not just a specialist for one task.

E-Z Trail 672: A Durable, No-Frills Workhorse

If you want a true, traditional hay wagon in a compact size, the E-Z Trail 672 is your answer. This is simply a running gear—the frame, axles, and wheels—that’s built to last for generations. It’s known for its exceptional tracking, meaning the rear wheels follow the front wheels almost perfectly, which is a massive advantage when maneuvering around buildings or through tight gates.

The beauty of the 672 is its simplicity and durability. There are no complex hydraulics or unnecessary features to break. You buy the running gear and build your own wooden deck on top, customizing it to the exact size you need, typically around 6 by 12 feet. This setup can comfortably and safely handle 70-80 square bales. This is the buy-it-for-life option for the farmer who values reliability over bells and whistles. It’s a straightforward tool that does its job exceptionally well, year after year.

Agri-Fab 45-0554: A Budget-Friendly Cart Option

Let’s be clear: this is a heavy-duty garden cart, not a traditional hay wagon. But for the market gardener with just a quarter-acre in production or someone on a very tight budget, it can be the perfect fit. It’s an enormous step up from a wheelbarrow and can be pulled by a lawn tractor or an ATV.

With a 1,000-pound capacity, you can stack about 10-15 square bales on it, which might be all you need for a small flock of sheep or for mulching your tomato rows. Its steel construction is reasonably durable for its price point, and the single-lever dump release is useful for moving soil or gravel. Don’t expect it to handle heavy-duty farm work, but if your primary problem is just getting materials from your truck to the garden, this cart offers incredible value and saves a lot of manual labor.

Pequea 686: Higher Capacity for Growing Farms

The Pequea 686 represents the next step up. It’s a well-built running gear designed for those who have outgrown the smaller carts but don’t need a massive commercial wagon. It’s a great middle-ground, typically fitted with a 7 by 14-foot deck, giving you the capacity for around 100-120 square bales. This is perfect for the growing homestead that has added more livestock or expanded its mulching program.

This model offers a good balance of size and maneuverability. It’s sturdy enough to feel safe and stable with a full load but not so large that it becomes cumbersome. For the market gardener who is starting to think about efficiency at a slightly larger scale, the Pequea provides that extra capacity without demanding a larger tractor or a huge storage space. It’s the right choice when you know your needs are consistently growing beyond what a simple cart can handle.

H&S 4RW: A Solid Running gear Foundation

Much like the E-Z Trail, the H&S 4RW is a running gear that provides a rock-solid foundation for a custom wagon. H&S has a reputation for building tough, reliable farm equipment, and their running gears are no exception. This model is a simple, effective choice for someone who wants to build their own deck and needs a dependable chassis to put it on.

The key advantage here is flexibility. By starting with just the running gear, you control the final product. You can build a flat deck for hay, add short stake sides for hauling firewood, or even design a custom rack for moving harvest bins. This DIY approach allows you to create a wagon perfectly tailored to the unique demands of your property. It’s an excellent path for the hands-on farmer who sees equipment as a starting point for a customized solution.

Horst 205: Tandem Axles for Stable Transport

For those of us farming on hills, slopes, or bumpy ground, stability is everything. The Horst 205 running gear introduces a key feature for this: tandem walking beam axles. Instead of a single axle in the rear, it has two axles paired together that "walk" over uneven terrain. This keeps the wagon bed much more level and dramatically reduces the risk of tipping with a tall, heavy load.

This feature is a game-changer for safety and peace of mind. If you’ve ever had a load shift while crossing a ditch or heading up a hill, you understand the value of a stable platform. While it’s a more premium option, the investment in tandem axles is well worth it for anyone regularly hauling on challenging ground. It allows you to move loads more confidently and safely, which is a critical consideration on any farm.

Key Features: Axles, Decking, and Hitch Types

When you’re comparing wagons, a few key terms come up repeatedly. Understanding them helps you make a much better choice for your specific needs, rather than just buying what someone else recommends. It’s about matching the gear to your land and your tasks.

First, consider the axles. A single axle is simple and cost-effective, great for flat ground. A tandem axle or "walking beam" setup, as seen on the Horst, provides superior stability on rough terrain by allowing the wheels to move independently. For most small, flat properties, a single axle is perfectly fine. If you have hills or very bumpy pastures, a tandem is a much safer bet.

Next is the decking. Most running gears are sold without a deck, leaving the choice to you. Pressure-treated wood planks are the classic choice—they are affordable, easy to work with, and last for years. Steel mesh decking is another option, which is great for drainage and lighter weight but can be slippery and may not be suitable for hauling loose materials.

Finally, check the hitch type. Most small wagons use a simple pin hitch, which is a flat bar with a hole that drops over a pin on the tractor’s drawbar. Some utility carts may use a ball hitch, like you’d find on a truck. Make sure the wagon you choose is compatible with the hitch on your tractor or ATV.

Ultimately, the best hay wagon is the one that fits the scale of your operation and reduces your physical workload. Whether it’s a simple utility cart for a few bales or a sturdy running gear for a growing flock, the right choice is an investment in your own efficiency and well-being. Don’t just think about hauling hay; think about all the heavy lifting you do, and find the wagon that makes those jobs easier.