6 Best Budget Farm Scales For 5 Acres That Old-Timers Recommend

You can guess the weight of a tomato, but you can’t guess the right dosage of wormer for a sick goat. A reliable scale is one of the most overlooked tools on a small farm, separating careful management from costly guesswork. On five acres, you don’t need an industrial truck scale, but you need something that works when covered in dirt, rain, or both.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Hanging vs. Platform: Brecknell and My Weigh Basics

The first decision isn’t about brands, it’s about function. You need to choose between a hanging scale and a platform scale, and most small farms eventually find a use for both. A hanging scale is perfect for anything you can get a hook into or put in a sling—think hay nets, feed buckets, or a big sack of harvested onions. They are portable, simple, and take up virtually no storage space.

Platform scales, on the other hand, are for things that need a stable, flat surface. This is your go-to for weighing boxes of produce, sacks of feed you can’t easily lift, or an animal in a crate. The best ones have a low profile, making it easy to slide heavy items on and off. Brands like Brecknell have long been the standard for mechanical hanging scales, while companies like My Weigh offer robust and affordable digital platform options.

Your choice depends entirely on your primary task. If you’re constantly portioning out feed into buckets, a hanging scale is faster and more ergonomic. If your main job is weighing 40-pound boxes of potatoes for market, a platform scale will save your back. Don’t think of it as one or the other; think of it as which one you need to buy first.

Brecknell 235-6S: The Classic Mechanical Hanger

When you see a simple, rugged hanging scale with a big dial face, it’s probably a Brecknell or something inspired by it. The 235-6S is a classic for a reason. It requires no batteries, has a tough metal housing, and can handle being knocked around in the back of a truck or left in a dusty barn. It’s the definition of a tool you can rely on.

This scale shines in the field. You can hang it from a rafter, a tree branch, or the front-end loader to weigh things on the spot. It’s ideal for checking the weight of hay bales, ensuring feed sacks are full, or getting a quick total on a basket of harvested squash. The large, clear dial is easy to read, even when your hands are covered in mud.

The tradeoff is precision. You won’t be weighing things to the hundredth of an ounce with a mechanical dial. It’s for getting a solid, reliable weight in pounds or kilograms, not for calculating postage. But for 90% of the heavy lifting on a farm, that’s exactly what you need: a tool that is consistently close enough and will never die because you forgot to buy AA batteries.

Taylor 3070: A Simple, Reliable Produce Scale

Sometimes you need the opposite of the big Brecknell. The Taylor 3070 is a small, digital hanging scale that fits in your pocket. It’s what you grab when you need to weigh smaller, high-value items with precision, especially if you’re selling directly to customers.

Think of it as your market-prep scale. It’s perfect for ensuring every bunch of carrots weighs the same, portioning out garlic braids, or selling specialty mushrooms by the ounce. Because it’s digital, it has a "tare" feature, allowing you to hang a container, zero out the weight, and then get an exact measurement of what you add. This is impossible with a basic mechanical scale and is a game-changer for packaging goods for sale. It’s not for heavy-duty work, but it’s an indispensable tool for the business side of farming.

Pelouze SP5: The Durable Dial Scale for Harvest

The Pelouze SP5 is the quintessential farm stand scale. It’s a compact, mechanical platform scale with a slanted dial that’s incredibly durable and easy to read. Like the Brecknell hanger, its greatest strength is its simplicity—no cords, no batteries, and a rugged construction that can withstand years of use and abuse. You can hose it down, and it will still work tomorrow.

This is the workhorse for your harvest and packing shed. Use it for weighing out five-pound bags of potatoes, pricing pumpkins, or filling boxes of apples. Its operation is intuitive and fast, which is crucial when you have a line of customers or a mountain of produce to get through. The platform is small, but it’s perfect for the standard bushel basket or produce box.

While it lacks the pinpoint accuracy of a digital scale, it offers something more valuable in a busy environment: speed and indestructibility. It’s a tool built for repetition and volume. For anyone selling produce by the pound, a reliable dial scale like this is non-negotiable.

My Weigh HD-300: Versatile Heavy-Duty Platform

The My Weigh HD-300 bridges the gap between simple utility and serious capacity. This is a heavy-duty digital platform scale that can handle up to 300 pounds, making it incredibly versatile for a small farm. Its standout feature is the detached digital display connected by a cord. This means you can weigh a large, bulky box or a sack of feed without the item blocking your view of the numbers.

This scale is for the tasks that require both capacity and precision. Use it to accurately measure out feed rations, weigh large boxes for shipping, or check the weight of propane tanks. The digital interface provides a precise reading and includes a tare function, so you can place a large tub on the scale, zero it out, and measure exactly how much you’re adding. It’s a huge step up from guesswork.

The main consideration is that it requires power, either from batteries or an AC adapter. This tethers it to the barn or packing shed, unlike a mechanical scale you can throw in the truck. However, for indoor tasks where accuracy with heavy items is key, the HD-300 offers a level of functionality that mechanical scales just can’t match. It’s a modern workhorse.

Adam CPWplus 75: For Small Livestock Weigh-Ins

Once you have livestock, your need for an accurate scale becomes critical. The Adam CPWplus series is a step up in both price and capability, designed specifically for tasks like weighing animals. Its stainless steel platform is durable and easy to clean, which is essential when dealing with animals. More importantly, it features a "hold" or "animal weighing" mode.

This function is a game-changer. It averages the weight over a few seconds, capturing an accurate reading even if the animal is shifting its feet or wiggling. Trying to weigh a goat kid or a piglet on a regular scale is an exercise in frustration; the numbers will jump all over the place. An accurate weight is crucial for calculating medication dosages, tracking growth rates for breeding programs, and ensuring market-weight animals are ready.

While it’s a significant investment compared to a simple utility scale, the cost is easily justified by preventing one instance of incorrect medication or by optimizing your feed program. If you have goats, sheep, pigs, or other small livestock, a dedicated animal scale isn’t a luxury; it’s a fundamental tool for responsible animal husbandry.

AWS PS-25: A Portable Digital Utility Scale

Not every job requires a 300-pound capacity. The AWS PS-25 is a compact, portable digital scale that fills a specific niche: small, precise measurements anywhere on the farm. It runs on batteries, is about the size of a book, and can handle up to 25 pounds. It’s the perfect tool for tasks that demand more accuracy than a kitchen scale but more portability than a large platform scale.

Think of this as your go-to for mixing and measuring. Use it to weigh out precise amounts of seed for planting trays, measure amendments like bone meal or lime for custom soil mixes, or weigh packages for your farm’s online store. Its small size means you can easily take it from the greenhouse to the shipping bench.

This scale doesn’t replace a heavy-duty platform or a rugged hanging scale. Instead, it complements them. It handles the small, detail-oriented jobs that are just as important for a successful operation. For a small price, it brings a level of precision to your farm that can improve consistency in everything from seed starting to product shipping.

Choosing Your Scale: Pelouze Durability vs. Digital

Ultimately, the choice comes down to your farm’s philosophy and primary needs. There is no single "best" scale, only the best scale for the job at hand. The decision often boils down to a classic tradeoff: the bombproof, battery-free reliability of mechanical scales versus the precision and advanced features of digital models.

Old-timers swear by mechanical scales like the Pelouze platform or the Brecknell hanger for good reason. They are built to last a lifetime. You can leave them in a damp barn for a decade, and they will still give you a reliable weight. They represent an investment in a tool that will never fail you due to a dead battery or a fried circuit board. Their simplicity is their greatest strength.

However, a modern small farm often requires a level of precision that mechanical scales can’t offer. Digital scales with tare, hold, and unit conversion functions are essential for managing feed costs, administering correct medication dosages, and selling products with accurate, consistent weights. A digital scale like the My Weigh or Adam CPWplus is a tool for fine-tuning your operation and maximizing efficiency.

The smartest approach for a five-acre farm is to have one of each. Start with the one that solves your biggest problem right now. If you’re overwhelmed with weighing boxes of produce for market, get a Pelouze. If you’re struggling to get accurate weights on your goats, invest in an Adam. Over time, you’ll find that having both a rugged mechanical scale for the field and a precise digital one for the barn isn’t redundant—it’s just good farming.

A scale doesn’t grow your food or feed your animals, but it measures the results of your hard work. Choosing the right one isn’t about finding the most advanced technology; it’s about finding the most reliable tool for your specific jobs. Good measurement is the foundation of good management, and that’s what turns a hobby into a successful small farm.